Deceased/Not Found Canada - Alvin, 66, & Kathy Liknes, 53, Nathan O'Brien, 5, Calgary, 30 June 2014 - #8

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Status
Not open for further replies.
Where did the wood chipper idea come from? The Airdrie acreage is a working crop farm ... why would they need a wood chipper? Keeping in mind that this farm is owned and run by an elderly couple. Woodchippers are for heavily treed properties where there is no value in the trees. It seems to me that trees that are planted in the farming community would have a lot of value.

Someone else asked if it was a wood chipper. I said it looked like one but I couldn't see the chute. There are models that have detachable chutes. This is the pic with the piece of equipment next to the burn barrels:

http://www.websleuths.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=54529

Other suggestions were crop fertilizer or crop seeder

Pics of crop fertilizers:
https://www.google.ca/search?q="cro...WtyATM94DABg&ved=0CAYQ_AUoAQ&biw=1280&bih=615

Pics of crop seeders:
https://www.google.ca/search?site=i.....1ac.1.48.img..13.0.0.EMRp8lFc_I8&gws_rd=ssl

Pics of wood chippers:
https://www.google.ca/search?q="woo...AQ&biw=1280&bih=615#q="wood+chipper"&tbm=isch

In looking through the numerous pics at the above links, IMO the piece of equipment looks more like a wood chipper than it does the other two pieces of equipment ... unless there is another piece of equipment that others could find that looks like the one on the Garland farm.

PS: When you ask why would they need a wood chipper on that farm ... Pickton didn't need one on his.
 
This is breaking my heart. I kept having to walk away and cry, so it took a while to transcrive Hanson's interaction with the media today. This child is the same age as my grandson, and I know that I would die trying to protect him, and I think his grandmother would have done anything to save him. I've also posted it on the media/maps thread for this case.



Transcript of Calgary Police Service Media Availability re O'Brien/Liknes Case

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calga...-of-nathan-o-brien-and-grandparents-1.2706455

http://globalnews.ca/news/1449500/person-of-interest-in-missing-family-case-re-arrested/

This is a rough draft and all errors are my own.
This is not an official transcript, nor is it connected to any of the participants.

Police Chief Rick Hanson = RH

RH: I want to start this media availability by once again our sincere and heartfelt condolences to Jennifer and Rod O'Brien, and all members of the Liknes family. I cannot imagine how difficult and painful the last two weeks have been.

It's been two weeks to the day since the disappearance of Nathan O'Brien and Kathryn and Alvin Liknes. We have arrested a man in relation to what has been an extremely challenging and heart-wrenching investigation.

At approximately 1:30 a.m. today, officers arrested a man in the Airdrie area. He's currently in custody and charges of two counts of first degree murder and one count of second degree murder are pending. Until he has seen a justice of the peace, I am prohibited from releasing his identity.

The Amber Alert in relation to this file has been discontinued, however, the bodies of the three victims have not been found, and we continue to ask people to come forward with any information they may have. Most importantly, we ask rural property and business owners to please search their properties for anything suspicious.

We know that this community has been anxious for answers to an investigation that has gripped the city for the last two weeks. There are still many questions left to be answered, however, due to charges before the courts, I can't release those details, and the investigation continues.

We wish to thank the public and the media for their assistance. We have had more than nine hundred tips come in. This level of public support and engagement has never been seen before in previous investigations of this magnitude. I'd also like to acknowledge and thank the more than two hundred officers, analysts, and investigators who have worked this file nonstop for the past two weeks. This has included uniform members, specialty investigative units, and our search partners with Calgary Search and Rescue, and the R.C.M.P.

As this matter will now be before the courts, I'm limited in what I can say, but I will answer any questions that I can.

Reporter scrum.

RH: An investigation, as you will recall, this investigation started with very little information. You remember one of the first press conferences we had, it was referred to as a mystery. This investigation, led by Staff Sgt. [Doug] Andrus and Doug Anderson's teams of officers over in Major Crimes [Section] has been a painstaking investigation. It has been pursuing 900 tips plus investigative leads that have been forthcoming.

