Missed all of yesterday's discussion. Pasting a response here from previous thread.
It is true that not all adulterers commit murder;
Yes, I would imagine it is a very small percentage. Way less than 1%.
It has been said that the security camera didn't show JY unplugging it or shoving it up; however, the security camera didn't show anyone unplugging it or shoving it up. That leaves the question, who was staying in the HI on Nov. 2, 2006 who needed the security camera unplugged at 11:20 pm and shoved up towards the ceiling at 6:35am the next morning?
Where are you getting these times? 6:35? 11:20?
Why was JY's shirt that he was seen wearing on the security camera at the front desk at midnight not in his luggage or in his vehicle the next evening? Clothing does not just disappear without a reason, and I cannot think of a logical reason for the shirt to be missing other than he threw it away.
I agree
How did a pair of Hush Puppy shoes with a unique sole just happen to be found in blood at the crime scene? A pair of HP with a unique sole that JY just happened to have owned.
How unique are these soles? I've seen no data to back this up. How many shoes were sold in the US that had this sole?
Why would a man staying at the HI on the 4th floor leave his valuables unsecured twice to go downstairs because he worried about disturbing his neighbors by shutting his room door? Why would a man go downstairs twice and prop open an exit door because that was more convenient than carrying his keycard with him?
Great question. I didn't buy JY's testimony that he didn't want to wake up neighbors. He admitted that there was no force/spring in the door and it actually stayed open without using anything to keep it from closing. Why leave your keycard in room for a trip downstairs to smoke.
Why was there no forced entry into the home?
Maybe someone rushed MY while she was outside. Got in through garage?
Why was a pregnant woman beaten 30 times to her and her unborn son's death, yet her 2 1/2 year old daughter who witnessed part of the crime was cleaned up, cared for, and left alive?
Many murderers draw the line at kids. Speaking of cleaned up.... If, JY cleaned up CY, she would have been left alone in house from 3-3:30am to 1:30pm. Give me a reason for anyone to clean up kid. I assume whomever killed MY assumed kid would just get dirty again being left at crime scene. There must be another explanation for her cleanliness.
Why was Michelle's purse that was sitting out in the open not stolen, but a wallet with $500 in it that was hidden in JY's closet was stolen? Why was JY's closet gone through, but Michelle's was left untouched?
I thought both were found to be not in their normal condition. Where is this testimony?
Why was the house not ransacked?
No idea. If it was, would this help JY??? If he was the master murder planner, wouldn't he try to make the scene look like a robbery?
Why didn't the dog that stayed in the house go after the "stranger" who murdered Michelle?
Some dogs are not wired this way.
Why does the timeline of JY stopping at Four Brothers in King fit perfectly?
Good question
Why did no cameras record JY going towards the breakfast area on Friday morning?
Why does this matter? If you believe JY is guilty, you must believe he made it back to the hotel to push up camera.
Why was the last person JY talked to before the murder and the second person (behind trying to reach his mom) he talked to after the murder MM?
Not sure why this is relevant. He spoke to MM what, 400 times in this timeframe?? Chance were good that he spoke to her before and after murder.
Why did JY print off the MapQuest directions and the Coach purse from Ebay at around the same time and remembered to get one but forgot the other?
No idea. Not sure this helps pros in any way though.
Why was JY so persistent about getting MF over to his house to pick up the Coach purse printout? He called twice and left messages, and he had his mom call once and leave a message.
Well if you believe JY its because he wanted to surprise his wife with the bag. In one of the messages he mentioned that if MF couldn't get over it was not a huge deal. If you think he's guilty its because he loved his daughter enough to get her out of there, but not much as if this were the case wouldn't he try to get his daughter out of there before noon-1:30?
Why didn't JY answer his MIL's 4 phone calls within the space of an hour when cell phone records show that he retrieved the two messages she left him? Why didn't he return those calls?
No idea.
When JY arrived at his mother's home and his stepfather gave him the news about Michelle's death, why did JY fall "plumb to his knees?" No surprise, no denial, no insisting that they must have gotten the news wrong. Just immediate acceptance. Remember that when LF found out, she was so shocked she couldn't even cry because she couldn't accept it yet.
Sure, because we all react exactly the same to news of our spouse's death.
Why didn't JY help LE at all even with his lawyer present?
No one knows. Was he advised?
Why didn't JY take a polygraph exam to clear himself with LE? MF did.
No one knows, was he advised? Have you ever taken a polygraph? Do you even know what it measures? How easy it is to cheat? Get false readings?
Why didn't JY keep custody of his daughter and allow MF and LF visitation?
No idea. Was he advised to wait to pursue custody after criminal trial?
Why didn't JY ever offer an award leading to the arrest of conviction of Michelle's killer(s)? Her place of employment did 9 months later; I guess they figured JY wasn't ever going to.
Good question
Why did JY testify that he was working on his marriage when in fact he was having two affairs?
Because he was a pig?
This is an open and shut case for me. JY has done everything in his power to make himself look guilty.
Just not seeing it. There are definitely some points here that make it very possible JY did it and is guilty.. There is also some evidence that makes it very possible he is innocent.