Recent content by Starmelody

  1. S

    Discussion Thread #60 - 14.9.12 ~ the appeal~

    I do recall Nel questioning OP as to why he didn't check out the window for more intruders after he fired his gun. I will have to go back and check to make sure- but I do remember something along these lines.
  2. S

    Discussion Thread #60 - 14.9.12 ~ the appeal~

    these are some of the key points - something triggered a prolonged argument that ran into the early hours of the morning and delayed dinner. (Such as changes OP was making to the contract). The reason I believe it was a prolonged argument is because of the food contents in reevas stomach (...
  3. S

    Discussion Thread #60 - 14.9.12 ~ the appeal~

    Regarding the jeans outside the bathroom window. I've been wondering about this too. One scenario could be: reeva attempts to put on the first pair of jeans in the bedroom. Oscar grabs them and throws them to the floor. She then grabs another pair from her bag and runs to the bathroom to put...
  4. S

    Discussion Thread #60 - 14.9.12 ~ the appeal~

    I was referring to the 'strike back'incident as an example. The contract that he was going through on the night he killed her would have been for upcoming project not 'strike back'. Sorry if I wasn't clear
  5. S

    Discussion Thread #60 - 14.9.12 ~ the appeal~

    What I find interesting is that in the video when he puts on his prosthesis and runs back to the bathroom, the gun vanishes. Yet it was found on the floor in the bathroom. On the Stand in court he claims that he placed the gun on the bed while he put his legs on and then picked it up again...
  6. S

    Discussion Thread #60 - 14.9.12 ~ the appeal~

    Maybe,but if that were the case why did they have dinner so late and argue for so long. Neighbour heard arguing. Why would she grab his phone at 2-3am. I just feel that it was an argument that delayed everything that night. It appeared that they hadn't even gone to bed. He would have a pass...
  7. S

    Discussion Thread #60 - 14.9.12 ~ the appeal~

    I keep wondering what actually pushed him to grab his gun and kill her. One senario I was thinking about relates to the contract (Reeva's) that OP claims he went through that night. I was wondering if he was making changes that she was not happy about and this then sparked the argument. In...
  8. S

    Post sentencing discussion and the upcoming appeal

    12. Oh and how he the gun went off on its own in Tashas.
  9. S

    Post sentencing discussion and the upcoming appeal

    7. He wanted to cover the LED light on the stereo with the jeans 8. He searched for Reeva in the dark after he thought he had shot her (not to mention the way he actually felt around for her) 9. The manner in which he says he brought the fan inside- not turning his head towards the bed nor...
  10. S

    Post sentencing discussion and the upcoming appeal

    "Secondly, that the presence of wood splinters among the clean white stripes along the back and sides of the bloodied toilet suggest it was flushed before Pistorius pulled the trigger, with the water continuing to run as Reeva collapsed into it. If she had run into the toilet to hide from an...
  11. S

    Post sentencing discussion and the upcoming appeal

    Also, there was a similar incident in south africa 2 weeks before in which a man was in bed, heard the window in the bathroom open, got this gun and as his wife was coming out of the toilet he was startled and shot her. I'm sure OP would have heard this on the news, so it wouldn't have be hard...
  12. S

    Post sentencing discussion and the upcoming appeal

    There are so many things I find strange about the night Reeva was killed. 1. That Reeva didn't have a shower. (she was killed wearing the same top she was wearing when she arrived to the estate) 2. That there was no intimacy between the 2 of them. OP had asked her to stay the night, that...
  13. S

    Post sentencing discussion and the upcoming appeal

    Thanks so much for the welcoming. I've been reading many of the oscar posts and finallty decided to join. My partner thinks I am obsessed with the case, but it really bothers me that we don't know what really happened. I've watched the trial till the end, hoping I would get some answers-...
  14. S

    Post sentencing discussion and the upcoming appeal

    I also believe that if the cousin had not testified, things would have been differenet. OP would be at home right now.
  15. S

    Post sentencing discussion and the upcoming appeal

    thank you Ok, let's forget the ear witnesses. massipa disregarded them anyway. Let's even assume there were NO ear witnesses and go back to the forsensic/expert evidence. According to both Mangena and pathologist, Reeva had time to scream and would have screamed due to the nature of the...
See more

Guardians Monthly Goal

10 20 30 40 50
Our goal for the month is 50 new Guardians members to sign up. Have you been thinking about becoming a member? Click here to find out how!

Staff online

Members online

... and 91 more.
Total: 1,943 (members: 92, guests: 1,851)

Online statistics

Members online
92
Guests online
1,851
Total visitors
1,943
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Forum statistics

Threads
636,276
Messages
18,693,744
Members
243,590
Latest member
micabella121169
Back
Top