PA PA-John Leonard, 52, Taxi driver, fatally shot back of head, 1970, Wife, Madeleine Leonard, 48, died in suspicious car crash, 22/2/73 *NEW INITIATIVE*

dotr

Well-Known Member
Websleuths Guardian
Joined
Oct 21, 2009
Messages
56,649
Reaction score
168,318
Very lengthy article.
March 25 2023 rbbm
By Kyani Reid
1679756348101.png

Lori Leonard remembers vividly seeing a police car parked outside of her classroom window. Although it was 50 years ago, it’s a day she’ll never forget.

“One of my classmates tapped me. He said, ‘Leonardo, ha, ha, hey, hey, the cops are going to take you away,’” Lori Leonard told Dateline. “He was joking, but it haunts me to this day. Little did he know how true that was.”


It was February 23, 1973. 15-year-old twins Debra and Lori Leonard were in the middle of their school day at Pocono Central Catholic School in Cresco, Pennsylvania.

Debra and Lori Leonard.
Debra and Lori Leonard.Debra and Lori Leonard

“They said, ‘Debbie, pack up your things and go with the principal,’” Debra Leonard recalled. “I did, and she said, ‘Go down to the Spanish class and get your sister.’”

Debra said the siblings arrived at the principal’s office, where their younger brother was already waiting. “Timmy was sitting there, and I said, ‘What’s going on?’”

There had been a terrible accident. Their mother, Madeleine Leonard, had been found dead -- just three years after the murder of their father...

John and Madeleine Leonard raised their five children in Cresco. “It was a nice community,” Debra told Dateline. “Everybody knew everybody — everybody watched out for everyone.” Lori agreed. “We used to go to the movies. We roller skated every Friday night,” she said. “We loved it.”
1679756461828.png


''The attic apartment was located above a bar owned by family friends — Ann and Don Mick. “The Micks owned a garage, a gas station, the bar, and a taxi service,” Debra told Dateline. “Our dad did everything there. He was a mechanic, he was a bartender, a taxi driver — you name it,” Lori added.

And that’s exactly what he was doing the night he died...

The Murder of John Leonard

1679756580767.png

''According to Det. Vanlouvender, at approximately 3:45 p.m., John was found dead in the front seat of the 1966 black Plymouth 4 door sedan that served as a taxicab -- it was parked in the driveway of the lodge.

Investigators believe when John was “driving up the driveway, he was approached by a white male, approximately 25-30 years of age, wearing dark rim glasses, a bright blue sports coat and carrying a white paper bag” and that the “suspect discharged 5 rounds from a 22-caliber weapon, most likely a revolver due to a lack of shell casings -- through the open driver’s side window,” the detective wrote.''

The twins, who were now 15 years old, said their mother, Madeleine, worked as a waitress at a diner in Scranton — which is where she was on the night of February 22, 1973.

After finishing her shift, Madeleine called home at around 10 p.m. “She said, ‘I have a tip on your dad. I’m going to Mount Pocono to check it out and then I’ll be home,’” Debra told Dateline. “I was like, ‘No, you can’t go by yourself.’”

But Madeleine went anyway. She did not return home that night.
1679756868649.png

Madeleine Leonard
According to Det. Vanlouvender, 48-year-old Madeleine Leonard “was discovered deceased as the result of a motor vehicle crash on February 22, 1973.” He wrote that “the crash occurred on SR 940 in Mt. Pocono Borough, Monroe County, Pennsylvania.”

The sisters told Dateline they were initially told there was a connection between their parents deaths. “Chief Hartman -- now deceased-- came to our house and told us. He said she was run off the road,” Lori said. “He said — ‘It is definitely tied to your dad’s murder,’” Debra added.''
 
2022

2022 rbbm.
1679757488379.png


1679757551812.png

"There was at least an eyewitness during that time that provided some physical details about who they believed was the person that they had seen walking up to the cab when John appeared. It would have been a white male between the ages of like 25-30. He had noted that he had kind of like slicked dark-colored hair. He was wearing like a sports coat and had a shopping bag with him," said Trooper Jonathan Bailey, with the Pennsylvania State Police Criminal Investigative Unit.''
rbbm
''Then in 1973 their mom, Madeleine Leonard told them that she was going to check on a lead in her husband’s death. Madeleine was found dead in her car the next day. Police say she crashed her car along Route 940 in Paradise Township and it was ruled an accident. The twins believe she was intentionally killed.

Lori says, "Police Chief of Mount Pocono Robert Hartman came to our house, he was a friend of our Dad’s and he told us he thought our mom was murdered as well and he said the cases are linked."

The children were all under 18 when they lost both of their parents leaving them orphaned. Over the past recent years their three brothers passed away without ever knowing what happened to their parents and the twins don’t want the same fate.

Debbie says, "It’s a sorrow and pain that we have to live with daily and it tears deeply within our hearts."

Lori says, "We’re kind of frustrated because our Dad was a World War II Vet, he was a POW for 22 months, he served this country and his memory shouldn’t be forgotten."

If anyone has information on the decades old crime that happened here, you’re asked to contact State Police at Stroudsburg or you can contact News13 to reach the family.''
 
.

2015 Article:

Monroe County Cold Cases:

POW = Prisoner-Of-War

.
 
.

2015 Article:

Monroe County Cold Cases:

POW = Prisoner-Of-War

.
From link, ty.. rbbm.
In the description of the suspect in sketch posted upthread, he was described as "snapping his fingernails'', unsure of exactly what that entails, but am reminded of something a classmate told me many years ago about his father during the war.
He said he used to get hit by a hand turned so that the receiver would be struck by the flicking nails, surprisingly painful.
Could this be a war time revenge of some sort, some mafia type thing?
complete speculation, imo
.

''On Sept. 8, 1970, John Leonard Sr., 52, of Cresco, was found shot four times in the head in the cab he had parked near the entrance of the now-abandoned Buck Hill Inn. Leonard's killer has never been identified or arrested, and the motive behind his murder is still unknown.''

''Hard-working family man
John Leonard was described as a quiet, hard-working family man born in Westover and raised in Elmhurst by Catholic Irish parents.

He was a 24-year-old crane operator when enlisting in 1942 to serve with the U.S. Army Air Corps in Europe during World War II. He was a prisoner of war for 22 months, but released when the conflict ended in 1945.''

''Leonard then returned home, where he drove a truck and worked at various other jobs prior to 1952, when he became a cab driver, bartender and mechanic at the business still owned today by the Mick family on Route 390.''

"We never knew him to have any enemies or owe anyone money," said Lori. "He never gambled or was into anything illegal that we knew of. He seemed satisfied with his job and the money he made.''

''setting up a station at the inn in the days after the murder, authorities were able to determine a small-caliber weapon had been used, but not by whom or why. No cab fare receipts were taken, so robbery apparently wasn't the motive.''
 
 John William Leonard Sr.
John William Leonard, Sr., age 52, murdered 8 September 1970

BIRTH 6 Jul 1918 Westover, Clearfield County, Pennsylvania, USA
DEATH 8 Sep 1970 (aged 52) Buck Hill Falls, Monroe County, Pennsylvania, USA
BURIAL Saint Catherine's Cemetery Moscow, Lackawanna County, Pennsylvania, USA

LINK:


Madeleine Leonard. (Debra and Lori Leonard)

Madeleine Leonard, suspicious death 23 February 1973

LINK:

 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
102
Guests online
629
Total visitors
731

Forum statistics

Threads
625,465
Messages
18,504,353
Members
240,808
Latest member
zoeep
Back
Top