IN IN - Hailey Buzbee, 17, Fishers, 5 Jan 2026

[cjaydub]

Fishers police searching for missing Hamilton Southeastern High School junior

There doesn't seem to be much information on this case. However, it seems that at least 3 girls have gone missing in the area since the year began.

 

[truthfinder2019]

The way that she executed this makes me believe that it was above her skill level and she was assisted,” Beau (her father) said. “She left the house without a lot of items that she would need to do this on her own… someone is assisting her because she does not have the resources.”

The family fears an individual outside of her immediate social circle may have used social media to influence her or coordinate her departure. Haley reportedly left the house on foot, and her cell phone was last pinged at the family’s residence, though it has not been located.


Physical: Biracial (light brown skin), 5’4″ tall, approximately 120 lbs.
Hair: Last seen with long braids; her natural hair is curly.
Clothing:Last seen wearing a white blouse, grey jeans, and a black puffer jacket.
Belongings: She was carrying a pink Vera Bradley duffle bag.

Fishers Father: Missing Daughter "Assisted" by Outside Influence

A Fishers family is desperately searching for their teenage daughter, Haley Paige Buzbee, who vanished from her home earlier this week under what her parents describe as "deeply concerning" circumstances.

wibc.com

 

[truthfinder2019]

https://www.facebook.com/100066843960986/posts/pfbid0Av9JwuZZyRLfGtzhsum4igniUgFXqbnXv8Z2aUJm1caLV8gjGvL6GDbA9sZyTXzjl

 

[truthfinder2019]

https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=pfbid029C7AGGxwzbJpEVKbkAtMGBAYEyzhFhLXX9yduuUwpJ4SPuMawCzr5Tt3SDrRBEP2l&id=100064440649688

 

[GraceG]

I moved to Chicago from Indianapolis when I got married. Fishers is an upscale area overall, and that particular subdivision is considered somewhat "luxury" homes ($500,00 - $800,000 in a city where the median home price is low 200,000s). A very safe area overall when I lived there so I can see her father worried it was an "outside influence" that helped her in leaving. The Fishers Police have been doing updates - no new news but here is their link. Log into Facebook

 

[swanniee11]

IMO, family members are posting they think she left between 3-4am that morning. Seems very much planned and their best option is to get all of her SM accounts, maybe even hire someone who knows how to dig. IMO.

 

[cjaydub]

From those of you who have followed these kinds of cases for some time, is it more likely her running away with an unapproved bf, someone nefariously recruiting her for SW, or just a basic runaway thing? Or does it just completely vary?

 

[truthfinder2019]

IMO, family members are posting they think she left between 3-4am that morning. Seems very much planned and their best option is to get all of her SM accounts, maybe even hire someone who knows how to dig. IMO.

I could not find any SM, I wonder if she has deleted them

 

[GraceG]

I could not find any SM, I wonder if she has deleted them

My granddaughters say that most of their frirends (16-17 age range) do NOT use their real names on social media.

 

[elinaaa_l]

The way that she executed this makes me believe that it was above her skill level and she was assisted,” Beau (her father) said. “She left the house without a lot of items that she would need to do this on her own… someone is assisting her because she does not have the resources.”

The family fears an individual outside of her immediate social circle may have used social media to influence her or coordinate her departure. Haley reportedly left the house on foot, and her cell phone was last pinged at the family’s residence, though it has not been located.


Physical: Biracial (light brown skin), 5’4″ tall, approximately 120 lbs.
Hair: Last seen with long braids; her natural hair is curly.
Clothing:Last seen wearing a white blouse, grey jeans, and a black puffer jacket.
Belongings: She was carrying a pink Vera Bradley duffle bag.

Fishers Father: Missing Daughter "Assisted" by Outside Influence

A Fishers family is desperately searching for their teenage daughter, Haley Paige Buzbee, who vanished from her home earlier this week under what her parents describe as "deeply concerning" circumstances.

wibc.com

wait do we know where she was last seen? was it js at her home and no other witnesses remember seeing her?

 

[elinaaa_l]

My granddaughters say that most of their frirends (16-17 age range) do NOT use their real names on social media.

they most likely have a jumble of their name, initials, etc. for example if my name is sarah brookes id probably use sb_rooks or something similar.

 

[Eli9]

From those of you who have followed these kinds of cases for some time, is it more likely her running away with an unapproved bf, someone nefariously recruiting her for SW, or just a basic runaway thing? Or does it just completely vary?

Yes, all of the above.

 

[otto]

There's also online luring using the ruse of becoming a famous model.

Example:

"Ottawa police say more victims have come forward since the arrest of an Ottawa man accused of luring young girls under the guise of potential modelling jobs, only to have those “jobs” turn into requests for sexual favours."

More victims come forward in alleged teen girl luring scheme

Ottawa police say more victims have come forward since the arrest of an Ottawa man accused of luring young girls under the guise of potential modelling jobs, only t…

ottawacitizen.com

 

[swanniee11]

From those of you who have followed these kinds of cases for some time, is it more likely her running away with an unapproved bf, someone nefariously recruiting her for SW, or just a basic runaway thing? Or does it just completely vary?

It could be any of these, I would hate to think or treat a missing teen as " a runaway" when it could be something even more serious. IMO

 

[borndem]

It could be any of these, I would hate to think or treat a missing teen as " a runaway" when it could be something even more serious. IMO

Yes, so scary. Hoping for good news, but the thought of the "modeling jobs" makes my blood run cold.
We've seen this before, and very often the news is not good.
Positive thoughts for her and for those who love her.

It seems to never stop.