Gilbert Attorney: Escort's Affidavit Implicates James Burke in GB Murders

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves

New Posts

Neptune said:
I have no data in my files about Hackett being a past Suffolk County medical examiner but others on WS have researched and said this is correct. He is mentioned in Point 9. Atty John Ray stated that Hackett, as ME, worked with Burke on the 1996 TWA 800 crash in the Atlantic. But this article states the Suffolk County medical examiner in charge of that tragedy was Dr. Charles V. Wetli not Peter Hackett. Other sources on the TWA 800 tragedy also say Wetli was the ME in 1996. I've only seen Hackett described in MSM as "a former Suffolk County Police Department surgeon". I don't know where to place him on the chart -- I personally don't think John Ray has produced enough definitive evidence to link him to Shannan other than what Hackett has said happened.

http://www.nytimes.com/1996/08/20/s...-says-he-did-what-he-could-when-he-could.html

And.... Welcome to Websleuths!
Click to expand...
I never heard anyone on here say medical examiner... it is Police surgeon.
I read that in the papers and here is an ABC link saying he was a former police surgeon.
http://abc13.com/archive/8105347/
An brief quote:
""Police have said the client, Joseph Brewer, is not a suspect.
Police opened a missing persons case and in December, a cadaver dog looking for Shannan a few miles away found the skeletal remains of four women. And later two more discoveries of human remains. But still, no sign of Shannan Gilbert.
As her painful pilgrimage continued, Mari Gilbert stopped by the home of Dr. Peter Hackett, a former Suffolk County police surgeon the Gilberts claim called them the day after Shannan disappeared.
"A man identified himself as Hackett, said she was there. And from there she disappeared," Gilbert said.""

SOMETHING I FIND INTERESTING... JB and CPH are NOT SUSPECTS! Why? Why? Why? EVERYONE IS A SUSPECT! There is a young woman dead and no one she last talked to is a suspect in the GILGO TRIANGLE? The police do not make any sense. Where did they get their certifications??? To be so incompetent is irresponsible! Sorry but this really hacks me off. It is so absurd.:facepalm:
 
Was there a web sleuths radio pod cast show last night on Dec. 20?
Can you give a link please?
 
Frap, go to the top and click onto Long Island Serial Killer. Scrolldown. You will see link for yesterdays show
 
IndieCindy said:
In 48 hours documentary they said Hackett gave out prescriptions, then I read in newspaper account how JB and SG went to the local CVS to pick up "lubricant". Was there a video @ CVS of that?
I need to go back and see what paper that was in again and post it. Also, why do you pick up "lubricant" if you aren't having sex? I am leaning more and more towards my original thought of Snuff films. Where does CPH fit in to the scenario? IF he gave out prescriptions to friends & neighbors like the 48 hours documentary said, then he probably gave one to either JB or SG, which they filled at the CVS. Did anyone investigate his prescriptions he had given out and dates to correspond to dates of missing persons? I am not saying he was involved in deaths of people, only that he admitted he freely gave out prescriptions and if the victims all had a habit to support, so it is possible they (sex workers) all received a written prescription THROUGH another person?
It makes perfect sense to tell the girls that will make a lot of money for doing a short *advertiser censored* film. If we go down that road... What if they filmed SG? And when it is over, finds out "they" are just getting started... and they try to film someone strangling/attempting to harm her and she runs out, dials 911 and tells them on the 911 tape what is going on. Was the 911 operator interviewed? If the police say that there is nothing on the 20 minute tape then fine, RELEASE IT ... do "they" think people are stupid? Logically, there is no reason NOT to release it if that is the truth! So the 911 tape obviously has something incriminating on it.
Also if JB says they didn't have sex, he could have been the one behind the filming? He obviously was there... And SG was asked to come over specifically to his house, thinking she was going to make money for SOMETHING... FOR WHAT OTHER PURPOSE THAN SEX??? You do not call up a pizza delivery guy to come over and drop off a bologna sandwich. In what bizarro world does that even make the least bit of sense? Logically, only two things make sense if he wasn't having sex with her... 1) he was filming something with her in it... 2) he was her pimp, and used CH to give out his girls prescriptions. Either way... JB had to have had something going on with her otherwise she wouldn't have been IN HIS house.
When he was questioned/interviewed... was his house/basement searched? "mirrors on the ceiling and pink champagne on ice"
Did he willingly come forward or wait? If the gate-shack guard was interviewed (if there was one) did he see who all came through the gate? Because if there were others there at the house, and they didn't come through the gate, they probably would have came by boat. What other possible scenario could there be? so CPH implicated and inserted himself, either because he is mentally not that bright, or because he was trying to cover up a prescription he had written to SG or to one of the other people mentioned if it came back to haunt him later. Trying to cover his tracks, yet... making it worse on himself in the process. This all reminds me of the lyrics to Hotel California. (hence my reference above to mirrors and champagne)
Hotel California=Hotel Gilgo. On the next Vacation, I for sure won't be going to the Gilgo Triangle. Geeze.
Click to expand...
Indie Indie nice analogy to hotel California. I believe that brewers house was searched after the gb4 were found. If there was anything nefarious going on, there was a lot of time to clean up. I also recall reading that the house was full of cat urine. After reading that, I wondered if cat urine can mess with forensics?

