Search results

You mean he didn't tell you he didn't do it?

But what did the CPD do to rule him out?

I am not Canadian and I expect everyone (in my family and children's friends-I would not require grownups to remove their shoes!) to leave their shoes at the door, so I don't think this is a Canadian thing exclusively. But I can tell you, with a family of four, there are so many shoes out in...

That is the problem with circumstantial evidence and hearsay-even in the affidavits by the friends there was so much he said, she said, i.e. "once I walked into the kitchen and heard NC tell my wife etc.etc.etc. The ducks and necklace seem trivial but are a perfect example of how the CPD based...

I agree. How would you like to be on that jury and come to a verdict after all this time, only to find out that you didn't have all the information and your verdict would have been different?

But you can't convict someone on it.

I do. I saved everything from high school and college. I'm sure it's all in there, the love letters too. Doesn't mean I'm going to murder my husband.

He also couldn't remember the name of his nephew (brother's child) which I found sad at first but it really goes to his character. He wasn't a huggy, touchy feely guy and some people just aren't. Also, my mind goes blank trying to remember what it was I went into the grocery store for. I...

See? You would be dismissed as a possible juror because you're too emotionally involved and thereby not able to form a rational opinion about the case. I'm glad for the jury selection process.

I agree, for anyone to say with 100% certainty either way is irrational. But I think there are two distinct types of posters here. 1. Just feels emotionally attached to this poor woman who was murdered or this poor man who sits in a jail cell with a lack of evidence. 2. Is interested in how...

She was at the grill, cooking the ribs that she brought! I'd be shocked if there wasn't something spilled on the dress.

Um, someone had to? I'm not being mean but I heard that the realtor had told them that the house was in no way ready to be listed because of the dirt and dissaray. Also, I have a friend who, every time she threatens to leave her husband 'for real, this time I mean it' type of thing, he starts...

She wasn't called by the prosecution. I wonder why.

But it is obvious that he isn't in their clique anymore.

I have a completely different opinion of the MH testimony. I thought he did a good job for the defense. Believable, forthcoming, assured. Yes, it was clear he shut down on Cummings but that was obviously Cummings mistake. A mechanical engineer who was trying to recreate the murder based on...

That is called reasonable doubt. If those other scenarios are possibilities, then the jury must vote NG. If the CPD didn't even notice the ducks sitting in a box, or the dirt on NC's left knee, what else did they not do that may have let the real killer go free? I think jurors are smart and...

Agreed. Trenkle did a great job today. I don't enjoy Kurtz's style as much but I think he is methodical and has a plan laid out for how the defense is presenting their case. The prosecution jumped all over the place with people and events and physical evidence. It was annoying to try to...

Cummings is the First Assistant DA to C. Willoughby. I'm sure he is part of the big J. Young trial, perhaps that is why he was so unprepared for this trial today?

I thought it came when he tried to show that you need a strong grip to hold a tennis racquet. I thought he was going to accuse BC of strangling her with a tennis racquet! My 8 yr. old plays tennis and of course he is able to grip the racquet. Women are able to hold on to golf clubs and tennis...