• #5,461
He looks like anyone else that has been accused of being a serial killer. I have read all the pages in the Heuermann threads where people comment what an ogre he is, how scary he looks, how he would look killing the women, etc. He doesn't look scary. He's just tall and heavy set. He doesn't walk weirdly. There was nothing odd about him in the interview with the WEIRDO French guy. There was nothing odd about him in the recorded phone call to whatever her name is.

And Costello's pimp who claimed to have seen his car is lying. Watch the old documentaries, read the old articles about LISK. Not once did he mention a car. Then all of a sudden, 13 years later, a pickup truck appears. Hell, they didn't even report Costello missing back when she was murdered.
8TB might seem like much, but it isn't really. Michael Brown will crush this case easily, just wait and see.

I suspect the real reason for his burner phones is because he has been with prostitutes and wants to keep it a secret from his wife. Some of his search history is pervy but him Googling the Long Island murders and serial killers 200 times is just a pudgy guy being interested in serial murders, especially close to home.

Not Quite!

According to a bail application prosecutors filed following Heuermann’s arrest, witnesses gave police a detailed description of a man who had visited Costello, one of the four women who bodies were found by police in 2010, shortly before her disappearance. The witness reports in the document describe him as an “ogre,” standing more than 6 feet 4 inches tall and driving a first-generation Chevrolet Avalanche. Tierney, the district attorney, confirmed in an interview that police had obtained the witness descriptions of the suspect’s appearance and his truck around the time Costello’s body was found in December 2010.

Three homicide investigators who worked on the case at the time provided little clarity on why the tip appears to not have been chased down. One of them, a supervisor who oversaw the case starting in 2011, said he was not made aware of the witness statements from the year earlier, which he called “inexcusable” and “beyond weird.”

 
  • #5,462
Not Quite!

According to a bail application prosecutors filed following Heuermann’s arrest, witnesses gave police a detailed description of a man who had visited Costello, one of the four women who bodies were found by police in 2010, shortly before her disappearance. The witness reports in the document describe him as an “ogre,” standing more than 6 feet 4 inches tall and driving a first-generation Chevrolet Avalanche. Tierney, the district attorney, confirmed in an interview that police had obtained the witness descriptions of the suspect’s appearance and his truck around the time Costello’s body was found in December 2010.

Three homicide investigators who worked on the case at the time provided little clarity on why the tip appears to not have been chased down. One of them, a supervisor who oversaw the case starting in 2011, said he was not made aware of the witness statements from the year earlier, which he called “inexcusable” and “beyond weird.”


The pimp and roommate, Dave Schaller, talked about a Frankenstein-looking guy twice his size. No car. <modsnip: not victim friendly/no source links>
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #5,463
  • #5,464
  • #5,465

'At one point in the courthouse, Rex Heuermann scanned the audience with a chilling gaze, appearing as if he was looking for someone''​

1690942208309.png
 
  • #5,466
He looks like anyone else that has been accused of being a serial killer. I have read all the pages in the Heuermann threads where people comment what an ogre he is, how scary he looks, how he would look killing the women, etc. He doesn't look scary. He's just tall and heavy set. He doesn't walk weirdly. There was nothing odd about him in the interview with the WEIRDO French guy. There was nothing odd about him in the recorded phone call to whatever her name is.

And Costello's pimp who claimed to have seen his car is lying. Watch the old documentaries, read the old articles about LISK. Not once did he mention a car. Then all of a sudden, 13 years later, a pickup truck appears. Hell, they didn't even report Costello missing back when she was murdered.
8TB might seem like much, but it isn't really. Michael Brown will crush this case easily, just wait and see.

I suspect the real reason for his burner phones is because he has been with prostitutes and wants to keep it a secret from his wife. Some of his search history is pervy but him Googling the Long Island murders and serial killers 200 times is just a pudgy guy being interested in serial murders, especially close to home. Maybe he's a websleuth?
Have you read the actual doc? You should. There is a lot more than just pervy google searches. They have a ton of cell data Linking him to the burner phones. And those burner phones linked to victims and their families.

 
  • #5,467
So, who is the witness who saw the car Amber Lynn Costello got into? It wasn't Schaller, that's for sure. And why didn't Schaller report her missing after September 2 2010? She wasn't found until December 13 that same year. That's a long time, especially if you knew how her last john looked like or what he drove.

