Gilgo Beach LISK Serial Killer, Rex Heuermann, charged with 3 murders, July 2023

[Kikalina]

Qq

L

Wondering if NY has some basements similar to some in Pa and Ohio. Sometimes called 'Pittsburgh basements/showers" that have a shower in them. Most are just an open shower area in the concrete or tile with a drain, not like a typical bathroom shower area. I guess that could be ideal for dismemberment. Ugh

We don’t have those in Suffolk county. Not sure about Nassau county though.

 

[investigatefred]

I've never believed that the killer of the GB4 had anything to do the other Long Island murders. But I have always suspected that he might have been responsible for the AC4. I still share that view, 13 years later.

Me too! The AC4 were more similar than the other beach victims.

With the AC4 being murdered during a one month span, (October-November 2006), what are the chances he could have made multiple trips, at least 3hr drive each way, during that time span? I know he has amittedly made trips there, but I can't make it make sense in my mind how he'd pull that one off? I personally don't feel he is the AC4 killer. I think he is responsible for some of the others, but that's JMO.

 

[investigatefred]

Qq

L

Wondering if NY has some basements similar to some in Pa and Ohio. Sometimes called 'Pittsburgh basements/showers" that have a shower in them. Most are just an open shower area in the concrete or tile with a drain, not like a typical bathroom shower area. I guess that could be ideal for dismemberment. Ugh

Off topic...I lived in Pittsburgh for several years back in the mid 90s and recall several of the basements had random toilets in the basement. We called it the "Pittsburgh Potty" lol. Just a random toilet in the middle of unfinished basements, no showers, sinks (other than maybe a mop sink). It was weird.

 

[x_files]

Plus dismembering creates a lot of DNA evidence

true but if he did it at his house, garage, and shed/yard and no one ever investigated he could easily get away with it until he was finally caught.
I'm curious what the Luminol picked up and especially on the floor tiles.

 

[x_files]

I think RH was cheap. He paid them for sex (maybe offering double the standard rate) and then killed them to get his money back, plus taking whatever money they had on them already. News articles say his wife was always poor and drove an old car, so he hoards his money. He never intended to pay. Also, in order to dismember a body, you have to have a place to do it, like a murder house. Maybe he had access to a vacant house at one time, but later lost that.

Gary Ridgeway said he killed the SWs because he couldn't afford his sex addiction and that way he got his money back. Pretty sad if he is being 100% honest, I think more comes into play though.

 

[x_files]

I agree completely. The rich-boy crowd wouldn't want anything to do with RH. They might hire him to get building code hassles handled in the city, but they wouldn't want him in their personal lives. He's not likeable.

jmo

They might use him to clean up a mess or dirty work though.

 

[Warwick7]

Exclusive | Fellow inmates not ‘happy’ with Gilgo Beach suspect Rex Heuermann

“I don’t think people would be too happy if he was into population,” Riverhead inmate Philip Walker said on Friday.

nypost.com

 

[Momoffourboys]

It’s the 1K subsection attached to the penal law charge. Very rare to see even a class A felony murder charge in Nassau and Suffolk Counties, at least. I’ve never seen that subsection used.

Found this explanation.
BBM

New York Penal Law 125.27(1)(a)(xi)

In order for a jury to find Heuermann guilty of Murder in the First Degree, the District Attorney’s Office must prove that Heuermann intended to cause the death of each of the women and in fact caused their deaths. Additionally, this subsection requires that he caused the death of two or more additional people withing New York State in separate events or transactions within a time frame of two years and did so pursuant to a common scheme or plan.

In the event a jury finds that each of the elements were not met, for example, only finding that the prosecution proved one murder beyond a reasonable doubt or that there was not a common scheme or plan, prosecutors could still secure a conviction for Murder in the Second Degree.

New York Penal Law 125.25(1)

A far easier crime to prove without the needed proof of additional murders or a common scheme or plan, a jury must only find that Heuermann intended to kill or cause the death of one of the women and in fact took at least one of their lives.

 

[x_files]

My hunch is he gets off on making women uncomfortable. I don't think he would kidnap a "nice" woman from a public park, but he might have a chance of engaging her in a conversation that makes her feel "less than" and out of place, vulnerable.

I'm sure many/most of us have encountered guys who made us feel like that. I used to wonder if the men thought they had a chance of success, but now I realize that making a woman uncomfortable and scared IS the success. And if you rebuff them too much, they call you a name as you walk way, preferably loud so you're now publicly shaken and put down.

Just a hunch.

jmo

Good point! Yes, there's way too many of those creeper types.

 

[Emilie D]

With the AC4 being murdered during a one month span, (October-November 2006), what are the chances he could have made multiple trips, at least 3hr drive each way, during that time span? I know he has amittedly made trips there, but I can't make it make sense in my mind how he'd pull that one off? I personally don't feel he is the AC4 killer. I think he is responsible for some of the others, but that's JMO.

