MD MD - Kathy Beatty, 15, Aspen Hill, 24 July 1975

Aug 12, 2019

ASPEN HILL, Md. (WDVM) — Over 40 years ago, a Montgomery County teenage girl went missing. She was only missing for one day but died 11 days after being found due to her injuries.

Her family, detectives and the community are still puzzled as to what happened to her. Kathy Lynn Beatty was known to always wear a smile on her face. Many who knew her said she had a big heart.

“Kathy went to school with me. We’ve been in class together the year before she was found, and for years people, my friends who I went to school with, always wondered what happened to Kathy,” said Private Detective, Steve Kerpelman. Kathy was reported missing in July of 1975...

LINK:

Cold Case: 40 years later, Montgomery County still seeking who killed Kathy Beatty
 



Kathy was 15 years old, a beautiful young girl looking forward to starting high school and enjoying a warm summer evening the night that she was abducted and brutally assaulted and left for dead.

The question persists of who did this terrible thing.

Kathy was known to have been walking around outside that evening. She was seen by other children near Parkland Middle School which was only a block or so from her home. She was also visited at her home by the young boy from next door who came over to give her a T shirt. It is possible that she called a girl friend that night to arrange a "cover story" of being at the girl's house prior to going to visit a boy whom she had a crush on.

Whether or not she saw the boy that night has never been established with certainty. It would be nice to know who that boy was and exactly what he had to say to investigators at the time. And what he might say today.

It is not known for certain where Kathy went that night or what route she took, but it is known that early the next morning, she was found beaten nearly to death across Georgia Ave, near the K-Mart in a rocky and trash strewn field near a stream bed. Her mother had stated that Kathy loved to walk to the K-Mart to look at bikes, and this was one of the first places that she went to look for her daughter that night.

It is quite possible that Kathy did indeed walk toward K-Mart that night. If she did, there were basically two routes she could have taken. One would be to walk on the roads that a car would be forced to drive in order to get out of her subdivision. She may have been picked up by someone in her neighborhood and driven on that route, but there is no evidence of that.

The other route would be much more direct and shorter. It would require cutting through at least one yard and a wooded area to get on the more direct road to K-Mart.

The more direct route would take her through or next to two parking lots belonging to Vitro Laboratories. Those parking lots still exist today and are used by the Home Depot, which was built years later on the same site of one of two Aspen Hill Vitro Buildings.

Working at Vitro Laboratories in Aspen Hill was a man named Fred Howard Coffey, Jr. He had been hired by Vitro in April 1975 and had spent the previous 12 years in the Navy. The Navy had discharged him because he had been convicted of the September 1974 rape a 13 year old girl in Virginia Beach, VA. In October 1975, he was again arrested there for a similar offense against a 15 year old girl.

Coffey is currently incarcerated in the North Carolina Prison System for the abduction and murder of a 10-year-old girl named Amanda Ray. He was also convicted of numerous other crimes against children and a prime suspect in the deaths of others.

Immediately after the attack on Kathy and after the newspapers announced that she was still alive in a hospital, Fred Coffey left town. He did not tell anyone that he was leaving - not even his boss at Vitro. Some time later, after Kathy died, Coffey wrote to Vitro explaining that his wife and daughter had been in a Kentucky car accident and asked that his last paycheck be mailed to him. He was paid through 31 July 1975.

It was later learned that the car accident was a total lie and that he used the same lie when leaving another job under suspicious circumstances.
 
This case seems to be of an almost random nature. Kathy was a kid out and wandering around the neighborhood. With the exception of her wanting to visit a boy who was not home, she seems to have been just walking around with not much to do.

Other kids saw her but all stated that she was alone and not "with them" when she was near the school. She was visited by a boy from next door, she called or talked to a girl friend, she stopped by a boys house. She is not seen again by anyone until early the next morning when she is found unconscious and near death in a trash strewn field near the K-Mart Parking Lot.

There could be a number of scenarios which led to the attack on her and her subsequent death, but as someone moving from one place to another, not on any predictable schedule, the conclusion could be drawn that she was targeted randomly by someone who was hunting for any victim, and not specifically for her.
 

