OH OH - Oregon, Lake Erie shore, BlkMale 30-50, UP4728, 'Adventurer's Club' sweatpants, Nov'05

[CarlK90245]

NamUs UP 4728 https://identifyus.org/en/cases/4728

LUCAS COUNTY
Technology seeks to solve mysteries of 2 bodies
Digital facial reconstruction gives hope to cold cases

http://www.toledoblade.com/Police-F...ogy-seeks-to-solve-mysteries-of-2-bodies.html

...

John Doe’s body was found early Nov. 4, 2005 ....

From a boat in Lake Erie, behind Oregon’s wastewater treatment plant in Jerusalem Township, a duck-hunting father-son duo saw the man’s bones along the rocky shoreline.

Nearby was a clump of clothing: Adventurer’s Club sweatpants, large, maybe blue, and Hanes undershorts, size 32.

...

What’s known about John Doe isn’t much. At some point, the bridge of his nose was broken, and he has a healed shoulder blade injury, and he had, perhaps, been shot in his right leg.

He was black and, when he died, was between 30 and 50 years old...

Based on measurements of John Doe’s left tibia and femur, he was between 5 foot, 3 inches, and 5 feet, 8 inches. He had a thin build.

At some time during his life, John Doe had access to good dental care, the report notes.

Despite the dental care, John Doe had an abscess at the root of a maxillary left-central incisor, fillings, and gum disease.

John Doe had been dead for at least several months, Dr. Barnett said, basing the observation on a lack of soft tissue.

John Doe’s information was eventually uploaded to databases, and that’s when the inquiries came in: missing boaters from Canada; a missing Bedford, Ohio, husband; another missing Canadian man, and a man missing from Columbus since 2002.

...

 

[hannah1988]

I literally got chills when I found Donald Harrigan on NAMUS:
https://www.findthemissing.org/en/cases/5662/23/

He closely resembles the sketch. In both the sketch and in his photo, the right eye is higher and closer to the eyebrow than the left eye! He's been known to travel to various places, and he has a fractured collarbone. He's also not on the NamUS rule out list.

Question though, DNA is entered for both the UID and Donald Harrigan, so should NamUS have already checked for this match? If so, why isn't it on the rule out list? I'm new to sleuthing, so I'm not sure how this works!

 

[CarlK90245]

I literally got chills when I found Donald Harrigan on NAMUS:
https://www.findthemissing.org/en/cases/5662/23/

He closely resembles the sketch. In both the sketch and in his photo, the right eye is higher and closer to the eyebrow than the left eye! He's been known to travel to various places, and he has a fractured collarbone. He's also not on the NamUS rule out list.

Question though, DNA is entered for both the UID and Donald Harrigan, so should NamUS have already checked for this match? If so, why isn't it on the rule out list? I'm new to sleuthing, so I'm not sure how this works!

That is a good resemblance.

But the UID has a prior fracture of the shoulder blade (i.e., scapula), but no mention of a prior injury to the collarbone (i.e., clavicle).

 

[hannah1988]

That is a good resemblance.

But the UID has a prior fracture of the shoulder blade (i.e., scapula), but no mention of a prior injury to the collarbone (i.e., clavicle).

Good catch! I must have read it too quickly. I wonder if his family could have remembered the injury wrong. Shoulderblade and collarbone seem pretty similar. At least they were similar enough that I got them confused! :blushing:

 

[tamar]

That is a very close resemblance, Hannah. Perhaps you should submit the possible match anyway, as there is always the possibility of human error on behalf of the family member/friend who reported Mr. Harrigan missing. Misidentified injury-- the all too common mistake of mixing up clavicle & scapula. p.s. Three quarters of scapula breaks are due to high speed car crashes and Mr. Harrigan did receive injuries in a car wreck.

 

[hannah1988]

Thanks! I agree and did call it in. It sounds like they'll follow up on it soon. I'll let you know when I hear something back.

 

[webrocket]

I'm not concerned about the injury, not all family members know the entire medical history of other adults.

what concerns me is that the Doe was estimated to be between 5'3" and 5'8" and Harrigan was 6'1".

