Still Missing KY - Crystal Rogers, 35, Bluegrass Parkway, 3 July 2015 #4 *arrest in 2023*

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
When we find out if their trials will be separate - I shall keep all of them on one summary.

Monday, July 8th:
*Motions Hearing (for Houck) (@ 9am ET) - KY – Crystal Maria Rogers (35) (reported missing July 3, 2015; car (with flat tire) was found July 5, 2015 on Bluegrass Parkway near mile marker 14 with keys in ignition & her belongings (phone & purse) in car, Bardstown). – *Brooks William Houck (33 @ time of crime/41/now 42) arrested, charged & indicted (9/27/23) & arraigned (10/5/23) with felony murder & tampering with physical evidence. Plead not guilty. Bond $10M CASH Only! Reduction of bond (to $500K) denied (10/9/23). KY Supreme Court denied (3/12/24) review of bond reduction. Was transferred (9/27/23) from Nelson County jail to Hardin County Detention Center. Was transferred (12/13/23) to Oldham County Detention Center. Nelson County
*Joseph Stephen Lee Allen Lawson (24 @ time of crime/32/now 33) arrested, indicted & charged (7/24/23) with criminal conspiracy to commit murder & charged (6/21/23) with complicity in tampering with physical evidence. Bond $50K unsecured bond (tampering) & $550K Cash bond (conspiracy). Bond reduced (2/12/24) to $250K Cash bond. Plead not guilty. Held in Grayson County Kentucky Detention Center. Nelson County
*Steven Eugene Lawson (48 @ time of crime/53) indicted, arrested & charged (12/7/23) & arraigned (12/21/23) with conspiracy to commit murder & tampering with physical evidence. Plead not guilty. $500K Cash only bond. Bond reduced to $250K (1/9/24). He's currently incarcerated in Harrison County, IN. Lawson was serving time at the Kentucky State Reformatory for a previous conviction, but that time will be served out in the coming weeks. He was moved to the Grayson County Detention Center this morning (5/3/24) & is currently in custody. Nelson County
Trial set to begin on 2/10/25. Trial will be held in Christian County.
Nelson Circuit Court Judge Charles Simms III presiding. Special prosecutor Shane Young. Houck’s defense attorneys Brian Butler, Michael Denbow & Jennifer Henry Jackson. S. Lawson’s defense attorney Theodore Lavit & J. Lawson’s defense attorney Kevin Coleman.

Case & Court info from 7/23/20 (Houck & J. Lawson) & from 12/7/23 (S Lawson) thru 5/21/24 reference post #519 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...y-3-july-2015-4-arrest-in-2023.690447/page-26

