NE NE - Carolyn Nevins, 20, Omaha, UNO student, found shot to death, 9 December 1955

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves

GEnome

New Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2019
Messages
4
Reaction score
3
From the OMAHA WORLD HERALD
Sunday, 11 December 1955
Page 1, 3:

SECOND CASE ON WEST SIDE IN FIVE DAYS: Carolyn Nevins was Brilliant Student

A brilliant and attractive University of Omaha co-ed was found murdered on the campus early Saturday.
The body of Miss Carolyn Nevins, 20, of 4923 Cass Street, was found beside the driveway leading into the campus from Dodge Street.
She had last been seen waiting for her father to take her home.
She was shot four times- twice in the upper arm, once in the left shoulder and once in the middle of the chest.
One of the bullets which hit her in the arm entered her left lung.
Sex Not Ruled Out​
The shooting apparently occurred between 10:55 and 11:25pm. The body was discovered at 4:10am.
There was no evidence of rape, but although police did not rule out the possibility that sex was the motive.
Her skirt was pulled up over her hips and her underclothing was disheveled.
She had not been robbed.
The Nevins slaying was the second in West Omaha in five days.
Miss Nevins’s killer used a .32-caliber automatic, the same type weapon as in the Erick W. Burkwist shooting last Monday.
However, a preliminary check ruled out the possibility that the same gun was used in both murders, police said.
At or Near Bus Stop​
Miss Nevins, a debater and part-time employe in the University Library, apparently was slain as she waited at or near a bus stop just east of the main building.
Her father was to have picked her up at 10pm, but was more than an hour late.
She had participated in a debate during the day and worked in the library until a few minutes before 10pm.
Co-workers saw her sit down at the bus stop as they left.
Mr. Nevins came by at about 11:25pm and failed to see her. Thinking she had gotten a ride with friends, he returned home.
Spotted by Headlights​
She wasn’t there so he returned to the university, but still failed to see her. At 3:50am he notified police.
Detective Sgts. Al Pattavina, Jr., and Earl White drove out to the university and their headlights disclosed the body, lying a foot or two from the curb on the west side of the driveway.
A moment before police arrived, the body had been seen by a bakery truck driver, Joseph Caniglia, 1903 South Sixteenth Street.
He was summoning the night watchman, Carl Kumneman, 216 South Twenty-fifth Street, as the detectives arrived.
Among the last persons to see Miss Nevins alive was Frank Paulsen, an English instructor.
Declined Lift​
Mr. Paulsen said he left the main university building at 10:55pm and was getting into his car at the faculty parking lot near the bus stop when he saw Miss Nevins. She was sitting on a retaining wall at the bottom of a flight of steps.
“There was a streetlight overhead so I recognized her readily,” Mr. Paulsen said.
“I asked her if she wanted a lift and she declined. I’m not sure she recognized me. I got into my car and drove home.”
Five hours later her body was found. It was lying about two hundred feet north of the bus stop. It is about the same distance from Dodge Street.
Detectives said they could find no evidence of a struggle.
Possibly in Car​
It was not immediately clear how she got from the bus stop area to the point where her body was found.
However, Chief Deputy Sheriff Jack Knudtson theorized that possibly she had been taken away in a car and returned.
He pointed out Mr. Nevins didn’t see the body when he drove to the university, yet the police saw it easily.
Police also know that two couples drove up the driveway about 1am following a dance to pick up a car belonging to one of the couples which had been left in the university parking lot.
Clutched Two Dimes​
Police also were checking a report from residents between Forty-eighth and Fiftieth Streets on Chicago Street that they heard gunshots about midnight.
There were leaves in one hand and on Miss Nevin’s bobby sox and knees. Her shoes were found right side up about 125 feet south of the body. Her blood-stained scarf was lying between them.
She clutched two dimes, inside her right glove.
Miss Nevins weighed about 140 pounds and was about 5 feet 8 inches tall.
-​
*Full Post in Progress: more to come*
 
Last edited:
MSM article from 2002:

Murder of UNO student still unsolved 47 years later - Gateway

Arthur Nevins was supposed to pick up his daughter after she got off her job as a library assistant at the university at 10 p.m. However, he was delayed by other errands and didn’t arrive until about 11:25 p.m.

