trial day 49: REBUTTAL; #150

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Status
Not open for further replies.
Respectfully copied this post from Kmouse- it is her transcription of actual trial testimony, BBM, also note she was there until they moved to YREKA for high school. Jodi would have been 15 as a freshman.

Jodi Arias takes the stand part 2
JODI ARIAS takes the stand
PART 2

--Objection is overruled.

--Jodi is asked to speak up so that everybody can hear her.
--Mother hit Jodi and her brother with the wooden spoon. Sometimes Mother would pull the car over and hit them with the spoon. It left welts.
--Father used a belt, was very intimidating and did not have to use the belt as often as her Mother.
--The incidents were frequent and intense. They increased in frequency as Jodi got older. Mother beat Jodi with the spon...it seemed like 4x a week to 1x every two weeks. It depended.
--Jodi lived in Selinas until age 11.
--Jodi and her brother did after school activities. Jodi began to get into art, her pets were very central in her life, read a lot of books, took karate lessons, flute lessons.
--re: art, Jodi liked to color when she was younger. Was fascinated by art and began to practice what she saw.
--beatings from parents continued. Increased all the way through the teenaged years.
--the level of the brutality increased. Jodi and her brother would squirm and the harder they would squirm the harder her parents would try and hit them.
--Mother broke the brother's vein once.
--as she became a teenager Father became rougher and rougher.
--Nurmi asks how she felt when her own mother was beating her. Jodi felt betrayed and confused and as she got older it made her mad because it hurt. It put a strain on their relationship but Jodi still loved her.
--re: Father and the beatings getting rougher. Father shoved her into furniture. Never used his fists. Side of her head hit a door post one time and it momentarily knocked her out. When she came to her Mother was there and told the Father to be careful. This happened when Jodi was 16-17 years old. She was arguing with her mother at the time.
--Sometimes she got grounded which became the norm in high school.
--re: beatings from Father. Jodi loved him.
--At age 11 moved to Santa Maria, CA. The pushing into furniture started then. Would have been in grades 6-8. Jodi was going to school with Carl at this time.
-
-Jodi's interests were trying to make new friends. Says it seemed like she was constantly going to new schools due to moving.
--Focused on her art in Junior High. Took art class. Mentored by her art teacher.
--Parents did not discourage her interest in art. Classmates and art teacher gave her a lot of praise. Parents were indifferent. Didn't really bother her at that time.
--Enrolled in art school for a few weeks. Other family members were more encouraging with her art. Parents never went out of their way to display it.

--Jodi went to high school, for Grade 9 they moved to Yreka and she went to Yreka Union High School. Grades 9-12.
--Jodi entered in her freshman year.
--Beatings from Father continued through the high school years.
--Right before they moved to Santa Maria, Jodi snuck out the house and she snuck back in and when her father asked her where she was her Father smacked her across the face 2x. Open handed hard slap. No bleeding. No bruising. It hurt.
--Father was very big at that time, he is frail now due to his health. Father is 5'11" and used to bench press 520 lbs.
--Mother was aware of Father beating her when she was present. Both parents punished Jodi.
--When Jodi turned 16-17 years old she doesn't remember Mother carrying the spoon anymore. Mother would grab whatever was around like a hair brush. Mother had acrylic nails so she would dig her nails in.
--In high school Jodi traveled to Costa Rica to learn Spanish better.
--Did not have many friends. Had a large circle but nobody she was very close with.
--Interes art continued.
--Worked in high school at her Dad's restaurant. Worked as a server from the age of 15. Worked afternoons and weekends.
--Jodi did not graduate high school because at the time, says it is complicated.
--Jodi dropped out of high school. She was living with her boyfriend at the time outside of Yreka.
--Jodi moved out of her parents home to live with the boyfriend because she was getting tired of the discipline. A few months before she turned 18 her parents grounded her until she was to turn 19 because she skipped a class. She skipped the class to study for an exam. She was studying and her Dad found her in her car and grounded her for a few months until she turned 18.
--This was towards the end of her senior year in high school in May.
--Got Fs because she "let it all fall apart".
--There was a physical incident of abuse where she was knocked against the door frame and Jodi then moved in with her boyfriend. Packed boxes and moved them to the boyfriends. Most of the stuff was at his place so when she was grounded she moved out.
--Turned 18 that summer and worked at a restaurant full time as there was bills to pay.
--Bobby Juarez was the boyfriend and he was unemployed. Bobby was three years older than Jodi. He had never been employed at that point.
--Met Juarez when she was 15, the first summer she moved to Yreka, the carnival came to town and she saw Juarez walking in a crowd. He caught her eye. He was dressed in 18th century goth clothing. It was July/August and it was hot and Juarez was dressed in a black suit and a high collared white shirt. Long dark curly hair. Jodi found Juarez intriguing.
--Spend the day at the fair, was waiting for her friends to go on the zipper ride. Saw Juarez again and he motioned for Jodi to come over. She walked up to him. They went on the zipper ride together, they parted and she did not see him for a while.
--later saw Juarez at a homecoming football game. They reintroduced themselves and Jodi gave him her phone number.
--They did not date right away, they were just friends for several months, Juarez was seeing somebody else at the time.
--Around new years they decided to become boyfriend/girlfriend.
--Jodi did not have a car or her licence yet. Juarez would come to town and meet her at a gas station by the school. They would hang out and hold hands.
--Juarez wanted to move to San Franciso and had other wild ideas and Jodi was 15 so she broke up with him.
--Juarez maintained the belief in vampires and read Ann Rice novels and wanted to go to San Fran to look for vampires.
--Jodi broke up with Juarez over the telephone. Juarez was very upset. Jodi says he didn't take it well. Nurmi asks what that means and Martinez objects.
 