6/4/24 Docket update: Defendant Houck's Sur-Reply in Opposition to Commonwealth's Motion to consolidate filed. Houck submitted a 40-page motion rebuffing Prosecutor Shane Young's request to consolidate the three defendants into a singular joint trial & sharing previously unreleased details about Steve Lawson's testimony to investigators, which his defense attorney has said was given under an unkept promise of immunity. Houck's motion provides excerpts of transcribed interviews that allegedly took place between Lawson & police, but an audio copy is not included in court documents. Motions hearing on 6/13/24 for all.
6/13/24 Update: Judge Charles Simms is considering the motion of whether to drop the charges against Lawson after the hearing that lasted a little over an hour. Thursday’s hearing focused on the motion to dismiss charges against Lawson based on the offer of immunity. “As I take it, there’s no agreement that was ever in writing. Is that is that correct? So everything was an oral situation?” Simms said. The commonwealth’s attorney, special prosecutor Shane Young, confirmed the offer of oral immunity was conditional on whether Lawson was 100% truthful & had no omissions. The Commonwealth provided four audio & video clips supporting their argument that Lawson was not 100% truthful. Judge Charles Simms did not rule on dismissing the charges against Lawson, nor what testimony wouldn’t be allowed at trial. A ruling is expected in the coming days. Neither Houck or Joseph Lawson were in court. A hearing on the state’s motion to consolidate the trial in relation to Houck’s objection will be held on 7/8/24 @ 9am.
6/14/24 Update: In an investigative document released on Friday, Steve Lawson told investigators that his son & a man named Jeremy Thompson were digging on the farm on Thompson Hill Road within five days of Rogers' disappearance in 2015. The document, filed in Nelson Circuit Court, appears to be additional evidence submitted to bolster the prosecution's argument against Steve Lawson getting immunity for cooperating with investigators. The newly-released document confirms that a dig site, where WAVE News crews saw authorities digging as part of a “murder investigation” in Nelson County, has been confirmed as a possible location for the body of Crystal Rogers.
7/3/24 Update: Steve Lawson: An attempt to have the case against him tossed out failed on Wednesday after a judge denied Lawson's dismissal motion. Judge Charles Simms denied Lawson’s motion to dismiss. In the order, Simms wrote that while an immunity agreement was made during Steven's discussions with law enforcement, Steven made “wildly inconsistent” statements to investigators & therefore breached the agreement by being untruthful. However, Steve Lawson's grand jury testimonies in June & September 2023 are admissible because there were no discussions of plea negotiations or immunity during these proceedings. Therefore, Steve Lawson did not have clear or reasonable belief to think he was negotiating a plea at that point, Simms ruled. One inconsistency Simms pointed to in his order was Steven's statements to investigators about a call between him & Houck on the night of Rogers’ disappearance. Steven at one point told authorities that he made the call to inquire about an apartment for his daughter, according to the order. He later told a Nelson County Grand Jury that the call was to “let Brooks Houck know the job is done,” the order read. Simms also ruled Wednesday that Lawson would be able to decide if he wants to exclude statements he made in several interviews he did with law enforcement. Lawson is set to appear in court on 8/8/24 to inform the judge whether he wishes to exclude the interviews in question.
7/7/24 Update: Joseph Lawson is not scheduled to appear in court on Monday. Prosecutors have argued the men should stand trial together because they're facing the same charges & allegedly worked with each other. Prosecutors are questioning why Steve Lawson called Houck after Rogers went missing in 2015. Butler argues he "fabricated the entire story" of what happened after she went missing because he was "threatened, coerced & promised immunity by investigators." Joseph Lawson's next hearing is scheduled for later this month.
Thank you for this timeline update. Good work keeping it up. This is very helpful to those like me, that have seen most everything on this case out there. We don't always have much time to look it up when there is updates. It helps me avoid wasting time catching up.
 
Thursday, July 18th:
*Motions Hearing (for J. Lawson) (@ 9am ET) - KY – Crystal Maria Rogers (35) (reported missing July 3, 2015; car (with flat tire) was found July 5, 2015 on Bluegrass Parkway near mile marker 14 with keys in ignition & her belongings (phone & purse) in car, Bardstown). – *Brooks William Houck (33 @ time of crime/41/now 42) arrested, charged & indicted (9/27/23) & arraigned (10/5/23) with felony murder & tampering with physical evidence. Plead not guilty. Bond $10M Cash Only! Reduction of bond (to $500K) denied (10/9/23). KY Supreme Court denied (3/12/24) review of bond reduction. Was transferred (9/27/23) from Nelson County jail to Hardin County Detention Center. Was transferred (12/13/23) to Oldham County Detention Center. Nelson County
*Joseph Stephen Lee Allen Lawson (24 @ time of crime/32/now 33) arrested, indicted & charged (7/24/23) with criminal conspiracy to commit murder & charged (6/21/23) with complicity in tampering with physical evidence. Bond $50K unsecured bond (tampering) & $550K Cash bond (conspiracy). Bond reduced (2/12/24) to $250K Cash bond. Plead not guilty. Held in Grayson County Kentucky Detention Center. Nelson County
*Steven Eugene Lawson (48 @ time of crime/53) indicted, arrested & charged (12/7/23) & arraigned (12/21/23) with conspiracy to commit murder & tampering with physical evidence. Plead not guilty. $500K Cash only bond. Bond reduced to $250K (1/9/24). He's currently incarcerated in Harrison County, IN. Lawson was serving time at the Kentucky State Reformatory for a previous conviction, but that time will be served out in the coming weeks. He was moved to the Grayson County Detention Center this morning (5/3/24) & is currently in custody. Nelson County
Trial set to begin on 2/10/25. Trial will be held in Christian County.
Nelson Circuit Court Judge Charles Simms III presiding. Special prosecutor Shane Young. Houck’s defense attorneys Brian Butler, Michael Denbow & Jennifer Henry Jackson. S. Lawson’s defense attorney Theodore Lavit & J. Lawson’s defense attorney Kevin Coleman.