Thanks for the link to the video, it's helpful. The place she was found was actually back into the woods a ways from the parking lot. It was an area called "The Rocks" where some local teens hung out. The scenario seems plausible of someone who worked in a nearby business, hanging out and watching young teen girls come and go.

I have a feeling the killing was somewhat opportunistic, but the killer had seen Kathy before. Was she going to The Rocks to meet someone that night or did she encounter someone who made her go there with them? Since it was a hang out and meeting place for teens, it does point to someone else who hung out there.

In this article about the murder of Travis Shane King, a young boy believed to have been abducted and murdered by Fred Howard Coffey, the main clue was a man using a metal detector to search the area around the apartment complex where the boy lived. LE speculated that Coffey used the metal detector as a ruse to lure the boy away from home.

BURDENS OF PROOF: File still open on Travis Shane King
 
Last edited:
I think that the video may have been somewhat misleading regarding where Kathy was found. She was indeed found in a rock strewn area, but not far from the K Mart parking lot. Today there is an Emergency Preparedness Office there which has a high chain link fence around it.

The place known as "The Rocks" was across a stream and uphill a distance from the parking lot and was (in 1975) a sort of hangout and party place for young people. While Kathy may have been there at some time, she was not found there.

It would seem that she was more likely headed to K Mart by the route she took, rather than to "The Rocks". If she had intended to go to "The Rocks" she would have taken subdivision roads and crossed Georgia Ave further north than where she was found.

Fred Coffey was living in Maryland at the time and worked for Vitro Laboratories, which was located directly across Georgia Ave from where Kathy's body was found. While police could never directly link him to her murder, there are many coincidental factors that point to him as the perpetrator. If he had been at "The Rocks" that evening, it is probable that someone would have seen him. Since he was pretty much a loner, it seems more likely that he would have been in or near his vehicle in the Vitro Parking lot when Kathy happened to walk by.

Speaking of Coffey - he is up for parole Again this coming July. Please take the time to send a note or email to the North Carolina Parole board to let them know your thoughts on the subject.
 
Last edited:
I think that the video may have been somewhat misleading regarding where Kathy was found. She was indeed found in a rock strewn area, but not far from the K Mart parking lot. Today there is an Emergency Preparedness Office there which has a high chain link fence around it.

The place known as "The Rocks" was across a stream and uphill a distance from the parking lot and was (in 1975) a sort of hangout and party place for young people. While Kathy may have been there at some time, she was not found there.

It would seem that she was more likely headed to K Mart by the route she took, rather than to "The Rocks". If she had intended to go to "The Rocks" she would have taken subdivision roads and crossed Georgia Ave further north than where she was found.

Fred Coffey was living in Maryland at the time and worked for Vitro Laboratories, which was located directly across Georgia Ave from where Kathy's body was found. While police could never directly link him to her murder, there are many coincidental factors that point to him as the perpetrator. If he had been at "The Rocks" that evening, it is probable that someone would have seen him. Since he was pretty much a loner, it seems more likely that he would have been in or near his vehicle in the Vitro Parking lot when Kathy happened to walk by.

Speaking of Coffey - he is up for parole Again this coming July. Please take the time to send a note or email to the North Carolina Parole board to let them know your thoughts on the subject.

Thanks, Richard! I hope Coffey remains locked up.

Here's a link to a map showing the walking distance between Parkland Middle School (near one of the last places Kathy was seen) and the KMart parking lot. The area behind the lot where she was found looks to have other development now, but it gives an idea. Can you indicate where Vitro Laboratories used to be located? Thanks!

خرائط ‪Google‬‏‏
 
Thanks, Richard! I hope Coffey remains locked up.

Here's a link to a map showing the walking distance between Parkland Middle School (near one of the last places Kathy was seen) and the KMart parking lot. The area behind the lot where she was found looks to have other development now, but it gives an idea. Can you indicate where Vitro Laboratories used to be located? Thanks!

