southcitymom
Well-Known Member
i understand about there being a wide range of reactions from listeners outside the family, but my question was about your, personal reaction to the facts, southcitymom!
Dont you think the threat of corporal punishment is at least possible? .... a beefy, foul-mouthed, 50-year-old father yelling angrily at a skinny 11-year-old about her "A$$"? .... and what he's planning to "fly out there for a day" to do to her "A$$"? .... and that she "better be ready" for it?! .... especially says he's gonna make sure she knows how angry he really is?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BxwD4UGnJjc
You know, Seven - hearing that tape as I did - in limbo and out of the entire circumstance - I heard a frustrated angry father who went too far in admonishing his child and who ended up sounding like a child himself and further damaging an already damaged relationship with his child. I didn't hear threats. There's no part of me that was or is scared for Ireland's physical well-being. So that's my honest reaction.
Now, is the threat of corporeal punishment possible upon hearing that message? Sure, I guess it's possible - that's what some people heard, I think, but I just find it highly highly unlikely. I don't believe for one second that Alec Baldwin planned to get on a plane - fly to his daughter - spank her or beat her up or whatever and fly home. I just didn't hear that. I think he was actually trying to make a point and make her feel how furious he was.