Our Forensic Crime Scenes Unit has been absolutely meticulous in going over the scene and any piece of evidence we have. This file has been built piece by piece by piece by piece. If somebody out there is thinking that there's one piece that's the smoking gun, one piece of information that has led to a break in the case, I'm here to tell you that has been a compilation of an immense investigation. And, during the course of this investigation, every day the investigators have met and discussed the information--the new information, the new leads, the new evidence--and assessed that information relative to this file.

And I don't want anybody to lose sight of the fact that there were three people that were missing on Day One. We have to assume that there's--whatever that is, whatever the small likelihood is, that someone, somewhere was keeping one of those three people alive. So we will always err to the side of caution, so we meticulously, the officers involved put this file together until yesterday afternoon, in a meeting with the Crown Prosecutor who was assigned to the case, and in reviewing all the evidence in its entirety, the decision was reached that this is now a homicide investigation, and that charges would be appropriate against the accused individual that will be named later.

Reporter: How do you know they're dead, sir?

RH: The preponderance of evidence is such that it has led our investigators to believe that they are dead. Hence, two counts of first degree murder, and one count of second degree murder.

Reporter: Can you set--can you extend the time line from the last media availability because then there was confidence that they were still believed to be alive. Can you talk about when the evidence came in where it turned out to be a murder investigation?

RH: What I can tell you is that every day evidence was coming in as our officers conducted their investigation, and every day it was assessed. And, until we had evidence that absolutely convinced all of us that the family was dead, that we were proceeding with the belief that if there was even a small likelihood that we would find somebody alive, we were gonna move our investigation based on that. As I'm sure anybody would if it was your family.

Yesterday, when they had their regular meeting to review the evidence, and assess that evidence, in consultation with the Crown, it was determined that it was clear at that point that this was no longer a missing persons investigation, this was a homicide investigation.

Reporter Scrum
Reporter: Where are you focusing your search efforts? Are you still searching the rural property in Airdrie? Are you still searching landfills?

RH: As you may have noted in my prepared statement, we are asking for the assistance of anybody who is on an acreage, anybody who's a business person, oil companies that have access to land to continue to be vigilant in looking for anything that's unusual. So, if somebody expects our search to be limited to one particular small area, we are not gonna limit ourselves to that. We are going to tell people out there be alert, be vigilant, if you see something you know wasn't right on your property, that it's different or that it could be suspicious, give us a call.

Reporter How confident are you that the evidence gathered in this case is very strong?

RH: Very confident.

Reporter: What is it that makes you feel confident?

RH: There is no single piece of evidence that will be what people would like to think is a smoking gun. Investigations of this magnitude are literally dozens and dozens, over two hundred people, each involved, officers each involved in doing a particular part of the investigation and meticulously pulling pieces of information together that supports a charge in this case. So, if you're looking for one piece of information, let me tell you that when the evidence comes forward you will see the meticulousness, the thoroughness of this investigation. And, I'm not going to jeopardize the file by rolling out individual pieces of evidence. Suffice to say that this, the officers in this case, the investigators, the support services, the different investigative teams, our covert assets, everybody, every officer, every person, every analyst involved in this investigation contributed in some small way to pulling these pieces of information together. They finally, as of yesterday, removed all doubt that it was a missing persons file and supported our now firmly held belief that it's a homicide, and led to the charges of first degree murder in two cases and second degree murder for a third charge.

Reporter: Was this based on evidence that was picked up Airdrie? You haven't quite said exactly what you…

RH: Well, what I have said is that I'm prohibited from saying who's been charged until the charges have been laid, and we expect those charges to be laid later on this afternoon. Once those charges have been laid, then we can identify the individual.

Reporter: Can you tell us if he's being co-operative?

RH: I can't say.

Reporter: Do police believe that these victims die right after they disappeared, or was there a lengthy period of time before they actually died?

RH: We are, we are putting a very complex case before the courts, a very complex case before the courts. We are not going to get into pieces and parts of information that could at some point in time jeopardize this prosecution down the road. You know, when the police do an investigation and charges are laid, that's only the beginning.