خرائط ‪Google‬‏‏

-----------------------------------------------

The overhead view/map is a good one of the area (not certain when the photo was taken). However, when you asked the computer for a route from the school to the K Mart, it gave you the closest DRIVING route for today, which is way off because Kathy was walking on foot that evening. Some of her interim stops are known while she was still in her residential neighborhood.

For some perspective, we know that Kathy's house and the Middle School were both on West Frankfort Drive, less than a block apart. Vitro Laboratories (their original or "old" location) was where the Home Depot is today. The parking lots North and West of Home Depot are the very same ones used when Vitro was on the site, although the old Vitro buildings were all demolished when the Home Depot was built.

The large building just south of Home Depot and adjacent to its Perimeter Road was known as the "New Vitro" building. It was later owned and used by BAE, a company that bought out Vitro, and it has been vacant for a number of years more recently. (See my post #59 this thread).

Fred Coffey worked at the "Old Vitro" building and would have parked his car in the large parking lot to the north of it.

The place known as "The Rocks" was on high ground in the center of what is now a housing development. The entrance to that housing area would be where Heathfield Road crosses Georgia Ave. That housing development, as it exists today, can be seen clearly in the overhead view.

Kathy most likely walked in a southeasterly direction down Frankfort Drive until she reached Marionet Street, where she turned left, went a block and crossed Landgreen Street. At this point, she would have cut through a residential lot on a walking path and through a wooded area, arriving in the Westernmost section of the Vitro property.

Walking through the grass field a short distance past the small parking lot, she would then be on the perimeter road adjacent to the larger parking lot. Note that the houses on Southend Road are separated from the Vitro property by a tall chain link fence. Steep terrain to the south (note the large pond) on the Vitro property forms a "channel" taking a person on foot directly to the Perimeter road. It was a path taken regularly by kids from the area who wanted to walk to Kmart. And Kmart was a favorite destination of Kathy.

That Perimeter road is today the main entrance/exit for Home Depot. If one goes to the end of it and crosses Georgia Ave, you would be on a small access road that goes by the 7-Eleven (which was there in 1975 and still today). That little road went right into the Kmart parking lot's Westernmost corner. Today the road does not go all the way through to the parking lot, and thus the computer generated route going way around it.

Looking at the Subdivision North of that corner (near 7-Eleven), note that it is bounded by a stream. Kathy was found between the parking lot and that stream in a rock and trash strewn area. This would be in the approximate area of the word "Kmart" in the linked map.

You can see that this is a much more direct path than the computer selected driving path shown, and a much more likely route for a young girl walking (barefoot) to Kmart. It would also have taken her right past the parking lot where Fred Coffey parked his vehicle.
 
Last edited:
Murder of Kathy Beatty still stumps Montgomery County Police Department
Maryland Mysteries: Who Killed Kathy?
Feb 28, 2019

ASPEN HILL, Md. (WMAR) — A lot has changed on Frankfort Drive, but some things -- like Patricia and Fritz Haberman's home -- hasn't all that much since 1975.

Pat, as she likes to be called, has lived in the house since the 50's. It's where she raised her two daughters, Theresa and Kathy; even leaving Kathy's room nearly untouched for more than 40 years.

Kathy Beatty was killed in the summer of 1975.

"She had a big, big heart. She was very talented. I gave the girls all sorts of exciting things to do. They took tap, ballet, and jazz," Patricia said.

Patricia had strict rules for her girls. Kathy had to be home before dark, she was only 15.

It was a Thursday, Pat and a friend had gone up to Baltimore to watch the Maryland Lottery drawing and told Kathy she'd be back by ten.

"I was late getting home, but that night it rained like crazy. We had thunder and lightning, it was really bad and when I got home, the house was dark. There was not a light on in the house. It scared me to death. My heart just leaped because something is wrong," Patricia said...

LINK:
Murder of Kathy Beatty still stumps Montgomery County Police Department
 
Murder of Kathy Beatty still stumps Montgomery County Police Department
Maryland Mysteries: Who Killed Kathy?
Feb 28, 2019

ASPEN HILL, Md. (WMAR) — A lot has changed on Frankfort Drive, but some things -- like Patricia and Fritz Haberman's home -- hasn't all that much since 1975.

