Search results

I don't think the poster is saying that everyone should have left a handprint But RG left a handprint in blood on her pillow. If they were so interested in cleaning, why didn't they wipe that away? Why not just take off the pillowcase? If you had 3 people stabbing someone in that room, and...

They did not test any of those knifes I don't think. Testing the other things in that drawer was important to set up a control. For instance, maybe they would have had that same result if they tested the spoon and surely the murder weapon was not a spoon. If there was contamination going on, it...

This ridiculous toilet story is in THE headline for the story in newspapers all over the world. If you look it up, nearly all the headlines mention at least either that MK was murdered over the toilet tiff or AK killed bc of cleaning or toilet fight. Not sure why they waited till now to...

I would also add the independent experts said contamination was a possibility as did 19 other scientific experts. The judge in this recent case even said there is no reason to think C&V is unreliable, so I follow that, and given I am not a scientist, if the independent experts say there is a...

I think she was really overwhelmed/taken by surprise. I think RG could easily have overpowered her preventing her from making defensive wounds. We also don't know what she did to RG. I think it was several days later before the police got a hold of him. He could very well have had Knicks or she...

What also ties the clean up to AK and RS? If you used a lamp, then the cleanup would have happened that night bc you would not need a lamp in the morning. As far as I know, there is no evidence of bleach in the murder room or maybe anywhere in that apartment. The mop did not have blood or other...

So now the story changed once again? Now they claim RG was somehow in that apartment (as a guest?) went to the bathroom, MK went in there, saw the unflushed toilet,,critiques AK, AK got mad at MK being a mother hen telling her what to do, and said to RG and RS, hey let's kill MK? Yeah, that...

I believe MK would have fought back as that would be a natural instinct, unless she was somehow taken by surprise or immobilized That said, one can have all the self defense training, etc in the world. But MK is simply no match for RG. Thousands of women are murdered every year by men...

Maybe MK simply wanted more light for studying. Maybe at some point that week, her lightbulb went out and she did not have another one so she borrowed the lamp. Maybe she wanted to look for something under her bed and wanted a direct light source to do that. In any event I don't see how it...

I wonder how jury selection works in the Italian justice system, I know there were some professional judges on the original jury, but were some ordinary lay people there and how are they chosen? Do parties have the option like in the US to hire jury consultants or do they pretty much get an...

Yes post 170. I proposed 2 scenarios of her guilt, one supposing facts not in evidence that there was some sort of prearranged meeting and the three go to the cottage and a second presupposing that the murder was going on and AK and RS just decide to join in. I also did not see anyone...

I wonder if it was on or plugged in. If not plugged in, she could have been borrowing it and put it by door to remember to give it back, If it was on, that would be a little weird. I don't see any reason any one - MK, RG, AK, etc.,- would even do that. The only thing that it could be is...

The prosecution never established who staged that crime scene. They never proved it was AK. Given RG threw rocks before when he burglaries, that was his most operandi. As I mentioned multiple times, I never said or believe you need DNA or forensics tying you to scene in all cases. Scott...

I don't think it is alleged MK had head wounds or was killed with a lamp. She was killed w a knife, and with weak circumstantial evidence, you need to connect her to the room at least and to the murder weapon or body. Indeed, DNA on the lamp would not prove anything either. So what if AK's DNA...

I also think it is wrong to equate a lamp with a knife. For a lamp as I explained, you have no reason to be touching it often once it is in place, let alone hold onto it for more than a second for the light switch, indeed, maybe it was a light switch in the wall so you do not even have to touch...

We don't know when the lamp was moved. None of us know where the lamp was before the murder bc none of us were in the cottage It was the prosecution's job to test. That was just sheer negligence if they did not test that lamp. They should have tested everything in that room. One can...

Not sure how absence of DNA in the murder room can be a "nonissue" just bc it suppsoedly was not also on the lamp. That would be like saying we should exclude RG in the murder room just bc his DNA was not in the rock room Some pieces of evidence in this case are more telling than others, and...

Maybe she used both lamps at different times. Maybe she as not going to study that night so she put it on the floor or maybe she was done w the lamp and she was going to give it back to AK. I don't know what possible relevance it could have to a murder The judge or whoever is in charge of...

That is not true, I have stated 2 theories of her guilt. But that is just it, it is one of a few possible scenarios. If the burden was to prove her innocence, showing that 1 scenario would be enough But it is not, it is to prove her guilt. Bc she left no evidence in the murder room (any...

I think most people who live in a house leave footprints at some point. If those footprints were in the murder room that would be a different story but they are not. What did they do, hop around the murder room on one leg so as not to leave footprints? People on the guilt side neglect the...