Case & Court info from 7/23/20 (Houck & J. Lawson) & from 12/7/23 (S Lawson) thru 6/14/24 reference post #533 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...y-3-july-2015-4-arrest-in-2023.690447/page-27

7/3/24 Update: Steve Lawson: An attempt to have the case against him tossed out failed on Wednesday after a judge denied Lawson's dismissal motion. Judge Charles Simms denied Lawson’s motion to dismiss. In the order, Simms wrote that while an immunity agreement was made during Steven's discussions with law enforcement, Steven made “wildly inconsistent” statements to investigators & therefore breached the agreement by being untruthful. However, Steve Lawson's grand jury testimonies in June & September 2023 are admissible because there were no discussions of plea negotiations or immunity during these proceedings. Therefore, Steve Lawson did not have clear or reasonable belief to think he was negotiating a plea at that point, Simms ruled. One inconsistency Simms pointed to in his order was Steven's statements to investigators about a call between him & Houck on the night of Rogers’ disappearance. Steven at one point told authorities that he made the call to inquire about an apartment for his daughter, according to the order. He later told a Nelson County Grand Jury that the call was to “let Brooks Houck know the job is done,” the order read. Simms also ruled Wednesday that Lawson would be able to decide if he wants to exclude statements he made in several interviews he did with law enforcement. Lawson is set to appear in court on 8/8/24 to inform the judge whether he wishes to exclude the interviews in question.
7/7/24 Update: Joseph Lawson is not scheduled to appear in court on Monday. Prosecutors have argued the men should stand trial together because they're facing the same charges & allegedly worked with each other. Prosecutors are questioning why Steve Lawson called Houck after Rogers went missing in 2015. Butler argues he "fabricated the entire story" of what happened after she went missing because he was "threatened, coerced & promised immunity by investigators." Joseph Lawson's next hearing is scheduled on 7/18/24.
7/8/24 Update: Houck: Special Prosecutor Shane Young has filed a motion to try all three men in one trial, claiming they worked together to kill Rogers & cover up her death. Brian Butler, Houck's defense attorney, has objected to the motion to combine the trials. Butler argues if the trial is combined, the jury will not see the “unsavory tactics law enforcement employed during their interviews of the Lawsons that ultimately resulted in false confessions.” Judge Charles Simms heard arguments from both sides. The judge announced Monday that he will wait to hear from Joseph Lawson's attorneys on July 18 before making a decision on separate trials.
For more info see posts #535 to 537 here:

https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...y-3-july-2015-4-arrest-in-2023.690447/page-27
 

Shay McAlister 1h​


Crystal Rogers Courtdate- Joseph Lawson is appearing by video for court today. His attorneys and the prosecutor are present in the courtroom. This is status conference, which gives the attorneys the chance to talk and then update the judge.

No decisions made today- next court date will be August 8th- Joseph and Steve Lawson will appear together for that one.
 
Here's an article that I can access... :)


July 17, 2024
One of the defendants charged in the murder of Crystal Rogers appeared in Nelson Circuit Court briefly Thursday afternoon.
[.....]
Nelson Circuit Judge Charles Simms III was to hear Joseph Lawson’s motion to separate his trial from that of co-defendants Brooks Houck and his father, Steve Lawson.

The attorneys agreed to delay hearing the motion to separate Joseph Lawson’s trial from his co-defendants until Aug. 8, 2024.