Pat, as she likes to be called, has lived in the house since the 50's. It's where she raised her two daughters, Theresa and Kathy; even leaving Kathy's room nearly untouched for more than 40 years.

Kathy Beatty was killed in the summer of 1975.

"She had a big, big heart. She was very talented. I gave the girls all sorts of exciting things to do. They took tap, ballet, and jazz," Patricia said.

Patricia had strict rules for her girls. Kathy had to be home before dark, she was only 15.

It was a Thursday, Pat and a friend had gone up to Baltimore to watch the Maryland Lottery drawing and told Kathy she'd be back by ten.

"I was late getting home, but that night it rained like crazy. We had thunder and lightning, it was really bad and when I got home, the house was dark. There was not a light on in the house. It scared me to death. My heart just leaped because something is wrong," Patricia said...

LINK:
Murder of Kathy Beatty still stumps Montgomery County Police Department

That's a good news report. Good to hear they have DNA and are still checking. JMO, that makes me think it was someone local, a friend or acquaintance. Someone who hasn't gotten in trouble with the law since, as their DNA isn't in the system.

The fact she was barefoot is interesting. A teen girl wouldn't have walked a mile to a store parking lot that way. A couple of scenarios:

1. She did go to a friend's house that night, where someone asked her to leave for a quick trip somewhere - hence going barefoot. She may have even been at home when a friend came to the door and she went outside to their car (to drink a beer, smoke a joint, listen to the car stereo, etc.) Maybe they even talked her into cruising around for a while.

2. Someone talked her into leaving her friend's house or her own home to go cruising around in a car. She's wearing shoes. At some point in the car she takes the shoes off to get comfortable, but the driver is suddenly threatening. She jumps shoeless out of the car and runs to the woods, where he follows and attacks her.

The quote from a previous post from a cold case file is interesting:

Two witnesses observed two male suspects carrying the body of a white female fitting the description of Kathy Beatty. The suspects were seen heading eastbound crossing Georgia Avenue towards the 7-Eleven convenience store and continuing on towards the "hill" area. Suspect one is described as a white male, mid to late teens, wearing a dark-colored jacket. He was taller than suspect two. Suspect two is described as a white male, mid to late teens, wearing dark clothing. He had fluffy, light brown hair that had grown below his ears.
Investigators believe that the information obtained from the witness is consistent with the chronology of events leading up to the discovery of Kathy in the area of the "hill".

She was found at the crime scene with her pants pulled down, so, if this is true, did the guys carrying her assault her after they dumped her?
 
That's a good news report. Good to hear they have DNA and are still checking. JMO, that makes me think it was someone local, a friend or acquaintance. Someone who hasn't gotten in trouble with the law since, as their DNA isn't in the system.

The fact she was barefoot is interesting. A teen girl wouldn't have walked a mile to a store parking lot that way. A couple of scenarios:

1. She did go to a friend's house that night, where someone asked her to leave for a quick trip somewhere - hence going barefoot. She may have even been at home when a friend came to the door and she went outside to their car (to drink a beer, smoke a joint, listen to the car stereo, etc.) Maybe they even talked her into cruising around for a while.

2. Someone talked her into leaving her friend's house or her own home to go cruising around in a car. She's wearing shoes. At some point in the car she takes the shoes off to get comfortable, but the driver is suddenly threatening. She jumps shoeless out of the car and runs to the woods, where he follows and attacks her.

The quote from a previous post from a cold case file is interesting:



She was found at the crime scene with her pants pulled down, so, if this is true, did the guys carrying her assault her after they dumped her?

All of your scenarios are possibilities, as are a few others seen in these threads.

Kathy was seen by several individuals and groups of kids that evening. One group of kids saw her near the Middle School. The boy from next door visited her briefly and gave her a T-shirt he brought home from a vacation trip. She wrote a note to her mother stating that she was going to visit a girlfriend. That same girlfriend stated that Kathy had called her, but did NOT stop at her house - rather that she said she was going to visit a boy friend at his house. The boy's father stated that the boy and a male friend of his were supposedly camping out in the back yard, but were not home.