Disappearing for a few hours or half a day could be easily explained by a business meeting. The hotel where the AC4 were murdered was a flop house and no one was watching it. No one cared (media and pd) when all of these women went missing. That’s why serial killers generally choose sex workers as victims. IMO it’s far more likely that RH is responsible for the AC4 than the other Long Island victims (outside of the GB4).

 

[x_files]

When I lived in Amsterdam a lot of my friends were Sw's but they worked on the windows and had alarms and ways of contacting each other if things went wrong as they often did with drunken tourists etc.
It was safe and because it was government regulated it was safe sexually too.

So many dangers without protection.

I'm so glad you survived and thank you for bringing your unique insight.

I would prefer sex work be legal so they have security and support from local police rather than disdain.

 

[Warwick7]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1682865601688244224

 

[ohiobuckeyegirl]

Off topic...I lived in Pittsburgh for several years back in the mid 90s and recall several of the basements had random toilets in the basement. We called it the "Pittsburgh Potty" lol. Just a random toilet in the middle of unfinished basements, no showers, sinks (other than maybe a mop sink). It was weird.

When you gotta go, you gotta go lol The showers used to be for the men when they were dirty so they didn't go walking through the whole house after coming in from work. I never figured out the toilet thing. I guess you can never have too many toilets haha

 

[Warwick7]

I would prefer sex work be legal so they have security and support from local police rather than disdain.

MOO
They would be security and support or they would be a James Burke. He had a real devotion for advancing prostitution in his own backyard.

Cop who bungled Gilgo Beach investigation was a cross dresser

A Long Island attorney of two Gilgo beach murder victims calls out former Suffolk County Police Chief for deviant behavior of prostitution, drugs and pornography.

www.dailymail.co.uk

 

[Warwick7]

"But for years, the investigation into their deaths stalled, with Burke shutting down work on Gilbert's case by labelling her death accidental, even though she had a wound in her neck consistent with a drill."

Cop who bungled Gilgo Beach investigation was a cross dresser

A Long Island attorney of two Gilgo beach murder victims calls out former Suffolk County Police Chief for deviant behavior of prostitution, drugs and pornography.

www.dailymail.co.uk

 

[x_files]

MOO
They would be security and support or they would be a James Burke. He had a real devotion for advancing prostitution in his own backyard.

Cop who bungled Gilgo Beach investigation was a cross dresser

A Long Island attorney of two Gilgo beach murder victims calls out former Suffolk County Police Chief for deviant behavior of prostitution, drugs and pornography.

www.dailymail.co.uk

true

 

[Ruminations]

I suspect their shared interests might outweigh the considerations by the "country club set". Theirs is a tiny percentage of the population. I wonder if they welcome people with similar interests or would they always expect betrayal?

Kinda my excessively subtlety made point.

MOO

 

[LadyL]

Probably for too-obvious reason, the King.

However, on seeing that belt, I started wondering if Rex was RH's true given name. I wondered if he was baptized William, after grandfather, hence the initials on the belt. (Or else, someone liked visiting thrift stores). Rex is a popular nickname, though.

this may have been answered cause I'm way behind again but what is Rex a nickname for? I don't think I've ever heard of someone named Rex

 

[LadyL]

I believe that to be the case. My friends cousin did so much coke one night he called the 911 tell them his house was being stormed by armed intruders. They arrested him for coke possession. Saw nothing on his cameras. The conclusion = a coke induced physcosis. Many people have called 911 while on drugs and described things that didn't exist.
Pak was her armed security. He begged her to go outside. I believe I read He passed a polygraph. I also believe brewer let the police inside and Hacketts whole Family was home.

1 small missing bone after 19 months in the elements. Snow, heat, rainstorms, high tides. Hell 3 months before SG body was found we got hit with the remnants of hurricane irene. 400k ppl lost power from wind and rain. The area where SG was found got clobbered during the storm.

ITA
I feel bad for her but I don't think she was a victim of murder

 

[FlukeU]

As for Rex popping out of the trees at the park in dirty clothing and harassing a young woman...I want to know where he came from and why he was filthy..what was he doing back there? is it a large area? If I am the detectives on this case I really want to know all his movements that day. Just saying..I find it very sus. mOO

The park (Brady Park) is small with a small wooded area, it’s should still be canvased with K9 Units, as should the much larger Massapequa Preserve which is a MUCH more likely dump site as it is massive, with many many access points available 24/7, and very dimly lit at night <modsnip: sleuthing friends/family> I’d be shocked if nothing turned up in there, truly. I believe ‘Blue’ the PO K9 who found the other four girl is now retired. Thank you Blue! While we’re at it, thank you officer Mellia (Blue’s PO handler) as well as a HUGE thank you to officer Udice from the task force for your efforts reviewing past evidence, and your attention to detail, and for naming Rex as a suspect first.