We have to be cognizant of the fact that the prosecution requires us to maintain carriage of that evidence until it's put before the courts. So, today, I know there's lots of questions that people have, lots of questions that you have, lots of questions that the people in the community have. The reality is, we cannot release, we cannot go through those parts of evidence, those pieces of evidence that have led to the charge. Suffice to say that we and the Crown are satisfied that the preponderance of evidence we've collected in its entirety supports the charges that will be laid later today.

Reporter: Are you looking at laying charges against anybody else?

RH: At this point in time, we're charging one person later on this afternoon.

Reporter: Are there any other charges charges possibly pending against him other than these three?

RH: I can tell you this. Any time there's a homicide of this magnitude, we would be remiss if we didn't look at every file that we have outstanding. At this point in time there are only those charges that relate to this file.

Reporter: Chief, what can you say about the circumstances of the arrest? Was this a product of investigators coming up with the evidence and deciding it was time to move, or was there a particular incident that sparked his apprehension. There were reports that he'd been removed from a premises, and so I was just wondering if you could add any clarity to that.

RH: The only clarity I can add is that the evidence that was collected allowed our officers to know, to form the belief, in consultation with the Crown, that the evidence was sufficient to arrest. And circumstances early this morning presented that opportunity to make the arrest, and that arrest was done at approximately 1:30 this morning.

Reporter: Do you have a better understanding of the motive? Or what you think may have motivated these murders?

RH: Motive? Anything to do with motive will be part of the evidence that's presented at trial.

Reporter: Are you looking for any other suspects?

RH: No.

Reporter: Can you elaborate on items or perhaps the blood samples that were taken from the Liknes home? I know you were waiting on test results, official results. Can you comment on the results if you have them?

RH: No, I can't.

Reporter: Why two counts of first degree and one count of third degree?

RH: OK. What I can explain to you is this. I'll explain generally why first degree murder charges are laid.

First degree murder charges are generally laid when you can show pre-intent.

Reporter: Pre-intent?

RH: Somebody formed the intent. And in second degree murder charges, that pre-intent, the intent to commit the act, may not be there in sufficient grounds to justify a first degree murder charge.

Reporter: Can you say who the charges relate to, in terms of are the first degree charges in relation to the grandparents and the second degree charges to child? Can you explain how that...

RH: The first degree murder charges will be laid on the Likneses. The second degree on the child.

Reporter: You've given condolences to the family. Do you have anything to say to them now? I mean, this is partially solved in their minds about, you know-- What can you say to them about finishing this off? It remains unclosed to them, I know.

RH: Sure it will be. Absolutely it will be. And our efforts will continue to be on the investigation. After charges are laid, it doesn't necessarily mean the investigation stops. There are other pieces of this file that have to be followed up, and our efforts to locate the bodies of the three deceased is obviously a big part of what we're hoping to do at some point in time be able to address.

Reporter: Are you still gonna hold the landfills that you are searching, or are you gonna just focus on Airdrie and asking people to look and check their property?

RH: Right now the investigators are still making investigative decisions on what they see as the best needs of the investigation, so they will make those calls as they see fit.

Reporter: How's the family doing?

RH: You know, it's extremely tragic. It's devastated them. We've kept them apprised the whole time. I think it's safe to say that even as the days went by there's always a hope, there's always a glimmer of hope. And, unfortunately, with the laying of the charges, we've taken that hope away from the family. So they are devastated.

Reporter: Chief, are you optimistic that you will find the bodies in this case?

RH: I'll always remain optimistic that we will be relentless in pursuing every lead. If we continue to get help from the community, if we continue to have folks that are alert to any changes or anything unusual that they see on their property, we remain optimistic that we may be able to put closure to that part of this file.

Reporter: Sorry, but when will the person who was arrested first appear in court?

RH: I can't say for sure, but the charges will be laid today so I don't know. I suspect it will be tomorrow, but I can't say 100% for sure.