Then nothing until her sister and her sister's boy friend find her badly injured and near death in the trash strewn field next to the Kmart parking lot the next morning.

I believe that the story about two boys carrying her across Georgia Ave came out many years later, but not at the time of the attack on Kathy.

As can be seen in the map, it is almost a direct line for someone walking between where Kathy began her walk and the place where she was found. That path would have taken her in a very close point of approach to the Vitro parking lot where Serial Killer Fred Coffey parked his car.

Coffey had raped a girl Kathy's same age in Virginia beach a year earlier and only months later was back in Virginia Beach where he was arrested and charged with "Contributing to the delinquency of a minor" with a 15 year old girl. Of course this is all coincidental - but it seems to indicate a pattern of behavior.

The news reports indicated that Kathy was in hospital, still living but in critical condition. Coincidentally, Fred Coffey immediately left town without a word to his supervisors at Vitro. Later when it was reported that Kathy had died without ever regaining consciousness, Fred Coffey contacted Vitro with a false story about why he had left and requested his last paycheck.
 
Last edited:
All of your scenarios are possibilities, as are a few others seen in these threads.

Kathy was seen by several individuals and groups of kids that evening. One group of kids saw her near the Middle School. The boy from next door visited her briefly and gave her a T-shirt he brought home from a vacation trip. She wrote a note to her mother stating that she was going to visit a girlfriend. That same girlfriend stated that Kathy had called her, but did NOT stop at her house - rather that she said she was going to visit a boy friend at his house. The boy's father stated that the boy and a male friend of his were supposedly camping out in the back yard, but were not home.

Then nothing until her sister and her sister's boy friend find her badly injured and near death in the trash strewn field next to the Kmart parking lot the next morning.

I believe that the story about two boys carrying her across Georgia Ave came out many years later, but not at the time of the attack on Kathy.

As can be seen in the map, it is almost a direct line for someone walking between where Kathy began her walk and the place where she was found. That path would have taken her in a very close point of approach to the Vitro parking lot where Serial Killer Fred Coffey parked his car.

Coffey had raped a girl Kathy's same age in Virginia beach a year earlier and only months later was back in Virginia Beach where he was arrested and charged with "Contributing to the delinquency of a minor" with a 15 year old girl. Of course this is all coincidental - but it seems to indicate a pattern of behavior.

The news reports indicated that Kathy was in hospital, still living but in critical condition. Coincidentally, Fred Coffey immediately left town without a word to his supervisors at Vitro. Later when it was reported that Kathy had died without ever regaining consciousness, Fred Coffey contacted Vitro with a false story about why he had left and requested his last paycheck.
@Richard, I’m just learning about this case- looks like you’re the WS expert on it. Did LE preserve evidence from her 1975 attack- and has it been DNA tested? I’m sure Coffey’s profile would be easy to confirm or omit. If not a match, this case is perfect for ancestry DNA. Perhaps would lead back to those 2 boys. Or maybe they had brothers or friends around that night too. So odd they weren’t in the backyard- where were they?
 
@Richard, I’m just learning about this case- looks like you’re the WS expert on it. Did LE preserve evidence from her 1975 attack- and has it been DNA tested? I’m sure Coffey’s profile would be easy to confirm or omit. If not a match, this case is perfect for ancestry DNA. Perhaps would lead back to those 2 boys. Or maybe they had brothers or friends around that night too. So odd they weren’t in the backyard- where were they?

The short answer is I don't know if any DNA evidence was obtained from Kathy's clothing. It was not something that anyone knew about in 1975. I know that at least some evidence from this case remains in storage, because there was a set of keys found near Kathy's body that have been mentioned in police briefings and news stories.

The two boys would certainly have been interviewed and presumably cleared by MCP investigators. But who they were and what they said regarding their location and activities that night were never reported publicly. Certainly persons of interest in this old case.
 
The short answer is I don't know if any DNA evidence was obtained from Kathy's clothing. It was not something that anyone knew about in 1975. I know that at least some evidence from this case remains in storage, because there was a set of keys found near Kathy's body that have been mentioned in police briefings and news stories.

