Recent content by PGHJW

I never get my hopes up anymore but it would be nice for there to finally be closure. The fact that a "she" is mentioned in the letter mirrors a very real seeming explanation of what happened to Cherrie maybe about ten years ago posted on some sort of local board. It wasn't Topix but I don't...

I was five minutes away from her last alleged sighting on Saturday and it didn't come to me that it was the anniversary. There's little left here after 50 years. The "friend" isn't talking. The one suspect is dead. The other probably isn't talking if he's still alive. Finding the remains would...

Whatever happened with the fellas making fajitas? Wasn't that the smoking gun?

A lot of rumors flying. I think it's time to reopen this discussion.

"The tape" is one of the most frustrating cold case elements I've ever seen. It's obvious that the transcript is just a small portion. The article about it talks of a seven minute confession from Tywee. Tywee barely says anything in the transcript. And it's impossible to tell how Barclay "feels"...

Well, I guess we now know AI is useless. They do not look at all alike.

Oh I'm sure that's why. Like I said it's a fitting title for a Pittsburgh mystery show. But if QED has any sort of legal claim on it I can't imagine they'll sit still.

Odd that she uses the name "Nebby" for her podcast. Rick Sebak used that for a series of half hour shows a few years ago. It definitely fits for a mystery podcast, I just wonder if WQED had anything to say about it.

Was there really never a Websleuths thread on her before last Friday? A podcast called "The Deck" did a very long series on her. Mixed feelings on it although I come away with a different thought than I do on most cold cases. I mostly think that named "suspects" in a cold case usually aren't...

I wonder if anyone from up that way remembers an odd tasting breakfast that summer? I'll stick to Jimmy Dean.

Too much Murder, She Wrotein' goin' on up in here.

Going by an article from a few years ago it looks like they at least were at that point. I can see some obscure ones, unfortunately, falling by the wayside, but this one has so much "going for it." Great possibility of sordid scandal, entire family killed and it at least was at one point fairly...

You would think with how high profile this one is/was and that it wasn't just one person that it would be fairly high priority, but it's all up to whoever's in charge of it. Also, it seems more often than not that these sort of results/resolutions pop up out of nowhere. They're kept close to...

But what about Grandma Mannindrag who kidnapped her? What happened there?

I'm fairly sure that the Reva Jean Emery that I found awhile back in listings was her.