Reporter: In light of any evidence that you have, is there any indication that the suspect would help you these bodies and help give the family some closure?

RH:: I can't speculate on, on what a suspect or an accused person may do or not do.

Reporter: Would that be what you would ultimately want?

RH: Ultimately what we want, is we want is to be able to find the bodies so that the family can have the final closure on this.

CPS PR: OK. Are there any other questions?

Reporter 1: Was he arrested at a motel?

Reporter 2: Have you spoken to Douglas Garland already? Can you give us any indication as his level, not just of co-operation but the idea that he may at some point tell you what happened to those bodies at ..

RH: You know, at this point in time we can't even confirm the identity of the person that was arrested. And, sorry, your question?

Reporter: Was he arrested at a hotel in Airdrie?

RH: It wasn't at a hotel in Airdrie. It was on property that was close to the, in the vicinity of the acreage.

CPS PR Officer: Any other questions?

RH: Are there any other questions from anybody? Thanks very much.
 
I remember reading one news source (I don't know if I can find it again quickly or otherwise), but it said that "an incident" occurred at the hotel, and he was asked to leave. And, the police chief in the news conference said, he was found "near" the Airdrie acreage IIRC.
Well, IMO, he's an idiot if he attempted to go back there at 130am.
 
yes but the LE also said they were still looking for the green truck when infact they already had it, so can't really take everything they said for what it's worth!

They would continue to ask for any other sightings that might be relevant until such time as it could be confirmed that the one they took from the farm is the one they were seeking.
 
Someone else asked if it was a wood chipper. I said it looked like one but I couldn't see the chute. There are models that have detachable chutes. This is the pic with the piece of equipment next to the burn barrels:

http://www.websleuths.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=54529

Other suggestions were crop fertilizer or crop seeder

Pics of crop fertilizers:
https://www.google.ca/search?q="cro...WtyATM94DABg&ved=0CAYQ_AUoAQ&biw=1280&bih=615

Pics of crop seeders:
https://www.google.ca/search?site=i.....1ac.1.48.img..13.0.0.EMRp8lFc_I8&gws_rd=ssl

Pics of wood chippers:
https://www.google.ca/search?q="woo...AQ&biw=1280&bih=615#q="wood+chipper"&tbm=isch

In looking through the numerous pics at the above links, IMO the piece of equipment looks more like a wood chipper than it does the other two pieces of equipment ... unless there is another piece of equipment that others could find that looks like the one on the Garland farm.

PS: When you ask why would they need a wood chipper on that farm ... Pickton didn't need one on his.
Picton had pigs.
 
Thank you wendiesan for your transcription. xo
 
***Note*** This is from early on in the investigation..dated July 9, 2014
http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/c...Amber+Alert+police+update/10011825/story.html

Look at point #3

. They still consider the disappearance a missing persons case.

Police remain optimistic that they will find Nathan O’Brien and the Liknes couple alive.

“We have no indication whatsoever to indicate anything other than that, so the investigation continues,” Brookwell said. He acknowledged that the violent struggle that occurred at the Liknes home before the disappearance is “a concern,” but said police remain hopeful.

Its just public relations. As per today's press conference.

Reporter: Can you set--can you extend the time line from the last media availability because then there was confidence that they were still believed to be alive. Can you talk about when the evidence came in where it turned out to be a murder investigation?

RH: What I can tell you is that every day evidence was coming in as our officers conducted their investigation, and every day it was assessed. And, until we had evidence that absolutely convinced all of us that the family was dead, that we were proceeding with the belief that if there was even a small likelihood that we would find somebody alive, we were gonna move our investigation based on that. As I'm sure anybody would if it was your family.
 
What the the heck is the "smoking gun"? A body, witness, weapon?
 
Rick Hansen is genuinely such a good guy and family man I can't believe how well he was able to keep himself together during that conference. All the service workers on this case deserve a well needed vacation after a not so happy ending.
 
http://www.discoverairdrie.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=8360&Itemid=176

"As the news of a missing persons case becoming a homicide investigation, people are taking to social media to express their feelings. There are many wishing they could do something to try and help the families of Nathan O'Brien, and Alvin and Kathy Liknes.

