BritsKate.... Oscar sinks or swims on this Screaming Woman.. the entire case rests upon it, and unless Roux and Oscar can eliminate this haunting sound , he is gone to hell.
I agree that Roux and Oscar have tried every damn thing that may even hint or hope at that sound of the Screaming Woman being a figment of peoples imagination, a collective mistake in hearing among strangers at the same time, a try at it being Oscar screaming, every thing that may have the slightest hope of being adjudicated as remotely possible, yet reasonable.. its the unreason of the ideas that Roux and Oscar are floating that is going to sink them 40 fathoms down. . they just cannot come up with a reasonably possible concept for that sound to be happening.
I agree that Roux and Oscar have tried every damn thing that may even hint or hope at that sound of the Screaming Woman being a figment of peoples imagination, a collective mistake in hearing among strangers at the same time, a try at it being Oscar screaming, every thing that may have the slightest hope of being adjudicated as remotely possible, yet reasonable.. its the unreason of the ideas that Roux and Oscar are floating that is going to sink them 40 fathoms down. . they just cannot come up with a reasonably possible concept for that sound to be happening.