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk
 
Neptune said:
I think we're starting to formulate a picture....
Click to expand...

-- REVISED GRAPHIC --

I went back and listened to John Ray's (might I add, lengthy) press conference. He referred to Hackett as the "former police surgeon of Suffolk County" -- so I've corrected that on the relationship chart.

For the record, I have never found research on Hackett as former ME -- only as police surgeon. But early on (~2011) a poster, who personally knew Hackett, made many wrong claims about him on the Internet. I think we all learned the guy's MO was to "poison the well" when it came to Hackett. He inflated some info and discounted other info whenever it suited his purpose.

LISK Dec 2016 (revision 1) Relationship Snapshot - Oak Beach, Prostitution & Suffolk Cty execs.jpg
 
I am reaching waaaaaay back in my memory bank........................Mr HC told me that an uncle of his (who was SCPD and knew fellow officers all over the county) to be very careful of going clubbing at The Oak Beach Inn (aka The OBI). It was/had the reputation of being a real cop trap for DWI. Even if you weren't drinking, people were pulled over in droves and basically harassed by SCPD. This would have been very late 1980's-1990 maybe as late as 1992. Makes me wonder if any of our unid'd victims may have been out clubbing that night.

Did I just open Pandora's Box ? I saw this uncle over the weekend and the story jumped into my mind. I remembered Mr HC telling me why he would not take me there on a date.
 
Robert Anderson said:
What was Burke's role at SCPD in 1996?
Click to expand...

Actually, he specialized in screwing prostitutes in his police car while on duty in the 1st.PCT. Regaling is co-workers with stories how he enjoyed receiving oral sex while he was defecating. He was very proud of that part of his 'police work."
 
Any thoughts on whether it was burke or his attorney that made the decision to respond to leanns claims, right after they were made last week? The initial response was that the claims werent worthy of a response and then it was flat out denial from his attny. After following this case for awhile now and being informed of the players.. "thanks to hawkshaw and many other justice seekers here" i was wondering whether burke is still ultimately calling the shots as to what statements his attny makes now that hes under the microscope. his denial response, hours after leanns press conference is suspect because if leanns claims are really so bogus, then why respond at all.
 
Neptune said:
-- REVISED GRAPHIC --

I went back and listened to John Ray's (might I add, lengthy) press conference. He referred to Hackett as the "former police surgeon of Suffolk County" -- so I've corrected that on the relationship chart.

For the record, I have never found research on Hackett as former ME -- only as police surgeon. But early on (~2011) a poster, who personally knew Hackett, made many wrong claims about him on the Internet. I think we all learned the guy's MO was to "poison the well" when it came to Hackett. He inflated some info and discounted other info whenever it suited his purpose.

View attachment 106431
Click to expand...

Neptune, I like your graphic. Can you add four items to it and see if any linkages or relationships become apparent. Michael Pak, Megan Waterman, Amber Lynn Costello, and the motel in Hauppauge. It would be most interesting to learn if any of the existing people on your chart had or have any type of involvement with that motel or the people I listed.

What if in the minds of the 'players' that Oak Beach was getting too much Media and Law Enforcement attention after Shannan disappeared, and certain 'party' activities switched from Oak Beach to the motel in Hauppauge?

Maybe nothing, maybe something.

Thanks
 
IndieCindy said:
I never heard anyone on here say medical examiner... it is Police surgeon.
I read that in the papers and here is an ABC link saying he was a former police surgeon.
http://abc13.com/archive/8105347/
An brief quote:
""Police have said the client, Joseph Brewer, is not a suspect.
Police opened a missing persons case and in December, a cadaver dog looking for Shannan a few miles away found the skeletal remains of four women. And later two more discoveries of human remains. But still, no sign of Shannan Gilbert.
As her painful pilgrimage continued, Mari Gilbert stopped by the home of Dr. Peter Hackett, a former Suffolk County police surgeon the Gilberts claim called them the day after Shannan disappeared.
"A man identified himself as Hackett, said she was there. And from there she disappeared," Gilbert said.""

SOMETHING I FIND INTERESTING... JB and CPH are NOT SUSPECTS! Why? Why? Why? EVERYONE IS A SUSPECT! There is a young woman dead and no one she last talked to is a suspect in the GILGO TRIANGLE? The police do not make any sense. Where did they get their certifications??? To be so incompetent is irresponsible! Sorry but this really hacks me off. It is so absurd.:facepalm:
Click to expand...


