Bishop Black
Former Member
- Joined
- Nov 18, 2021
- Messages
- 567
- Reaction score
- 1,227
ENID, Okla. — A 51-year-old man is facing multiple charges following the sexual assault and homicide of a 2-year-old.
Michael Scott Geiger was charged on Friday afternoon with felony counts of first-degree murder, first-degree rape, kidnapping and first-degree burglary.
A motion to hold Geiger without bond was filed, and Geiger appeared at the Garfield County Court House before Special District Judge Brian Lovell at 3 p.m. Friday.
Geiger’s bond was denied. His next court appearance is scheduled for 1:15 p.m. on June 6.
Geiger had been convicted in 1995 on charges of unauthorized use of a vehicle, robbery with firearms and kidnapping in Oklahoma County and was released from Oklahoma Department of Corrections custody on March 29, 2022.
-
Caliyah’s grandfather, Kevin “Charlie” Brown, said he and Caliyah went to the hotel’s ice machine and were approached by a man who asked if Caliyah wanted any chips or candy, which Brown said she could. Brown also said Geiger said Caliyah was pretty, the affidavit states.
Brown, Caliyah, her mother Chelsea Guyton and her father Cody Buckingham later went to the hotel’s swimming pool before returning to their room, and Brown said he fell asleep between 8:30 p.m. and 9 p.m. with Caliyah, Guyton and Buckingham all still in the room, according to the affidavit.
Buckingham said he and Guyton had gone to the room where Geiger, whom they met earlier in the day, was staying. According to the motion to hold without bond filed in the case, evidence suggests Geiger, Buckingham and Guyton consumed alcohol and methamphetamine.
-
According to the affidavit, Buckingham knocked on one of Geiger’s doors, which opened, but nobody was inside. Buckingham then knocked on the door to Geiger’s other room, but there was no answer.
The woman suggested Geiger may have gone to the pool, so the three walked toward the pool and found Caliyah. According to the affidavit, Buckingham pulled Caliyah out and attempted to perform CPR.
According to the affidavit, Buckingham said Geiger made a comment earlier in the day that Caliyah “was cute” but “too young.” He also said there were two keycards to their room and that he had one while Brown had the other.
-
During the investigation, EPD detectives located a pair of orange Texas Longhorns shorts — the pair that had been wrapped around Caliyah’s neck — and found two keycards, which both opened one of Geiger’s two rooms, in the pocket of the shorts.
The affidavit states in Geiger’s other room, police found a “noticeable amount” of blood on the bed and on the floor; a pair of girls’ underwear on the floor with blood on the inside; a homemade adult sex toy, used for “manual stimulation on typically male subjects,” which contained a sock which matched another found in Geiger’s other room and had blood and fluid consistent with semen inside; a pair of girls’ capri pants and a headband; a pair of Champion underwear matching pairs found in the other room; and a pink studded earring on the bed matching Caliyah’s missing earring.
When detectives turned on the television, the Nicktoons channel, which is “geared toward a younger audience,” was on, according to the affidavit.
In Geiger’s other room, detectives found a juice bottle matching others found in the room Caliyah’s family was staying in, along with gummy worms placed on the bed in a “nature that wouldn’t suggest the candy was accidentally spilt,” describing the candy as being placed on the bed “as if to possibly entice a child,” according to the affidavit.
Geiger denied sexually assaulting and killing Caliyah, but admitted he spoke with and offered chips and candy to her earlier in the day.
Michael Scott Geiger was charged on Friday afternoon with felony counts of first-degree murder, first-degree rape, kidnapping and first-degree burglary.
A motion to hold Geiger without bond was filed, and Geiger appeared at the Garfield County Court House before Special District Judge Brian Lovell at 3 p.m. Friday.
Geiger’s bond was denied. His next court appearance is scheduled for 1:15 p.m. on June 6.
Geiger had been convicted in 1995 on charges of unauthorized use of a vehicle, robbery with firearms and kidnapping in Oklahoma County and was released from Oklahoma Department of Corrections custody on March 29, 2022.
-
Caliyah’s grandfather, Kevin “Charlie” Brown, said he and Caliyah went to the hotel’s ice machine and were approached by a man who asked if Caliyah wanted any chips or candy, which Brown said she could. Brown also said Geiger said Caliyah was pretty, the affidavit states.
Brown, Caliyah, her mother Chelsea Guyton and her father Cody Buckingham later went to the hotel’s swimming pool before returning to their room, and Brown said he fell asleep between 8:30 p.m. and 9 p.m. with Caliyah, Guyton and Buckingham all still in the room, according to the affidavit.
Buckingham said he and Guyton had gone to the room where Geiger, whom they met earlier in the day, was staying. According to the motion to hold without bond filed in the case, evidence suggests Geiger, Buckingham and Guyton consumed alcohol and methamphetamine.
-
According to the affidavit, Buckingham knocked on one of Geiger’s doors, which opened, but nobody was inside. Buckingham then knocked on the door to Geiger’s other room, but there was no answer.
The woman suggested Geiger may have gone to the pool, so the three walked toward the pool and found Caliyah. According to the affidavit, Buckingham pulled Caliyah out and attempted to perform CPR.
According to the affidavit, Buckingham said Geiger made a comment earlier in the day that Caliyah “was cute” but “too young.” He also said there were two keycards to their room and that he had one while Brown had the other.
-
During the investigation, EPD detectives located a pair of orange Texas Longhorns shorts — the pair that had been wrapped around Caliyah’s neck — and found two keycards, which both opened one of Geiger’s two rooms, in the pocket of the shorts.
The affidavit states in Geiger’s other room, police found a “noticeable amount” of blood on the bed and on the floor; a pair of girls’ underwear on the floor with blood on the inside; a homemade adult sex toy, used for “manual stimulation on typically male subjects,” which contained a sock which matched another found in Geiger’s other room and had blood and fluid consistent with semen inside; a pair of girls’ capri pants and a headband; a pair of Champion underwear matching pairs found in the other room; and a pink studded earring on the bed matching Caliyah’s missing earring.
When detectives turned on the television, the Nicktoons channel, which is “geared toward a younger audience,” was on, according to the affidavit.
In Geiger’s other room, detectives found a juice bottle matching others found in the room Caliyah’s family was staying in, along with gummy worms placed on the bed in a “nature that wouldn’t suggest the candy was accidentally spilt,” describing the candy as being placed on the bed “as if to possibly entice a child,” according to the affidavit.
Geiger denied sexually assaulting and killing Caliyah, but admitted he spoke with and offered chips and candy to her earlier in the day.