On that date, Joseph Lawson’s father, Steve Lawson will advise the court of his decision of whether to allow or disallow his statements to investigators that were made while they were offering him an immunity agreement.
[.....]
According to Kentucky Rules of Evidence, statements made by a defendant during discussions regarding immunity or other plea agreement are only admissible in court if the defendant allows them to be used in court.

Simms said that Steve Lawson will enter his decision at the Aug. 8 hearing. That decision is likely to impact the other co-defendants’ arguments for separate trials.
[.....]
Simms has yet to rule on a motion for a change of venue for the trial, which is anticipated to take place next year. The prosecutors and defense attorneys have agreed on a new venue at the Christian County justice center in Hopkinsville.
 
@arielilane - is there an update for Houck's next hearing? TIA!

Hi @Niner, no new update since BH's last appearance on July 8 when he argues for separate trials in Crystal Rogers case. BH is being held on a $10 million bond.



bbm

LOUISVILLE, Ky. (WAVE) - Brooks Houck, the former boyfriend of Crystal Rogers, was back in a Nelson County courthouse on Monday. Houck and his attorneys appeared for a hearing, as Houck tried to get his case separated from the other two men charged in connection to Rogers’ disappearance and presumed murder.

...

On Monday, his attorney Brian Butler argued against a joint trial with a father-son duo, Joseph and Steven Lawson. Butler said trying the three men together would require jurors to do “mental gymnastics” to keep up with everything. He also called Steven Lawson a liar and said if they are tried together, they will have to play more than 20 hours of police interviews.

...

According to court documents filed back in May, Houck recruited the father and son duo to help “get rid of” Rogers. Steven Lawson filed a motion to have his charges dropped, saying he cooperated with investigators and in exchange, he was supposed to be given immunity. A judge dismissed that motion, saying he lied too many times during interviews with police, prosecutors and the grand jury and would not be given immunity.

Prosecutors want to try all three men together, but Houck’s attorneys don’t want that to happen. The judge put that discussion on hold until Steven Lawson decides if he wants to exclude the police interviews or use them as part of his defense, as he’s previously indicated. That decision is to be made by August 8.

...

Full article at link...


Updated: Jul. 8, 2024 at 5:50 PM EDT
 
Hi @Niner, no new update since BH's last appearance on July 8 when he argues for separate trials in Crystal Rogers case. BH is being held on a $10 million bond.



bbm

LOUISVILLE, Ky. (WAVE) - Brooks Houck, the former boyfriend of Crystal Rogers, was back in a Nelson County courthouse on Monday. Houck and his attorneys appeared for a hearing, as Houck tried to get his case separated from the other two men charged in connection to Rogers’ disappearance and presumed murder.

...

On Monday, his attorney Brian Butler argued against a joint trial with a father-son duo, Joseph and Steven Lawson. Butler said trying the three men together would require jurors to do “mental gymnastics” to keep up with everything. He also called Steven Lawson a liar and said if they are tried together, they will have to play more than 20 hours of police interviews.

...

According to court documents filed back in May, Houck recruited the father and son duo to help “get rid of” Rogers. Steven Lawson filed a motion to have his charges dropped, saying he cooperated with investigators and in exchange, he was supposed to be given immunity. A judge dismissed that motion, saying he lied too many times during interviews with police, prosecutors and the grand jury and would not be given immunity.

Prosecutors want to try all three men together, but Houck’s attorneys don’t want that to happen. The judge put that discussion on hold until Steven Lawson decides if he wants to exclude the police interviews or use them as part of his defense, as he’s previously indicated. That decision is to be made by August 8.

...

Full article at link...


Updated: Jul. 8, 2024 at 5:50 PM EDT

Thanks for the answer on Houck's next hearing. Guess we wait until 8/8 for S. Lawson to decide...
 

