OK, Noah Presgrove, 19, Sept 4, 2023, Comanche, homicide, attended a house party, found on side of road

yes there's nothing normal about the actions taken by the teens that night. i've been to so, so, SO many rural parties as a teenager that included guns, drinking, and drugs,, and i don't understand other commenters saying that the party seemed really normal. they flipped a vehicle, they took videos of a kid showering and losing consciousness, like wtf. that sort of stuff never occurred at any party i went to.
I've been to parties just like this, and I find absolutely nothing unusual about it. Haven't been to one where someone rolled an ATV, but I was at one where someone drunkenly drove a dirt bike into a lake. We didn't take videos of this stuff, simply because smart phones weren't a thing.

People fighting, people coming and going, if you asked 10 people what happened they'd all tell you completely different stories.
 
Can you provide a source for "they took videos of a kid showering and losing consciousness," please? I have only seen this is one of many rumors on social media. I think we need to be careful here when stating unsubstantiated rumors as facts. MOO
That's the thing with this case... There are SO MANY rumours around it, it's difficult to know what is fact. I did read posts from approximately 8-10 people who said they had seen the "shower video" but nobody could find it to share it for everyone else to confirm it exists.
I attempted to follow a cpl of the fbk groups about this case at the beginning and for about 6 months, and clearly 'anything goes' on there. I do think that any information that is remotely close to fact (that hasn't been published by MSM) was very quickly shot down (and shut down) by friends and family of those concerned.


IMO JMO of course
 
That's the thing with this case... There are SO MANY rumours around it, it's difficult to know what is fact. I did read posts from approximately 8-10 people who said they had seen the "shower video" but nobody could find it to share it for everyone else to confirm it exists.
I attempted to follow a cpl of the fbk groups about this case at the beginning and for about 6 months, and clearly 'anything goes' on there. I do think that any information that is remotely close to fact (that hasn't been published by MSM) was very quickly shot down (and shut down) by friends and family of those concerned.


IMO JMO of course
We can agree to disagree. I think some people shut down rumors that were causing their loved ones to be stalked, harassed, and receive death threats. For those who have made up their minds that Noah's friends did something nefarious, no amount of logic matters. I hope the family gets real answers.
 
We can agree to disagree. I think some people shut down rumors that were causing their loved ones to be stalked, harassed, and receive death threats. For those who have made up their minds that Noah's friends did something nefarious, no amount of logic matters. I hope the family gets real answers.
IMO, the social media has been a dumpster fire of people trying to find their fifteen minutes of fame (or worse) off other people's suffering.
It is amazing when communities like this one can come together and figure something out, help bring closure, use crowd power for good. The flip side on social media is horrifying.
 
Can you provide a source for "they took videos of a kid showering and losing consciousness," please? I have only seen this is one of many rumors on social media. I think we need to be careful here when stating unsubstantiated rumors as facts. MOO
It's been documented in numerous articles posted on this thread, as has stuff about JN. Just go back to page 15 on ward and read each link
 
I've been to parties just like this, and I find absolutely nothing unusual about it. Haven't been to one where someone rolled an ATV, but I was at one where someone drunkenly drove a dirt bike into a lake. We didn't take videos of this stuff, simply because smart phones weren't a thing.

People fighting, people coming and going, if you asked 10 people what happened they'd all tell you completely different stories.
Have you ever been to a party where a kid's body was so mangled it was "worse than falling from a parachute" and each kid has a totally different story? So far only one kids story matches the facts (K)
 
It's been documented in numerous articles posted on this thread, as has stuff about JN. Just go back to page 15 on ward and read each link
Rumors being perpetuated does not equal "being documented," IMHO. Repeating something many times does not make it true. The moon landing being a hoax has also been widely "documented."
 
Have you ever been to a party where a kid's body was so mangled it was "worse than falling from a parachute" and each kid has a totally different story? So far only one kids story matches the facts (K)
One click-bait pod caster said that, to engage clicks. What is happening to these young people at the hands of a rabid, badly-informed crowd is horrific.
 
Have you ever been to a party where a kid's body was so mangled it was "worse than falling from a parachute" and each kid has a totally different story? So far only one kids story matches the facts (K)
Nope, but that sure as hell doesn't describe what happens in a fight. I think he passed out on the road, and got hit by a truck.
 
You are far from alone in that theory, MassGuy, especially among those who have really dug deep into the autopsy. I cannot imagine the pain for all his loved ones who do not have answers.
Nope, but that sure as hell doesn't describe what happens in a fight. I think he passed out on the road, and got hit by a truck.
 