 

[hannah1988]

I'm not concerned about the injury, not all family members know the entire medical history of other adults.

what concerns me is that the Doe was estimated to be between 5'3" and 5'8" and Harrigan was 6'1".

I noticed that too! A pretty big difference - but maybe an error somewhere?!?

 

[Irish_Eyes]

Harrigan is not yet on the rule out list, though there are 28 ruleouts.

Bringing Jerry Hawkins into the mix here.

http://www.blackandmissinginc.com/cdad/index.cfm?MissingInfoID=306


Negatives - like Harrigan, he's 6'0 tall. (I'm more open to look outside of height guesstimates based on partial remains for a number of reasons.)

Also, he went missing in October of '03, whereas the remains were found in November '05 and estimate DOD was "at least a couple months". But, again, after the Ronnie Gibbons case where his remains were found in '99 and estimated DOD was in '98 and Ronnie was killed in 1995, a three year difference, I made a mental note to question time frames of remains found in the Great Lakes. Just not sure how well they are able to take into account things like algae blooms and freeze/thaw cycles and the effects if any on decomposition, bone bleaching, etc.

As for the positives:

He's the right gender/race/age. He was about 41 when he went missing.

He makes sense geographically. He was last seen in Highland Park, MI, which is only an hour from Toledo and is also near the Detroit River which dumps into the lake.

He was wearing blue jogging pants when last seen

He has a scar on his shin which could perhaps line up with the possible injury to the leg of the UID.

Thoughts?

 

[MizKim]

Irish Eyes

I see a gross resemblance to Jerry Hawkins also. I wish he was looking straight into the camera.

Here's a side by side




With that said some of the reconstructions and their ultimate identifications have made me question my eyesight. :waitasec:

 

[MizKim]

Was any one going to call in Jerry Hawkins?

 

[Irish_Eyes]

Sorry MizKim, I've been a little busy, so I haven't called it in. I'll try and shoot them an e-mail tomorrow and I'll let you know.

 

[Melt71]

Bumping for some later attention as find it hard to do research on my phone, The National Missing and Unidentified Persons System (NamUs)

 

[YaYa_521]

Ruleouts:
MP9638 Dion Akemon 09/26/2005 Hamilton OH
MP3853 John Ashley, Jr. 12/14/1971 New Castle DE
MP5881 Allen Briscoe 12/13/1985 Philadelphia PA
MP7088 Anthony Davis 05/24/1996 King WA
MP17626 Desmond Dix 01/30/1996 Fulton GA
MP10230 Thomas Flowers 07/01/2002 Lavaca TX
MP7825 Edgar Forbes 10/28/1995 Palm Beach FL
MP13574 William Forshee, Jr 04/16/1973 Miami-Dade FL
MP5673 Kevin Gardner 02/11/1996 Polk FL
MP7869 Marvin Gibbs 03/29/1985 Sullivan NY
MP12556 Anthony Grandberry 07/01/1995 Multnomah OR
MP14767 Derek Gray 10/07/1997 Kent MI
MP13 Charlie Hall 12/31/1981 Davidson TN
MP9678 Andrew Hargrove 07/25/2005 Washtenaw MI
MP1255 Saeed Hedgepeth 04/24/1999 Alameda CA
MP10901 Leonard Johnson Jr 03/01/1975 New York NY
MP7851 Anthony Lofston 08/30/1993 Vigo IN
MP7733 James Mayberry Jr 04/02/1999 Karnes TX
MP4297 Phillip Modlin 02/17/2004 Montgomery OH
MP979 Roman Oldacre 10/16/2004 Tarrant TX
MP1789 Kawan Pryor 09/09/1997 Accomack VA
MP9752 Sedrick Randle 06/01/2000 Pulaski AR
MP20297 Cordell Shepherd 03/01/2004 Cuyahoga OH
MP7116 Stevey Sommerville 09/06/1990 Queens NY
MP11093 Clarence Thomas 10/10/2002 Lorain OH
MP3935 Myron Traylor 07/27/1988 Maricopa AZ
MP514 Michael Way 03/25/2002 DeKalb GA
MP289 Antwon Williams 08/24/1998 Charleston SC
MP1041 Cedric Wright 11/24/2001 Creek OK