[modsnip]
A meeting is being held tonight at the Toad n Turtle at 7pm. Green says a retired RCMP officer is helping the group, providing them with maps, and had contacted Calgary City Police and local RCMP on behalf of the group.

[modsnip]

There is a facebook page the group has created specifically for this, called "Help us bring some closure to the O'Brien & Liknes Family.. SEARCH AIRDRIE"



- See more at: http://www.discoverairdrie.com/inde...=view&id=8360&Itemid=176#sthash.gaJ1aFxG.dpuf
 
:modstop:


Do not post gruesome forensic details without a LINK. Link it up or keep the rumor to yourself until MSM/LE reveal it.

Salem
 
Someone else asked if it was a wood chipper. I said it looked like one but I couldn't see the chute. There are models that have detachable chutes. This is the pic with the piece of equipment next to the burn barrels:

http://www.websleuths.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=54529

Other suggestions were crop fertilizer or crop seeder

Pics of crop fertilizers:
https://www.google.ca/search?q="cro...WtyATM94DABg&ved=0CAYQ_AUoAQ&biw=1280&bih=615

Pics of crop seeders:
https://www.google.ca/search?site=i.....1ac.1.48.img..13.0.0.EMRp8lFc_I8&gws_rd=ssl

Pics of wood chippers:
https://www.google.ca/search?q="woo...AQ&biw=1280&bih=615#q="wood+chipper"&tbm=isch

In looking through the numerous pics at the above links, IMO the piece of equipment looks more like a wood chipper than it does the other two pieces of equipment ... unless there is another piece of equipment that others could find that looks like the one on the Garland farm.

PS: When you ask why would they need a wood chipper on that farm ... Pickton didn't need one on his.


I don't think a wood chipper on a farm is odd at all.

Trees, brush, branches, leaves, etc... make really good mulch.
 
Took a nap, woke up with this case on my mind. Could the perp have been caught while attempting to go somewhere to commit suicide?? Perhaps her knew what evidence was left, what cops could have found, and fled with the intention??

I've heard it said many times that a perp often returns to the scene of the crime. Could have been checking to see if everything was still hidden, or to further hide evidence. In this case, I would think LE could continue to trail him, and see where he leads them. Maybe he did, and we just haven't been told. If not, I wonder if LE did believe he was going to self harm so had to act when they did, rather than wait to see what he was up to.

I still can't imagine the shock, the horror, the pain that each victim's family and loved ones are experiencing. Yes even the perps family, as they are victims to his actions. His sister being brought into such a horrific crime involving her family as well. Just terrible. All through no fault of their own. That's the worse! Well, I guess the murders are the worse, but you know what I mean. To be thrown into such a tragedy through no actions of your own. Maybe because I have one brother, and his birthday is today that it's hitting me hard today. My brother lives on the opposite coast than I do, and thus through time, and distance, we aren't as close as we once were. But he's still my brother!!! I just can't imagine!!

Maybe they weren't close. Maybe they didn't even speak anymore. I don't know. But I do have empathy for her.

I was also thinking about prior posts today (really before the latest arrest happened) when lots of discussion about the businesses, bankruptcy, etc., were being discussed. While we probably won't know much more until trial, I've been thinking about this lots. I wonder if any of the family truly knew the financial status, and what was going on with the move etc. I personally have no idea how much money parents do or don't have. I know they aren't wanting for anything, but they live a very simple life with their home, and vehicles paid for. I don't think they are monetarily rich, though they are rich in many other ways. But I truly don't know. I do know they've never filed bankruptcy, but truly if they had at some point, I don't know that I would have known. Maybe it's just my family, but truly finances aren't discussed. Beyond knowing my parents have enough for their burials if something happens, it's just not a conversation, even when prompted. Even in talking about their future, etc. Maybe it was the same with the Liknes couple?

