bourne
"The truth shall set you free." ~JUSTICE FOR REBEC
- Joined
- Aug 10, 2012
- Messages
- 2,406
- Reaction score
- 15
Totally agree, and this would be *very critical* to establish using Max's medical records and testimony from his caregivers, if the criminal investigation were ever to be reopened (which I highly doubt). Max's caregivers could ALSO provide insight into the dynamics that were being displayed to caregivers between Jonah and Dina at the hospital-- was there anger at each other? Anger at Rebecca? Was anyone verbalizing that Rebecca or XZ hurt Max? What questions were they asking docs and nurses? What was their interaction with each other, and with staff individually? What was their demeanor?
However, since Dina's comments are in evidence that she believed Max was recovering, it provides support to excuse Dina from the lawsuit (in combination with the lately found video evidence of her at Rady). And for Mr. Greer to argue that if Rebecca thought Max was at least stable, or improving slightly, she would be less likely to have committed an impulsive, very strange suicide, that looked like a murder.
The "Max was getting better" story from Dina in her deposition is inconsistent with Jonah's claim he phoned Rebecca with a late night "he took a turn for the worse" VM, which precipitated a guilt- induced suicide.
If we were to have access to Max's medical records, and testimony from his doctors, it might reveal evidence that could support a conspiracy to murder her, or support the murder without a conspiracy.
Right now, Mr. Greer has to go with what is in evidence, and that is Dina's comments that she "thought" Max was improving.
The really interesting thing is that the most consistent explanation is that Max was in dire condition, with a grim prognosis from the time of admission, to the time of Rebecca's death. Then Jonah's alleged voicemail contents are consistent with what Dina told the writer about the day of Rebecca's death-- that she was on her way in to get the results of Max's latest MRI, which showed the basal ganglia necrosis. And consistent from the seriousness of the situation as we know it from the EMS report. And consistent with Max's eventual diagnosis of brain death with organ donation less than 48 hours after Rebecca's death.
Max's actual condition (as documented in his unavailable medical records, and by testimony of his doctors) provides justification and a motive for Rebecca's murder and/or a conspiracy to murder her. OR-- provides a motive for the circumstances of an astonishing and impulsive, and elaborate, suicide scene-- but without any actual evidence that she ever had any suicidal ideation or history of any kind of mental illness.
And it's also why it would be so important to know if Adam ever took Ambien the night of Rebecca's death.
That's why Max's actual condition is so very relevant to Rebecca's death circumstances, IMO.
I believe irrespective of Max’s condition, the murderer was hell bent on condemning and punishing Rebecca to the fullest and that meant assaulting, torturing, hanging and humiliating Rebecca in death.