Verdict is in! GUILTY of MURDER ONE - Hung Jury On Penalty Phase

JusticeJunkie · May 23, 2013

bREAKDOWN 8 FOR DEATH 4 FOR LIFE

doubt · May 23, 2013

8 to 4. death vs life.

i'm shocked there were 4.

wow.

TexMex · May 23, 2013

HLN says juror breakdown 8 for death 4 for life

MidwestMama · May 23, 2013

WOW!
It was 8 for death and 4 for life!

Pink Panther · May 23, 2013

MandyLeigh said:
Ponytail had the options of being taking away from the court house like all the others did and have been doing. He chose not to and instead to walk right in front of all the media, down the street, pick up a bus pass and take the bus. I do not blame the media for speaking to him and honestly I felt JVM was decent to him. She apologized at almost every question in case he felt it was innapropriate and then asked it. She didn't push it and went onto another.

If this guy wanted to be left alone and just go home he could have done so with the rest but by doing what he has done the entire world now know what he looks like and probably where he lives since he could have easily been followed.

I'm not trying to take one side or the other, it's just silly to expect the world to ignore him when his choice was to show the world his face directly out of the court room and right past the media.

ITA - You get what you give.

moo

moonshyne · May 23, 2013

8-4 - 8 in favor of death..I am surprised there was 4 opposed to death. I really thought it would be one maybe 2 holdouts max.

kpm · May 23, 2013

Vinnie just gave breakdown
8 for death
4 for life

atthelake · May 23, 2013

It was just announced 8 to 4 death to life.

Sent from my SCH-S720C using Tapatalk 2

polleypockets · May 23, 2013

jury count breakdown was 8 to 4 - so not just 1 hold out - 8 for death

ncgramma · May 23, 2013

Jury breakdown according to HLN: 8 for death -- 4 for life sentence

luv · May 23, 2013

Jodi Arias Jurors Leaving After Court
Jurors getting on the bus after a mistrial is declared in the penalty phase of the Jodi Arias murder trial.

http://www.azcentral.com/video/2405490606001

Except Juor #9??

.

gramcracker · May 23, 2013

stunned by the breakdown! (how did Vinnie get it?)

Pink Panther · May 23, 2013

doubt said:
8 to 4. death vs life.

i'm shocked there were 4.

wow.

Un-freek-in-believable.

Even the judge cried.

For shame.

moo

Berry · May 23, 2013

Jury 8 for Death 4 for Life. On HLN

Peachy Keen · May 23, 2013

I thought it would be much closer than 8-4!

snowcat · May 23, 2013

From Sheriff Joe Arpaio's Twitter feed a couple of hours ago:

Joe Arpaio ‏@RealSheriffJoe 2h
Arias is returning to Estrella Jail and will remain closed custody. No more interviews for her.

cackle · May 23, 2013

Mrs G Norris said:
Ok .. I'm going to play devils advocate, so please don't stone me to death ..

Mitigators could be: the text Travis sent Jodi calling her a sociopath, or her BPD or other aspects of their interaction for example .. the jury wasn't limited to mitigators put on by the defence at the end, they could take in the whole trial .. they were also instructed that voting for death was a personal decision .. they really don't have to give an answer at all, just that personally they thought that was the right sentence.

I'll play. I could see any of the below going through a juror's mind.

She's young, still has a chance to turn her life around and at least contribute in jail.

She doesn't seem to understand she's on trial for her life, her behavior is weird, I think she's mentally ill.

She's obviously isolated -- no one has spoken for her, even her family is off -- maybe she never had a chance to grow into a healthy adult. I can't give her the DP when her parents created her.

She's a vicious ***** who enjoys the limelight, I'll not give her the DP and deprive her of the spotlight the appeals will give her.

If I give her life it will at least end the ordeal for the Alexander's. Given all the death sentences being overturned maybe the DP will actually prolong their agony they have suffered enough.

I wanted murder 2 but compromised and gave in to Murder 1. I will now not give her death for a verdict I didn't really agree with.

ljs713 · May 23, 2013

I am surprised the jury was so split. I thought it would have been more for death.

kayice · May 23, 2013

7x11 for Jodi, no media interviews ...23 hours a day.

katiedid2 · May 23, 2013

MandyLeigh said:
Ponytail had the options of being taking away from the court house like all the others did and have been doing. He chose not to and instead to walk right in front of all the media, down the street, pick up a bus pass and take the bus. I do not blame the media for speaking to him and honestly I felt JVM was decent to him. She apologized at almost every question in case he felt it was innapropriate and then asked it. She didn't push it and went onto another.

If this guy wanted to be left alone and just go home he could have done so with the rest but by doing what he has done the entire world now know what he looks like and probably where he lives since he could have easily been followed.

I'm not trying to take one side or the other, it's just silly to expect the world to ignore him when his choice was to show the world his face directly out of the court room and right past the media.

i think so too i know emotions are flying high right now.

Verdict is in! GUILTY of MURDER ONE - Hung Jury On Penalty Phase

New Member

Former Member

Punishment is justice for the unjust.

Active Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

~ i am easily satisfied with the very best ~ wc

Former Member

New Member

New Member

Live Love Laugh ♥

Indentured Cat Servant

Well-Known Member

Gotch ya

Member

New Member

New Member

Member

Member

New Member

DNASolves

Online statistics

Forum statistics