Shay McAlister 2h​

·

Both Steve and Joey Lawson are expected in court tomorrow in the Crystal Rogers case. Here's what we know about the hearing... and this is very 'in the weeds' so stick with me...
  • This is a status hearing in regards to the request for separate trials
  • Judge Charles Simms wants to know if Steve Lawson plans to waive evidentiary protection before he makes his decision on the request for separate trials
  • If Steve Lawson chooses to waive evidentiary protection, that means the prosecutor can include statements he made during police interviews last year, and Joey and Brooks Houck's attorneys will make a case that those comments incriminate them so they should be able to cross examine Steve (which would require separate trials)
  • If Steve Lawson chooses not to waive evidentiary protection, the comments will be excluded from trial and the judge may decide the separate trials are not necessary
  • Steve Lawson's attorney filed documents in court today that indicate he doesn't believe they should have to make this decision so far ahead of trial, but that if the judge forces them to make a decision, he WILL NOT waive evidentiary protection
  • With that in mind- the judge very well could rule on separate trials tomorrow. Judges very rarely agree to try defendants separately because of the burden it puts on the victim's family to go through multiple trials and the burden on taxpayers who pay for travel expenses to move the court personnel to another county.
Court starts tomorrow at 1:30pm in Nelson County
 
Thursday, August 8th:
*Status Hearing (for J. & S. Lawson) (@ 1:30pm ET) - KY – Crystal Maria Rogers (35) (reported missing July 3, 2015; car (with flat tire) was found July 5, 2015 on Bluegrass Parkway near mile marker 14 with keys in ignition & her belongings (phone & purse) in car, Bardstown). – *Brooks William Houck (33 @ time of crime/41/now 42) arrested, charged & indicted (9/27/23) & arraigned (10/5/23) with felony murder & tampering with physical evidence. Plead not guilty. Bond $10M Cash Only! Reduction of bond (to $500K) denied (10/9/23). KY Supreme Court denied (3/12/24) review of bond reduction. Was transferred (9/27/23) from Nelson County jail to Hardin County Detention Center. Was transferred (12/13/23) to Oldham County Detention Center. Nelson County
*Joseph Stephen Lee Allen Lawson (24 @ time of crime/32/now 33) arrested, indicted & charged (7/24/23) with criminal conspiracy to commit murder & charged (6/21/23) with complicity in tampering with physical evidence. Bond $50K unsecured bond (tampering) & $550K Cash bond (conspiracy). Bond reduced (2/12/24) to $250K Cash bond. Plead not guilty. Held in Grayson County Kentucky Detention Center. Nelson County
*Steven Eugene Lawson (48 @ time of crime/53) indicted, arrested & charged (12/7/23) & arraigned (12/21/23) with conspiracy to commit murder & tampering with physical evidence. Plead not guilty. $500K Cash only bond. Bond reduced to $250K (1/9/24). He's currently incarcerated in Harrison County, IN. Lawson was serving time at the Kentucky State Reformatory for a previous conviction, but that time will be served out in the coming weeks. He was moved to the Grayson County Detention Center this morning (5/3/24) & is currently in custody. Nelson County
Trial set to begin on 2/10/25. Trial will be held in Christian County.
Nelson Circuit Court Judge Charles Simms III presiding. Special prosecutor Shane Young. Houck’s defense attorneys Brian Butler, Michael Denbow & Jennifer Henry Jackson. S. Lawson’s defense attorney Theodore Lavit & J. Lawson’s defense attorney Kevin Coleman.

Case & Court info from 7/23/20 (Houck & J. Lawson) & from 12/7/23 (S Lawson) thru 7/7/24 reference post #544 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...y-3-july-2015-4-arrest-in-2023.690447/page-28

7/8/24 Update: Houck: Special Prosecutor Shane Young has filed a motion to try all three men in one trial, claiming they worked together to kill Rogers & cover up her death. Brian Butler, Houck's defense attorney, has objected to the motion to combine the trials. Butler argues if the trial is combined, the jury will not see the “unsavory tactics law enforcement employed during their interviews of the Lawsons that ultimately resulted in false confessions.” Judge Charles Simms heard arguments from both sides. The judge announced Monday that he will wait to hear from Joseph Lawson's attorneys on July 18 before making a decision on separate trials.
For more info see posts #535 to 537 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...y-3-july-2015-4-arrest-in-2023.690447/page-27