I think Noah’s death was caused by being hit by a vehicle. Possible contributing factors:
1) possible internal injuries or not noticeable injury caused by ATV accident
2) superficial injuries or abrasions caused by horsing around and/or minor fighting among the guys

Reasons the other partygoers may not being forthcoming:
1) people do stupid stuff when they are drunk, especially at that age
2) While at the time their behavior may have been fun, in hindsight, it looks bad & given a death occurred, leads to lots of talk & rumors. Rumors then are quoted as fact.
3) Sometimes females are more ashamed or shamed by their behavior while drunk & do not want to be talked about forever. This is a small town after all.

In my larger community, there’s been several people hit on the interstate while walking at dusk or at night. One man was walking at night to his second job & he was hit by several cars. His body was so damaged, other drivers could not tell he was human. He was in the roadway for approximately 10 hours before someone called 911 to report “something” was in the roadway.
 
Last edited:
I think Noah's death was NOT caused by being hit by a vehicle

Fact: Lack of blood at the scene Noah's body was found
as stated by Jeremie Wilson, sheriff of Jefferson County, Oklahoma who was one of the first on scene


JMO MOO
 
I think Noah’s death was caused by being hit by a vehicle. Possible contributing factors:
1) possible internal injuries or not noticeable injury caused by ATV accident
2) superficial injuries or abrasions caused by horsing around and/or minor fighting among the guys

Reasons the other partygoers may not being forthcoming:
1) people do stupid stuff when they are drunk, especially at that age
2) While at the time their behavior may have been fun, in hindsight, it looks bad & given a death occurred, leads to lots of talk & rumors. Rumors then are quoted as fact.
3) Sometimes females are more ashamed or shamed by their behavior while drunk & do not want to be talked about forever. This is a small town after all.

In my larger community, there’s been several people hit on the interstate while walking at dusk or at night. One man was walking at night to his second job & he was hit by several cars. His body was so damaged, other drivers could not tell he was human. He was in the roadway for approximately 10 hours before someone called 911 to report “something” was in the roadway.
Very thoughtful and logical points. Thank you. Thank you for sharing what happened in your community, as well. Very sad.
It takes work and time to dive into the autopsy and compare it to real life accident data, but out of respect for Noah and all of those who truly care for him, I think it is necessary. I respect all input that is based on fact.
 
I think Noah's death was NOT caused by being hit by a vehicle

Fact: Lack of blood at the scene Noah's body was found
as stated by Jeremie Wilson, sheriff of Jefferson County, Oklahoma who was one of the first on scene


JMO MOO
Lack of Blood: if NP’s head injury was closed, there wouldn’t necessarily be a lot of blood at the scene. In the autopsy report, I see words like blunt force injury, subcutaneous, abrasions, hemoperitoneum, subdural hemorrhage, etc that may indicate he bleed internally.

The sheriff acknowledged he only called emergency services and didn’t treat the area containing NP’s body as a crime scene, which may have provided more information.

I don’t find the two different shoes significant.
 
I read through everyone's theories and counterpoints and still have no idea!

Being a rural girl, I know teenage parties can get out of control. I never attended one, but I sure did hear all kinds of stories and see all kinds of pictures. Nothing would surprise me. Teenagers, alcohol, little supervision, various vehicles, after dark...

Honestly, I wouldn't be shocked if no one really knew what happened and that's why it seems so difficult to get any details. They all only saw part of the events, but not THE event or they did witness it but the alcohol impaired their memory. As an adult it takes very little for me to have a fuzzy memory after drinking. Alcohol hits me hard. I can only imagine what it would have been like if I drank when I was their age. (No wild parties, no under aged drinking. I know, I was a nerd! :))
 
I read through everyone's theories and counterpoints and still have no idea!

Being a rural girl, I know teenage parties can get out of control. I never attended one, but I sure did hear all kinds of stories and see all kinds of pictures. Nothing would surprise me. Teenagers, alcohol, little supervision, various vehicles, after dark...

Honestly, I wouldn't be shocked if no one really knew what happened and that's why it seems so difficult to get any details. They all only saw part of the events, but not THE event or they did witness it but the alcohol impaired their memory. As an adult it takes very little for me to have a fuzzy memory after drinking. Alcohol hits me hard. I can only imagine what it would have been like if I drank when I was their age. (No wild parties, no under aged drinking. I know, I was a nerd! :))
I had a very similar experience and perspective growing up. Thank you for this.
We know it is not being investigated as a murder. We know whatever happened, happened on the road. It may be one of those things that is impossible to solve, which is maddening and obviously hard to accept. Trying to come up with wild murder theories does not help, IMO.

And WOW! 19 years. That is awesome. You have seen and considered some things just on here alone. Really appreciate your perspective.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
124
Guests online
570
Total visitors
694

Forum statistics

Threads
626,478
Messages
18,526,721
Members
241,057
Latest member
unshattered
Back
Top