Schaller himself mentions not seeing who she met that day:
 
  • #5,468
Have you read the actual doc? You should. There is a lot more than just pervy google searches. They have a ton of cell data Linking him to the burner phones. And those burner phones linked to victims and their families.


So he got burner phones but saved them all? What exactly connects the burner phones to the victims and their families? I thought the killer used the victim's phones to taunt families?
 
  • #5,469
So he got burner phones but saved them all? What exactly connects the burner phones to the victims and their families? I thought the killer used the victim's phones to taunt families?

This podcast breaks down the connection of the burner phones really well
 
  • #5,470
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #5,471
But there was a problem: The homicide detectives chasing the lead were bordering on mutiny.

Prosecutors believed the detectives refused to follow orders and clashed with federal partners, multiple high-level law enforcement officials familiar with the case said. Detectives, meanwhile, felt that the district attorney at the time, Tim Sini, was forcing them to investigate leads they had already ruled out while ratcheting up pressure to solve the case before his 2021 reelection bid. The tension grew so high that, at Sini’s urging, the case’s longtime lead detective was removed.

I am gifting this article, it's important enough.

Thank you for this article. I hate to think how many girls may have died over the years while law enforcement groups were bickering over jurisdiction.
 
  • #5,472
Thank you for this article. I hate to think how many girls may have died over the years while law enforcement groups were bickering over jurisdiction.

they chose not to see them as human.
 
  • #5,473
Any chance Rex would have been in Nebraska in 1997?

There’s a case of a man going barefoot into a gas station and shooting a woman who worked there.

His physical description is similar.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2904.jpeg
    IMG_2904.jpeg
    773.7 KB · Views: 90
  • #5,474
real hair or a cheap toupee? anyone know?
if you look at his high school yearbook photos which have been in MSM, it looks the same
 
  • #5,475
  • #5,476
Any chance Rex would have been in Nebraska in 1997?

There’s a case of a man going barefoot into a gas station and shooting a woman who worked there.

His physical description is similar.

I don't think he has that widow's peak in his hairline
 
  • #5,477
<modsnip: Quoted / referenced post was removed>

From the Bail app at pp. 7-8 (emphasis mine)

"After the client entered the home, a ruse was executed on the client whereby a person pretended to be the outraged boyfriend of Amber Costello and the client left from the residence, while Amber Costello retained the money the client had brought to pay for her services...

...Thereafter, at approximately 1:18 a.m., on September 2, after the ruse had been perpetrated, the burner cellphone sent a text message to the Costello Phone, which stated, “That was not nice so do i [sic] credit for next time.” Phone records show that the burner phone was located in Massapequa Park, within two minutes of this text message being sent.

.... the next day.. Ms. Costello was again contacted by the same client that was in the house the night before with the Avalanche. Further, “Amber told us that he wanted to see her again...

...the same burner cellphone from the previous evening again communicated with the Costello Phone...in Midtown Manhattan.... travel[ing] to Massapequa Park and had contacts with the Costello Phone at approximately 10:39 p.m. and 11:05 p.m.

Cell site records for the burner phone indicate that ... the phone [then] traveled to West Babylon in proximity to the residence of Amber Costello. Subsequently, Amber Costello left her own cellphone behind, walked out the front door of the residence, and was seen alive for the last time."


 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #5,478
Snipped and bolded.

A defendant in a U.S. court never has to prove innocence. It is the burden of the government (the prosecutors) to prove guilt.

And in this case, I think the prosecutors have enough for a jury to convict. The only defense, from what I can tell, would be to poke holes in the investigation and try to dismiss evidence from being presented in court. I don't think that tactic will work. He's toast, imo.

jmo

his defense will have to be that he just picked SWs who all happened to be killed by some one else- of course he called them....and he left hairs- of course he did. Not sure about the harassing calls to relatives. that's a tough one to explain away, but those will have to have been done by the other killer. wonder if he has any alibis for the days the victims disappeared. so long ago it would be unusual if he has calendars from those dates, but LE is saying it was when his family was away. He can have other SWs testify that he was always nice and polite to them; would not hurt a fly.
 
  • #5,479
  • #5,480
So he got burner phones but saved them all? What exactly connects the burner phones to the victims and their families? I thought the killer used the victim's phones to taunt families?
Your answer lies in the Bail Document.

 

Guardians Monthly Goal

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
151
Guests online
2,569
Total visitors
2,720

Thread Chapters

Forum statistics

Threads
646,066
Messages
18,853,852
Members
245,891
Latest member
42wallabyway
Top