Hercule Holmes
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Dec 15, 2024
- Messages
- 40
- Reaction score
- 479
Hi all. Have followed the case all along, but have only read here.
There is a bit of current discussion on another site (begins with R) around the similiarities between Bung and Karmein Chan. Reference is made to the reported sighting on Harcourt Rd. 130 metres from the school. A poster has said this sighting was made by a young boy and found to be false (he was lying). I've never been aware of that sighting being officially ruled out? I know it's never been confirmed and the last confirmed sighting is via the neighbour whose dog barked out the window as she passed, but does anyone know whether there is any truth to this?
I do find it a bit surprising that police don't do something like official annual updates on the anniversary of cases like this. I don't see the value in confusion around whether a sighting is still considered valid or not. They could come out and say whether there are any updates on the information that has been released publicly. Understandably, they may hold something back and they are not going to update that publicly. For example, we have no idea whether anyone has come forward and identified themselves as the driver of either the white Falcon (Boronia) or the white Kingswood (Rowville). If one or both was explained away as legitimate, it saves people reporting things that are irrelevant. You would assume not, but that's all we can do - assume.
They've gone well past the point of solving this without public help, and yet it's hard not to feel that they don't help the public help them
There is a bit of current discussion on another site (begins with R) around the similiarities between Bung and Karmein Chan. Reference is made to the reported sighting on Harcourt Rd. 130 metres from the school. A poster has said this sighting was made by a young boy and found to be false (he was lying). I've never been aware of that sighting being officially ruled out? I know it's never been confirmed and the last confirmed sighting is via the neighbour whose dog barked out the window as she passed, but does anyone know whether there is any truth to this?
I do find it a bit surprising that police don't do something like official annual updates on the anniversary of cases like this. I don't see the value in confusion around whether a sighting is still considered valid or not. They could come out and say whether there are any updates on the information that has been released publicly. Understandably, they may hold something back and they are not going to update that publicly. For example, we have no idea whether anyone has come forward and identified themselves as the driver of either the white Falcon (Boronia) or the white Kingswood (Rowville). If one or both was explained away as legitimate, it saves people reporting things that are irrelevant. You would assume not, but that's all we can do - assume.
They've gone well past the point of solving this without public help, and yet it's hard not to feel that they don't help the public help them