7/18/24 Update: Joseph Lawson appeared by video for court today. His attorneys & the prosecutor were present in the courtroom. This was status conference, which gave the attorneys the chance to talk & then update the judge. Nelson Circuit Judge Charles Simms III was to hear Joseph Lawson’s motion to separate his trial from that of co-defendants Brooks Houck & his father, Steve Lawson. The attorneys agreed to delay hearing the motion to separate Joseph Lawson’s trial from his co-defendants until 8/8/24. On that date, Joseph Lawson’s father, Steve Lawson will advise the court of his decision of whether to allow or disallow his statements to investigators that were made while they were offering him an immunity agreement. According to Kentucky Rules of Evidence, statements made by a defendant during discussions regarding immunity or other plea agreement are only admissible in court if the defendant allows them to be used in court. Judge Simms said that Steve Lawson will enter his decision at the 8/8/24 hearing. That decision is likely to impact the other co-defendants’ arguments for separate trials. Judge Simms has yet to rule on a motion for a change of venue for the trial, which is anticipated to take place next year. The prosecutors & defense attorneys have agreed on a new venue at the Christian County justice center in Hopkinsville. Next court date will be 8/8/24 for Joseph & Steve Lawson will appear together for that one.
7/20/24 Update: Houck: Nancy Grace episode in which Houck spoke with Nancy on HLN has been entered into evidence.
 
BARDSTOWN, Ky. — A father-and-son duo charged in the death of Bardstown mother Crystal Rogers are back in court on Thursday.
Joseph and Steve Lawson are charged with complicity to murder and tampering with physical evidence in Rogers' unsolved disappearance. Their charges stem from an incident over the Fourth of July weekend in 2015, the same weekend Rogers was reported missing.

Thursday's hearing in Nelson County is a status hearing in regards to their request for a separate trial.
WHAS11's Shay McAlister will be in the courtroom during the hearing, which begins at 1:30 p.m.

Updated: 12:27 PM EDT August 8, 2024

What to Expect​

Judge Charles Simms wants to know if Steve Lawsons plans to waive evidentiary protection before he makes his decision on the request for sperate trials.

If Steve Lawson does chose to waive those protections, it means the prosecutor can include statements he made during police interviews last year.



 

Shay McAlister 15m​

Steve Lawson just fired his attorney Ted Lavit, accusing him of working with Brooks Houck’s attorneys behind his back.

Here’s what happened:
Lawson told the judge his counsel has been ineffective and he wants a public defender

The prosecutor echoed his concerns, saying “I don’t know what’s going on here. It’s disturbing.”

In response, Ted Lavit said “I have done my best without any conflict whatsoever.”

The judge ended court, asking for a public defender to be here in 2 weeks to represent Steve Lawson.

Next court date set for August 22nd at 1:30pm

454502101_998802141930027_4633397118564778821_n.jpg

All of this is credit to Shay McAlister's facebook page.
 
Last edited:
@WLKYLaurenAdams

This afternoon Steve Lawson - 1 of 3 men charged in connection to the murder of Crystal Rogers- fired his lawyer. The judge delayed today’s hearing but says he wants to see Lawson back August 22, and with a new lawyer, so that February trial date will stand.


The judge delayed Thursday's hearing and said he wants to see him back in court on Aug. 22 with a new lawyer.

As of now, the February trial date still stands.




Updated: 2:45 PM EDT Aug 8, 2024
 
@arielilane - is Joseph going to be back on the 22nd also? I can not access that last article - not available for the EU. TIA! :)

And does Houck has a next hearing yet?
Yes, JL (son) will be back on Aug. 22 for court hearing.

Thursday’s (Aug 8) hearing included SL & JL, a status hearing regarding their request for a separate trial.
JL appeared at hearing via zoom call.

There has been no hearing scheduled for BH, at this time. imo, they are waiting for outcome of Aug 22 hearing before scheduling BH another hearing. moo

:)
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
64
Guests online
441
Total visitors
505

Forum statistics

Threads
608,240
Messages
18,236,715
Members
234,325
Latest member
davenotwayne
Back
Top