They could have been telling the truth, saying we're retiring, and would like to live our retirement. Think we'll go enjoy Mexico for awhile, and relax and reap the benefits of retirement and having worked our lives. Many people do downgrade their homes to smaller size when the extra rooms just aren't needed and more to keep clean. So it's very possible that's what they were doing. Selling their larger home for a retirement home that would cost less, and allow them travel and sight see. My parents have even talked of selling their place and renting a smaller place because neither is able to farm anymore, and have no desire to have anything but their garden for fresh veggies. Even that has decreased in size, and Mom says her canning days are over, and gave me her canning jars, and pressure canners.

It's also possible they didn't have a strict schedule or itinerary to when they were going to Mexico, when they were coming back etc. No need for such if retired and just wanting to travel some.

Have we actually found where they had bought another home? Or were they just thinking of moving to certain area and looking for home? Maybe they were tired of the harsh winters and wanted to secure a warmer place to stay in the winter, but didn't want to cut all ties to Canada because they knew they still had kids and grandkids that couldn't afford to leave their jobs, and security to move with them to Mexico.

I don't know how close the communities are either. Meaning how close your neighbors are to you, etc. Maybe they didn't feel it was really any of the neighbor's business where they moving, why, when, etc. If their plans hadn't been set in stone, then maybe whoever happened to ask go the answer as the Liknes knew at that time. Subject to change as they felt or wanted. Nothing sinister in different folks knowing different things, just floating dreams or thoughts and sharing what they felt on that day. Sadly, now we may never know. They didn't get to live their retirement and travel. They didn't get to watch the grandkids grow up, graduate, etc. Little did they know they'd never leave their home and enjoy another day. Just thinking of all the dreams and thoughts they had that last week, preparing for a new life, hopes high, dreams about to be lived, not realizing the evil that was lurking for the perfect storm to attack. Those dreams shattered. It's just unbelievable how lives can change so quickly.

And no matter how many crimes I've followed....the shock factor is there each time. Even when things look grim, I try to reach for that last bit of hope to hang onto. Sometimes hope shines through, and the missing are found, and other times, no amount of hope seems sufficient.

ALL JMO...as I ramble through my thoughts, and grieve for a family I never met, but shouldn't have died.
 
Also IMO if the hotel kicked him out upon police request my reasoning behind that was they didn't want to cause a commotion or there could have been kids at the hotel during that time they might have just been being safe not knowing how he was going to react.

He was picked up at 1:30 AM.
 
If there was enough blood and other body matter found in the home.. why would the police say in the first week that they are optimistic that they could find them alive?

The homicide unit was involved on June 30. The medical examiner was at the house on the same day. I think there was hope that someone would be found alive, but I don't think it was ever expected that all three would be found alive. There was a violent event that resulted in medical distress, and police knew that right away.
 
Someone else asked if it was a wood chipper. I said it looked like one but I couldn't see the chute. There are models that have detachable chutes. This is the pic with the piece of equipment next to the burn barrels:

http://www.websleuths.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=54529

Other suggestions were crop fertilizer or crop seeder

Pics of crop fertilizers:
https://www.google.ca/search?q="cro...WtyATM94DABg&ved=0CAYQ_AUoAQ&biw=1280&bih=615

Pics of crop seeders:
https://www.google.ca/search?site=i.....1ac.1.48.img..13.0.0.EMRp8lFc_I8&gws_rd=ssl

Pics of wood chippers:
https://www.google.ca/search?q="woo...AQ&biw=1280&bih=615#q="wood+chipper"&tbm=isch

In looking through the numerous pics at the above links, IMO the piece of equipment looks more like a wood chipper than it does the other two pieces of equipment ... unless there is another piece of equipment that others could find that looks like the one on the Garland farm.

PS: When you ask why would they need a wood chipper on that farm ... Pickton didn't need one on his.

If that is a wood chipper, and if a body went through it, it would have been collected as evidence, and there would have been evidence all over the place.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
230
Guests online
299
Total visitors
529

Forum statistics

Threads
608,763
Messages
18,245,494
Members
234,441
Latest member
DizzyKat
Back
Top