Thank you for replying to me with this theory. I didn’t know that Dr. Michael Baden attached the caveat of the results being insufficient to determine cause of death in the case of Shannan Gilbert. Therefore I can agree that there is a possibility that she may not be a murder victim. However, due to the fact that her personal belongings, most significantly her jeans, were found in a different area, and the fact that a person of interest, Joeseph Brewer, had a motive, I still believe that foul play may be involved in her death.
Regarding the Gilgo Beach 4 and the other unidentified bodies. I believe these murders were committed by different people. I belive the Gilgo Beach 4 were murdered by Unsub, whose psychological profile I documented in my original post. The time frame matches and the modus operandi is identical. The others, including Asian Male, I believe were murdered at a much earlier time, with a different modus operandi, (dismemberment), and by a different psychological profile with certain similarities. The case of Asian Male seems to be a different situation than the rest. Asian Male was not strangled but was murdered by blunt force trauma to the head. My theory regarding Asian Male is that he met the killer of the unidentified persons, peaches and Jessica Taylor, and when the killer discovered that he was transvestite, he was enraged and beat him to death. I’ve touched lightly on the reports of John Bittrolf and believe that he could be the one responsible for the murders of the unidentified bodies, peaches and Jessica Taylor, but I will need more analysis.
Regarding the Gilgo Beach 4 many people have stated that the reason they were wrapped in burlap is because of Unsubs access to the material. I can agree that he may have had access to the material, but why would he choose it over something more common than plastic garbage bags. The significance of the burlap to me is that it is symbolic and somewhat ritualistic on the part of Unsub. Burlap in the Bible is symbolic of mourning and repentance. Perhaps Unsub believed that he was somehow saving these girls. Take that with the significance of the phone calls to Amanda Barthelemy. Those who I have discussed this with state that they believe the phone calls were a form of sexual sadism, but maybe Unsub was trying to scare Amanda away from a life of prostitution. I’m going to begin researching John Bittrolf at this point, please share with me any significant information regarding him.
