I'm starting to think the guy from Wisconsin had nothing to do with Nyleen's case at all. Just a former Montanian who knew what he knew through gossip and Montana newspapers that go into way more detail on the case than just "went missing at a picnic; children near her saw a guy in a jogging suit." You don't need to have the little Mormon girl to know her family missed her when it's obvious and Montana had a news article about the family four months before that first mysterious phone call. Plenty of people have given police "confessions" they took and killed this girl, but further investigation yielded they're full of it. A man by the name of Richard James Wilson was one of them when he lead authorities to a mineshaft in 1991.
I maintain that she was taken by the unidentified male (I'll start calling him "Shadow Nelson") the children last saw her with.
I maintain that she was taken by the unidentified male (I'll start calling him "Shadow Nelson") the children last saw her with.