Recent content by rob525

  1. R

    PA - Ellen Greenberg, 27, Philly teacher’s brutal stabbing, ruled suicide but possible homicide, Jan 2011

    Interesting points. I wonder about the bruising. I believe that it is all in the medical examiners report. I also wonder if the bruising could have been a result of teaching younger children. My wife deals with younger and special needs children and just the other day she was bitten requiring a...
  2. R

    PA - Ellen Greenberg, 27, Philly teacher’s brutal stabbing, ruled suicide but possible homicide, Jan 2011

    Yes. the locked door is a puzzler ( If it was truly locked). I do agree that EG locking the door amounts to someone performing a logical and coherent action while in the midst of a totally illogical and not reasonable episode. Seems like it would have required a moment of clarity that does not...
  3. R

    PA - Ellen Greenberg, 27, Philly teacher’s brutal stabbing, ruled suicide but possible homicide, Jan 2011

    I just finished the Detective Perspective podcast and listened to the interview with Dr. Banerjee. I agree that it was done well and very informative. I have heard nothing that remotely supports suicide although this is a weird case to try to explain. Reason being, I haven't really heard much...
  4. R

    TX - Shots fired, injuries reported at ICE facility in Dallas - Sept 24, 2025

    I think one issue many people have in these situations is the urge to try to find logical reasoning in totally illogical actions. I.e. if the shooter was anti ICE, why did he seemingly target the detainees? That is a logical question. However, an illogical mind may not have reached the same...
  5. R

    NC - Iryna Zarutska, 23, slain on Commuter Rail Line, Charlotte - Some Content may be Graphic - Aug 22, 2025 *Arrest*

    I am not buying the mental illness argument. Certainly there is some level of mental illness and it played a factor. I think there has to be some level of that illness in most crimes where one human being took the life of another but, as in most cases, he knew exactly what he was doing. It is...
  6. R

    NJ NJ - William Jamison, 33, Linden, 27 March 1981

    I just finished the three episodes of BIll Jamison's case as it was just republished on the podcast. I am relieved that I am not the only one that thought Mr. Walter's "profile" was complete horse manure. By his own admission even the family did not know much about WJs personal life and having...
  7. R

    NJ NJ- Christopher Thomas, 16, Honor Student, Randomly Shot by Stranger w. 'Rocky H P Show Makeup', Rockaway Townsquare Mall, 1 Oct '82, *New Initiative*

    Soon to be 43 years. There was a mention of a new initiative and testing of items from the scene using new technology not available in 1982. That would lead me to believe that they are trying to test potential DNA samples. If so, I wonder if they have had any success creating a profile.
  8. R

    MN- Minneapolis, mass shooting at church, multiple fatalities, possible explosive device found. Aug 2025

    “I know we have not been successful in talking to the shooter’s mother yet at this time,” O’Hara said. “But there continue to be efforts made to get that done.” This is concerning.
  9. R

    MN- Minneapolis, mass shooting at church, multiple fatalities, possible explosive device found. Aug 2025

    I think this guy just wanted to kill himself and make as big of a news splash as possible. He targeted everyone and everything that would check the box to ensure that his name stays in everyone's mind for years to come. I have a brother-in law who could be considered supportive of his kids. In...
  10. R

    MN- Minneapolis, mass shooting at church, multiple fatalities, possible explosive device found. Aug 2025

    This guy was just all over the place with the mental illness. I am trying to put reason to his actions where likely no reason is to be found. Citing Nazi rhetoric seems to go against everything that this guy built his life around. None of it makes sense. I agree with the premise that most of...
  11. R

    LA LA - Vicki Carriere, 18, Waggaman, 12 July 1987

    Just listened to the Vanished episode on this case. That podcast is, at times, very frustrating. There seems to be instances where they gloss over seemingly important details. In this case, they mention the sister of Vickie being at the fishing camp at the same time but there is just not much...
  12. R

    OH OH- Boardman, WhtMale, 18-50, UP8548, hit by car, cross tattoo. August 1982.

    Another thought just struck me however it would likely not lead anywhere. I wonder if this guy was work seasonally at one of the farms in the area? Perhaps the farmer thought that one of there folks just decided they didn't like farm work and move on. I remember living in that area as a kid and...
  13. R

    Clinton David Brink, 43 & Cristen Amanda Brink, 41 found on trail - Devil's Den State Park, AR- 26 July, 2025 #2 *Arrest*

    Just somewhat random thoughts. I am not 100% sold that this was an attempted child kidnapping. I agree that it is a plausible scenario but there are so many questions. Why choose a summer, weekend day in a park well populated with people? Why choose a family of four? Certainly, common sense...

Guardians Monthly Goal

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
168
Guests online
1,374
Total visitors
1,542

Forum statistics

Threads
635,395
Messages
18,675,383
Members
243,200
Latest member
inglishmariaxx
Back
Top