Around 11 p.m., Nevins must have decided to take the bus home. A teacher who knew her saw her sitting at the bus stop at 10:55 p.m. and offered her a ride, but she declined.

Between 11 and 11:15 p.m., four people saw her sitting at the bus stop. The first person, who drove by shortly after 11 p.m., saw her alone. Three others saw a dark, tall, slender man standing near by.

With no witnesses, few clues and an unidentified suspect, only theory can explain what happened from here on.

After investigating the facts, Snyder concluded the shooting took place near the former Administration Building, between 11 and 11:30 p.m. The motive could have been an attempted sex assault.

Nevins, who was shot after resisting her killer’s advances, probably fell unconscious and in deep shock, but revived two hours later and tried to get to Dodge Street. She made it 40 yards before she collapsed in a ditch along today’s University Drive East, where she may have lived for another 30 minutes before she finally died.

A delivery truck driver found her body, covered by the falling snow, at 4:10 a.m. on Dec. 10, 1955.
 
OMG that poor young woman. She was alive for such a long time.

That's a shame no one heard the gun shots. Or, if they did, they didn't investigate what had happened. Maybe they thought it was a car/truck back firing?

1955. I wonder if they actually saved, and preserved, any evidence? We now have the technology.....
 
I was so impressed with the details of the journalism and the well spoken quotations before I realized how old this case was. Man, our reporting has gone downhill.

IKR? 100% agree with you. The reporting was top notch.

_____________________
From that link in Post #2:

"In Nevins’ case, the perpetrator, if still alive, may be well over 70 and health-impaired by now, which poses the question whether such a person is still a threat to society, Ficenec said.

“There are lots of considerations that make it less and less likely, as years go by, that it’s ever going to be solved,” he said."

I wonder if any surviving family members would agree with those sentiments?
 
FACTS POST #2: Timeline of Known Events of 9 December 1955 (The Night of Carolyn's Murder)

8:30-10 pm: Carolyn works in the University Library filing government reports.

10 pm: Carolyn walks to the main campus building to wait for her father inside. She waits inside the east foyer with Jodie Miller and another female friend.

10:15 pm: Jodie Miller gives up waiting for her boyfriend and calls for a cab on the payphone in a nearby hallway. She sees three men in the hall, one of whom carries a briefcase. One of the men (not with a briefcase) leaves while the other two remain waiting in the hallway. Later, it was learned the men were attorney and UNO professor Robert N. Spire and two of his students from night class, who went to the first floor to talk and smoke.

10:25 pm: The cab arrives. Jodie offers Carolyn a ride, and Carolyn declines, saying, “No thanks. I have a ride.”

10:30 pm: The university janitor locks the building’s east doors, and does not report seeing Carolyn. He lets two men out, one of whom carries a briefcase, assuming them to be professors. (Police statement cited in OWH)

10:55 pm: English professor Frank Paulsen walks to his car in the faculty lot. He sees Carolyn waiting on the retaining wall at the bottom of a small flight of steps near the bus stop. Because there is a street lift overhead, he recognizes her, and offers her a ride. She declines; Paulsen is unsure if she recognized him. He gets into his car and drives home.

11:00-11:05 pm: A female student reports seeing a girl waiting near the bus stop.

11:10 pm: A motorist reports seeing a girl matching Carolyn’s description waiting near the bus stop. He also reports seeing a man nearby.

About 11:15 pm: Two witnesses (a couple driving by) report seeing a girl waiting near the bus stop and a man nearby.

11:15-11:20 pm: The city bus driver, Max Krussell, comes eastbound to the university stop. The bus is scheduled to make the stop at 11:09 pm, but arrives several minutes later. Krussell does not see anyone.

