Search results

Do we have a time of the first confirmed sighting of her car at the barn? I know its been stated she clocked out/left around 11:20 but do we know when her car was first seen? Also, how close was the barn to the Black Lantern Inn?

I apologize if this has already been asked, but do we know where the tip came from that led to the car?

I agree. I thought the same thing as well. Also, maybe it's just me, but maybe by being so hell bent on getting someone to come home with her was a way to make the situation with her mother easier. Again, maybe just me, but growing up, I knew I wouldn't get as royal a chewing out if I had a...

Yes, very interesting read! The author is the man who wrote the book about Hall that I read! I just think that he could definitely fit the profile of a perp who could have and likely would have if given the opportunity to commit this crime. He just seems to fit it best to me out of all the perps...

Also, I am curious as to anyone thinking that Larry Hall could be responsible for this? I read a book on him and concerning his methods, I feel he could have (not saying did) done this. Thoughts?

I agree about the grave robbers. It seems entirely too convenient that all 3 disappeared just mere days before Suzie was to testify. Surely, if this were the case, Sherrill, would have been taken as well since she would have been able to point LE in the right direction. Stacy, as I tend to...

My apologies for the double post, but I was wondering. It has been stated that Cox worked at the same car dealership as Stacy's father. Was this ever proven or disproven?

This case is so very puzzling. So many things could have happened. I wonder what the FBI had to have said that Sherrill was the target and that it was a sexually motivated crime. MM, when you say you think that the crime was staged, do you mean it took place somewhere else? Or just that it...

MM, What leads you to believe the crime was staged?

Thank you. Do we know of Sherrill was dating anyone at the time? Both Suzie and Stacy were reported to have boyfriends. What do we know of them?

What do we know of Sherrill's ex husbands? I'm sure they were vetted by the police, but is anything known of significance about them?

Pretty much. I live in Tennessee and the biggest trail has been that of Holly Bobo. Until that trail, there really wasn't much in the way of cases like this. I had only just heard of the Searching for Ghosts podcast by mistake and I live only about 2 hours away from Milan.

I agree that could be a possibility. Perhaps then Sherrill, knowing the ins and outs of this because certainly Suzie would have told her, would have been silenced as well. Yes, Stacy was just in the wrong place at the wrong time. But let me ask you this, the man, the one you suspect might be the...

To me, what else motive would there be other than sexual when 3 women were kidnapped? Clearly, robbery wasn't the motive. What else could it be?

I don't know if this has been asked before, so please forgive me if it has, but is there a link where a person can read the FBI profile for the perp/perps for this case? MM, thats a very interesting theory about the abductor taking the dog. I think it could totally be possible.

I just listened to the podcast in its entirety and the stepfather looks so guilty. Whether or not he did it I cannot say but he surely had means motive and opportunity. It just breaks my heart.

I totally agree that the motive was surely not money. I also am in the boat that Cox isn't the perp. Seems all to easy to me. I could totally be wrong for sure, but I have never thought he was the culprit. I couldn't remember if it was confirmed that Suzie called her Mom or not, so thank you...

Catmammy, I agree with some of what you said. Now, my own mother, would have fought tooth and nail to get in control, even if there was a gun pointed at me. She would have gathered what vile things would happen once the perp got us wherever he wanted to take us. I think it would be possible...

It is my belief that the perp/perps arrived shortly after the girls got home for the night. To me, this explains the blinds moved in Suzie's room. Of course, that could be staged, but just seems odd to me. Now what I have always wondered about, is why Sherrill didn't wake up when the girls came...

MM, I wouldn't be surprised at all considering a lot of offenders are also narcissists. I do recall a case, the Tara Grinstead case, where one of the perps was actually posting on the Podcast Up and Vanished website. He had allegedly said he wanted to know what was being tossed around. I know...