Re the term, "Police surgeon" -- I had never heard of that term, so I looked around and found some info about it. Here's a bit of it:

[h=1]Police surgeons are important part of criminal justice system[/h]Margaret M Stark, chair, education and research subcommittee, Association of Police Surgeons

Author information ► Copyright and License information ►

Editor—Clinical forensic medicine is one of the most dynamic and rapidly advancing specialties, but the article in Career Focus missed an opportunity to show just how the work of a police surgeon has changed in recent years.[SUP]1[/SUP]
In contrast to the views expressed, the assessment of drink-drivers is now a minor component of the work. Much more of the doctor's time is spent assessing substance misusers, mentally ill people, injured prisoners, and people with pre-existing morbidity to determine their fitness for detention; their fitness to be released, charged, or transferred; their fitness to be interviewed by the police; and whether an appropriate adult is required.[SUP]2[/SUP] The examination of both adults and children who complain of serious sexual assaults is also an essential part of the role.
.
.
.

NLM
NIH
DHHS
USA.gov

National Center for Biotechnology Information, U.S. National Library of Medicine 8600 Rockville Pike, Bethesda MD, 20894 USA
Policies and Guidelines | Contact
Click to expand...

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1118291/
------------------------------------
Below is an old article, but it helped me understand more about one case:

[h=1]New Shannan Gilbert autopsy reveals ‘disturbing’ findings in Gilgo Beach case, medical examiner says[/h]LONG ISLAND— Unhappy with the work of the Suffolk County Police Department, the family of Shannan Gilbert, one of the women found dead near Oak Beach, agreed when a famed medical examiner offered to perform a secondary autopsy. On Friday, family attorney John Ray revealed the report’s “disturbing” new findings, which directly contradict SCPD detectives, who listed the cause of death as drowning.
Click to expand...
http://pix11.com/2016/02/12/new-sha...gs-in-gilgo-beach-case-medical-examiner-says/
 
hot cawfee said:
I am reaching waaaaaay back in my memory bank........................Mr HC told me that an uncle of his (who was SCPD and knew fellow officers all over the county) to be very careful of going clubbing at The Oak Beach Inn (aka The OBI). It was/had the reputation of being a real cop trap for DWI. Even if you weren't drinking, people were pulled over in droves and basically harassed by SCPD. This would have been very late 1980's-1990 maybe as late as 1992. Makes me wonder if any of our unid'd victims may have been out clubbing that night.

Did I just open Pandora's Box ? I saw this uncle over the weekend and the story jumped into my mind. I remembered Mr HC telling me why he would not take me there on a date.
Click to expand...

Yes this sounds right. It's apparently covered in the book "Scandal At The Oak Beach Inn". The owner Bob Matheson was in dispute with politicians and policing, so they set up road tolls and DUI checks to destroy his business. He re-located the OBI to Key West, FL. I want the book but it's costly to ship to UK... I keep wondering which of the characters mentioned in these threads may also pop up in that book. Feingold?

A phone number I found for Harry Feingold a few days ago, showed up as a Verifcation phone number when typed into Facebook search bar that matched another family member (maybe his son?). Wonder what secrets that phone SIM holds if it's been passed from father to son?

Check out my other posts on how I think Hackett/Burke/Brewer trinity have corresponded on UG Forum since 2002, I think it shows Burke mentioning he knows Brewer's address all the way from 2002 which could prop-up Leanne's claims
 
I see your posts and they are interesting, but what evidence do you have to back up your claim that these are the usernames of these individuals? The only basis you provided is "I think that this is so and so's UG username" Ok, based on what?
 
Cici_Cyclone said:
Can you expand on what the article says? I have limited access as it's asking for a subscription payment.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

The motion, filed in Riverhead on behalf of the man Burke beat, Christopher Loeb, 30, of Smithtown, seeks to set aside Loeb’s guilty plea to criminal possession of a weapon after a pretrial hearing in 2013. Loeb was sentenced to 3 years in prison in 2014.

[...]

Barket said attorneys involved in the case have told him at least six officers and detectives have pleaded guilty to crimes. Burke pleaded guilty in February to beating Loeb on Dec. 14, 2012, and orchestrating a cover-up, and is serving a prison sentence of 46 months.

[...]

Beyond that, Meyers said, “Our partners at the U.S. Attorney’s office have asked us not to comment and we are going to honor their request.”

[...]

The motion does not reveal the source of that information. There were no other details on the cases.

[...]

A special prosecutor, William Ferris of Islandia, will handle the motion because of Burke’s close ties to Suffolk District Attorney Thomas Spota, which date to when Burke was a teenage witness against four defendants in the notorious 1979 murder of 13-year-old John Pius. Ferris said he had just received Barket’s motion and needs time to consider the arguments.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

DNASolves

Who is Escambia County John Doe (1989)?

Members online

... and 86 more.
Total: 2,016 (members: 87, guests: 1,929)

Online statistics

Members online
87
Guests online
1,929
Total visitors
2,016
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Forum statistics

Threads
600,394
Messages
18,108,029
Members
230,992
Latest member
Clue Keeper
Back
Top