Dr. JD is responding just like an expert witness is supposed to with her unbias and professional opinions.

If the defense witnesses would have been even close to this, then the jury would have given them the respect they deserve. But they did not. Their witnesses were obviously bias and ridiculous and so the jury cast them aside as they should and their questions they asked proved this.

Nobody has a problem with truthful testimony even if it is not necessarily favorable to the prosecution, but the key is that it has to be truthful and unbias. Both of which were obviously not the case with the defense witnesses. The jury saw right through this. Which is no surprise to me.

How in the world could the defense team even begin to think they could fool 12 people on the jury with the crud they threw at them. Its unbelievable and it truly makes me think that I could have prepared a better defense for Jodi without any experience being a laywer.

I'm flabergasted at their lousy approach.

I'm with you. Unfortunately, they have to work with what they've got. And what they've got is Jodi.

I've never understood how the defense can come in and basically throw everything at the wall, and see what sticks. I realize the prosecution bears the burden of proof, but shouldn't the defense have to at least be truthful?

And then I think, well, if a defendant claims they were abused, their attorney prepares their defense as if their client was abused. It doesn't matter if it's actually true or not. The attorney is operating under the assumption that it is true.

So then how do you figure in claiming the man your client admittedly murdered was a pedophile? What does that have to do with your client murdering him, even though she's claiming self-defense? This is clearly just character assassination. How does it even work it's way into the defense strategy? If he's a pedophile, he deserved to be slaughtered so go easy on my client - she basically performed community service by getting rid of this guy?

The only thing I can figure is, Jodi said she wanted all these things included in her defense and her attorneys had to do it because she's in control.

I don't understand how this defense was prepared and how it fits legally. Clearly I'm not a lawyer or legalistic in any way, but I do not understand what the TH's mean when they say the defense team is doing what they're supposed to by "muddying up the waters". Well, how is that seeing justice done? How is that doing what you're supposed to do? If she's guilty, she deserves a fair trial, but shouldn't that be a fair trial about the truth? Not a bunch of made up crap, smoke and mirrors to confuse the jury so they forget the horrible things she's done?

Sorry for the off-sides rambling. I got on a roll... :/

MHOO
 
Good grief I just waited for a nurse to leave my kid's hospital room so I could listen to a fart by Arias :facepalm:

Sorry to hear your Child is in Hospital. LOL I checked it out too but i didn't hear anything or see her blush. Perhaps i was not looking at the correct one.
 
I've seen some of her hand drawn stuff, but have any of Jodi's 'professional' photos been shown?
 
