Allison Baden-Clay - GENERAL DISCUSSION THREAD #36

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves

New Posts

Status
Not open for further replies.
pulpfiction said:
"and did you, at any point, in the 3 days prior and post the deceased going missing, see the accused being attacked by these, um er, caterpillars?". Hehe.
Click to expand...

Maybe role playing trial questions and answers will open up new lines of thinking, or earn time out. The later me thinks.
Is that the flutter of Marlywings or a cool summer breeze in mid winter?
Time to hde back under my rock now.:truce:
 
drsleuth said:
4 Corners ( ABC 1 ) is running a story on domestic violence tonight.........8:30pm

http://www.abc.net.au/4corners/stories/2012/07/26/3554420.htm
Click to expand...

I watched this doco last night, really disturbing.

Particularly worrying was the sentence for the husband of the young Japanese woman. He only got 5 years (and eligible for parole in 3), for a lesser charge of assault resulting in death.

He told police he hit her and left her for dead, but her body was so badly decomposed after 12 days that cause of death was unknown.

I worry that this may happen with Allison's case regarding cause of death.
 
Congrats to Marlywings for her flash new role as our very own Aussie moderator :rocker: :woohoo:
 
whitechapel said:
OT - Batman shooting in Colorado
.
Mr Holmes faces two counts of first degree murder for each of the 12 people killed - one each for their deliberate killing and one more for killing through "depraved indifference" to the lives of his victims.
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/world/batman-shooting-suspect-to-face-first-degree-murder-attempted-murder-charges/story-fnd134gw-1226438964619

I can't see the point of two murder charges for each victim.
Click to expand...

That's what I thought, 2 counts per person?
 
Funny pulp, but seriously as an eg of types of questions, I would maybe not ask that question because you then give the witness the opportunity to tell a story which he already has worked out. If he makes it sound credible then it may have assisted the defence and not the prosecution.

pulpfiction said:
"and did you, at any point, in the 3 days prior and post the deceased going missing, see the accused being attacked by these, um er, caterpillars?". Hehe.
Click to expand...
 
alioop said:
Funny pulp, but seriously as an eg of types of questions, I would maybe not ask that question because you then give the witness the opportunity to tell a story which he already has worked out. If he makes it sound credible then it may have assisted the defence and not the prosecution.
Click to expand...

Yes indeed. The stories I've heard over the years...oh my, Oscar winning. A recent very high profile case of long missing child in Qld springs to mind. The POIs were outstanding with their responses - however not credible.
 
LauraMars said:
I watched this doco last night, really disturbing.

Particularly worrying was the sentence for the husband of the young Japanese woman. He only got 5 years (and eligible for parole in 3), for a lesser charge of assault resulting in death.

He told police he hit her and left her for dead, but her body was so badly decomposed after 12 days that cause of death was unknown.

I worry that this may happen with Allison's case regarding cause of death.
Click to expand...

thats what i said some time ago. why not say we had a fight and i choked her. leave body where it was and plead grievous bodily harm causing death. lot lighter sentence I would think.
AND havent been on much so BIG congratulations to our darling Marly
 
Yes and the poor family had to listen to those terrible made up stories to try to ascertain if there was any shred of truth in them.

pulpfiction said:
Yes indeed. The stories I've heard over the years...oh my, Oscar winning. A recent very high profile case of long missing child in Qld springs to mind. The POIs were outstanding with their responses - however not credible.
Click to expand...
 
squizzey1 said:
thats what i said some time ago. why not say we had a fight and i choked her. leave body where it was and plead grievous bodily harm causing death. lot lighter sentence I would think.
AND havent been on much so BIG congratulations to our darling Marly
Click to expand...

The narcissistic high rollers (well they think they are) can be gamblers. Going for the highest payout. Blaming others - not my fault.
 
alioop said:
Yes and the poor family had to listen to those terrible made up stories to try to ascertain if there was any shred of truth in them.
Click to expand...

Quite vulgar for all concerned. I remember many years ago doing my psychology prac placements out at Wolston Park in the high secure John Oxley. Was quite an eye opener. I was literally stunned at what also goes on once these types are incarcerated. More crimes of a violent nature that made me almost sick to my stomach. It is extrmely difficult for families having to listen to the ugly outcomes let alone the lies etc. One would think Allison's family will be represented in court by family so I hope somehow they are spared from further deceit - but in reality there is always deceit in these cases. As we have already seen it appears. Very close friend is a senior Court Reporter here in Brisbane. She has been on many infamous trials over the years. Like in my line of work you become somewhat used to it but what we see is how much it affects the family at trial. Your work must be equally as interesting Al:) even if not in criminal law, law itself is a fascinating field. Very pleased you are able to answer the legal questions. Most important when we have a long wait.
 
I'm also one of the members who hasn't been on much lately...life getting in the way of my addiction.

BIG congratulations to MarlyWings....I have so many questions...how does one become a moderator on a forum? are you invited (would not be surprised...your competence is well appreciated here) or do you apply? what time, skill, commitment does one have to make? I know this is a volunteer's role, and I'm always impressed with how much time our mod's spend here (cleaning up our mess!)

and Alioop! thank you for going through the steps to get certified. We all learn so much from our certified members. One of the reasons I keep coming back even when there is no news is that I just learn something new everyday. Not that others who are not certified don't also teach me heaps...they DO. It is just nice to know who to turn to on specialsed areas.
 
Please remember to keep up-to-date in our Threadiquette section. Here's the latest post there: [ame="http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8209934&postcount=31"]Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - Threadiquette- Questions about rules welcome here[/ame]

Do not discuss it in this thread. This is just a management announcement so I know you all saw it.

This post lands at random and is not in response to the post above.
 
Just watched a movie on channel 7... Crime of Passion- sleepwalker. I'm surprised GBC hasn't used this theory yet?

Apparently it can happen, very scary though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

DNASolves

Who is DeKalb County John Doe (2022)?

Members online

... and 68 more.
Total: 2,436 (members: 69, guests: 2,367)

Online statistics

Members online
69
Guests online
2,367
Total visitors
2,436
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Forum statistics

Threads
603,528
Messages
18,157,892
Members
231,758
Latest member
sandrz717
Back
Top