When I first heard the news, I cried and thought they finally found her. But, then I thought about it some more, and it kind of sounds like it could've been a pet or something. A plastic clover toy? It sounds like a dog toy.
And, I still think Cocoamom's church theory may be where she is. When I read through that thread, it gave me goosebumps and all seemed to make perfect sense. I haven't had a gut feeling on anything we've heard so far until I saw those church pictures. The location, the pings, the remoteness but not too remote (I can't see KC traipsing through that rough of terrain carting a dead body. I just don't see it.), and all the the similarities with the psychics visions and dreams. It just feels right to me.