Born and raised lol. Fun fact, Santa Maria is a 20 minute drive and Santa Maria style tri-tip is the best BBQ ever :-)

I lived on Vandy AFB for 6 months....
Got some great ink in Santa Maria....
 
I heard many times in this case, you're supposed to have a good faith basis when you suggest something in a question. If this is good faith, JW was badly misinformed. They don't even need Walker to testify to prove it. They can just produce her book. It says the same 6 criteria still on page 42.

The Battered Woman Syndrome - Lenore E. Walker - 3rd Edition (2009)

I'm just trying to understand WHY Wilmot said this. Was she trying to intimidate the witness somehow? She is unshakeable IMO. She didn't bite.
 
Can anyone tell me where to find the full interview of Sandy Arias with detective Flores? TIA
 
Sorry to hear your Child is in Hospital. LOL I checked it out too but i didn't hear anything or see her blush. Perhaps i was not looking at the correct one.

Lol, thanks Bravo....I didn't hear it either. It sounded like someone went psssstt. OMG lol, why do I care!?
 
JB&C-- oh yes... When I quit drinking, it was helpful to officially rule out hangovers as the problem and pursue the migraine diagnosis.

I get botox injections for migraines (real treatment). Every three months at my nuerologist, a series of injections all over my head, neck, forehead. It's reduced the frequency and intensity of the migraines.
Only problem is my face is frozen like a Beverly Hills housewife. :gasp:

My secret guilty pleasure. O/T RHOC - Vicki looks like CRAP!:moo:
 
Thank you all for the kind words. I'm still watching her videos and BLOWN AWAY. As the cop is trying to leave she won't shut up... this is the most honest view of her. This is her fear of being abandoned or left alone. She needs focus on her, people paying attention and she does this by staling time. I have a feeling this is where her BPD comes in, because I had a very nasty habit of doing this in arguments with an ex.

But watching her feel nothing - nothing at all.. is just "wow". And her talking to herself about her f'in make-up! And the singing. I can't tell if she's faking that aspect or if this is her. If this is really her - then WOW. I find it interesting the lyrics she chooses out of the song too "I didn't hear you breath". Uh. hmm. She cares what she looks like and her entire cry is fake. Which we all know but I want to point that out lol. It is 100% fake as she stops it and starts it at will. I've never seen anything like this in a woman. this is scary. Just flat out scary. I can't imagine what she's like upset.
 
I don't know but what stood out for me was her claim that Jodi was "normal" in her view. Never witnessed any inappropriate behavior. I don't believe her. That or she is a lousy judge of character. She had to have witnessed something in all that time they spent together. IMO

This friend has been on NG twice. Both times, she has sounded very strange. She seems to have a difficult time getting her words out. Last night, Nancy had to finish a sentence for her. I find myself getting very aggravated listening to her.
 
I think you're probably right in that it came from ALV originally, but I suspect that JW did not understand what ALV was saying -- she has been pretty dodgy with this material generally with this witness in cross. My suspicion (particularly after hearing Walker tonight on NG) was that ALV was talking about the changing use and particularly the theoretical framework behind the six criteria -- Walker noted that that has changed, but that does not mean that the criteria are no longer in use. I think JW just grabbed onto the "changed" part, remembered it, and thought she could challenge Dr. D on that basis.

:cow:

This. Plus I noticed that the current criteria Walker recited did not match in several particulars the 6-point list put up in the NG video right after she listed them. I've missed all this week of the trial so far, though, so I don't know which criteria DeMarte used. The ones Walker spoke or the ones NG posted in the video. Anyone know which?
 
I don't know but what stood out for me was her claim that Jodi was "normal" in her view. Never witnessed any inappropriate behavior. I don't believe her. That or she is a lousy judge of character. She had to have witnessed something in all that time they spent together. IMO

The pictures they had on of Jodi when she was younger looked normal. I almost found myself feeling....BUT I stopped myself. We all need to get back to the reason we're all here. She butchered Travis Alexander on June 4, 2008 and the road to justice has been a long time coming. One day closer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
117
Guests online
497
Total visitors
614

Forum statistics

Threads
608,356
Messages
18,238,156
Members
234,351
Latest member
nh_lopez
Back
Top