The two boys would certainly have been interviewed and presumably cleared by MCP investigators. But who they were and what they said regarding their location and activities that night were never reported publicly. Certainly persons of interest in this old case.
I know it was too early for dna samples, but boy I sure hope they kept other items in storage. Kathy’s clothing, undergarments, items at the scene. Even the keys might have touch dna. A good cold case detective should submit those items for testing & run results through criminal databases & ancestry dna sites. This would be a perfect case for that if they just stored something.

PS: I love that you’ve been dedicated to this case for FOURTEEN years! I hope this case is solved for Kathy & her fam & friends, but also for you! That there are people who care enough about these cases to follow through for all these years is why I love WS! Thank you, Richard.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the video. Quick question as I read. add more questions later. At 1730 hours530pm Kathy seen on bike. Where was the bike found? Is it considered that she went bike riding then came back home and left again on foot. she was seen at school at 430pm then at home at 5pm then riding her back at 530pm. In one hour school, home, bike riding. but other witnesses seen her at the school 5pm and as late as 8pm...ADD ON. I took a good look at those keys. There are flowers on them. I dont thin a guy at the time would have his keys on something with flowers, unless there hemp flowers from the time. I dont think the keys are relevant anymore. Just happened to be near where her purse was found. Seem they had been there longer than Kathy, just by looking at the photo.
ADD ON 2...all the witnesses except for the one, im guessing they seen her walking not riding bike, is that correct.
ADD ON 3... If I had to guess, and its just a guess. I would say she came into contact with the killer inside that kmart store. Someone followed her out into the woods, or she left with someone she knew well or not very well and they both went together into those woods....This was a Thursday night. I dont think a serial killer happened to be there at the same time and decided to act upon Kathy after spotting her. I think this was someone that knew the area, knew about the woods, and probably knew Kathy in some respect. Someone whom lived right around there. I wonder what time the shift ended there that evening at Kmart. Any employees that may have gotten off work around the time she was murdered. Someone left early for whatever reason.
ADD ON 4...Right now, if I had to guess, and its all just guessing speculating etc. I would say Kathy knew her killer. Either directly or indirectly but knew them the same. I would guess the killer worked at that Kmart in some aspect in someway
 
Last edited:
I know it was too early for dna samples, but boy I sure hope they kept other items in storage. Kathy’s clothing, undergarments, items at the scene. Even the keys might have touch dna. A good cold case detective should submit those items for testing & run results through criminal databases & ancestry dna sites. This would be a perfect case for that if they just stored something.

PS: I love that you’ve been dedicated to this case for FOURTEEN years! I hope this case is solved for Kathy & her fam & friends, but also for you! That there are people who care enough about these cases to follow through for all these years is why I love WS! Thank you, Richard.

In a couple of the articles linked above, they mention some DNA evidence. It's been used to help further investigate the case. It doesn't sound as if it's been linked decisively to any individual. There's a Facebook page dedicated to finding info about Kathy's killer (s). Some of her school friends and family post there and there are some interesting comments about the activities that night. Nothing earth-shaking but interesting.

Keep in mind, there's also a convenience store or 7-11, that's also near the KMart parking lot. What if that was the spot where some of them went to get an older person to buy alcohol for them? What if that person took an interest in Kathy? There are any number of scenarios about what may have happened to her, but there are friends still around who were in the vicinity. Some of them were there that night. They may or may not know what happened to her. Its possible they just saw her leave with someone else. I hope they get some answers before too long.
 
News reports do mention that DNA might have been obtained (years after Kathy's death). However, there are different types of DNA evidence and they do not mention any specifics. It is possible that only Kathy's DNA was obtained - or maybe DNA from a family member. That might help if a murder weapon testing positive for Kathy's DNA was to be found in the possession of a suspect.

DNA also could have been obtained which came from someone else also, but again nothing specific was ever stated by LE to the press.
 
Last edited:

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
174
Guests online
4,117
Total visitors
4,291

Forum statistics

Threads
592,884
Messages
17,976,970
Members
228,934
Latest member
Contrary Marge
Back
Top