11:25-11:45 pm: Arthur J. Nevins, Carolyn’s father, and her 13 year old brother Noel drive through Elmwood Park to campus to pick Carolyn up. They had been attending an Eastern Star event (Masonic religious group) at the Masonic Temple that ran late. Mr. Nevins drives around for a while looking for his daughter, but does not see her. Assuming she got a ride with a friend, he drives home.

About 12:00 am: University-assigned police Officer Charles Clawsen leaves campus from the south parking lot. At the entrance of the lot, a car nearly collided into his as it passed through the lot without stopping.

About 12:00 am: Campus night watchman Carl Kunneman sees the same car with two people in the front seats. He could not identify the make or model of the car.

About 12:00 am: Other tips are made to either the OWH or the police about a 1955 Buick seen in Elmwood Park near the university drive.

About 12:00 am: Police receive reports of gunshots from residents between 48th and 50th Streets and Chicago Street near Elmwood Park.

Around 3:00 am: Arthur Nevins calls Carolyn’s friends to see if she is with them.

3:20 am: World-Herald delivery man Earl Hansen drives through University Drive from Dodge Street, his headlights sweeping the area where Carolyn’s body would later be found. He sees nothing.

3:50 am: Arthur Nevins calls the police and reports Carolyn missing.

3:50 am: Bakery delivery truck driver Joe Caniglia finds Carolyn’s body just to the side of University Drive.

4:00-4:10 am: Police detectives Al Pattavir and Earl White arrive at the scene.

Sources: Omaha World-Herald articles from 10 Dec- 23 Dec 1955
 
FACTS POST #3: Evidence from the Scene and Autopsy Notes

Carolyn's Body (Scene)
  • Found face down in divet next to University Drive
  • No snow found under body; snow started approx. 3 am, body reached location between 3:20 and 3:50 am
  • Coat and skirt pulled up to hips
  • Underwear disheveled
  • Leaves found on bobby sox, leaves and gravel on knees
  • Clutched two dimes in right hand
Autopsy Notes
  • Body is cold but not frozen (Omaha temperature 9-10 Dec. 1955: 17-19 deg. F)
  • Height: 5'8, Weight: 140 lbs
  • Shot four times: twice in upper arm, once in left shoulder, once in middle of chest
  • One bullet entered her left lung, both lungs punctured
  • Powder burns on chest and left shoulder
  • Two bullets recovered in body, one in clothing (fourth later found on campus)
  • Bruising on/around left eye
  • Two quarts of blood in right chest cavity
  • One quart of blood in left chest cavity
  • Angle of bullet wounds suggest shot while sitting or kneeling
  • Hair not belonging to Carolyn found in her mouth
  • "No evidence" of rape (probably means no semen found on body or clothing)
From the Scene
  • Shoes and bloodied scarf found about 14o feet north of bus stop near Administration Building (100 feet away from body)
  • Copper-coated bullets recovered are from a .32-20 revolver; right twist indicates gun is American-made
  • Fourth bullet found barely penetrating the ground three feet from where her shoes were
  • Hair found on nearby tree trunk at eye-level
  • Carolyn's pink hair comb was recovered on 22 December by a reporter in Room 100 of the Administration building, which is both a lecture and lounge room; blood spots found near comb and on nearby stairwell
  • All missing textbooks later found except for a notebook containing autobiographical information Carolyn had been compiling to use for scholarship applications
Sources: Omaha World-Herald articles December 1955
 
Findagrave: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/155267312/carolyn-marie-nevins

There was a suspect at one point:

Rita Kapperman, wife of Keith Kapperman, was murdered in Omaha, Nebraska - Newspapers.com

Nothing further that I can find. Perhaps local libraries have microfiche from more articles around that time?

Yes, there were. I will upload more information soon from my research, eventually including transcriptions of every article about the murder (the OWH has its microfiche digitized and is accessible online with a library card).
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
153
Guests online
870
Total visitors
1,023

Forum statistics

Threads
602,190
Messages
18,136,436
Members
231,267
Latest member
ChiChi8773
Back
Top