AZ - Valley HS senior with leukemia denied cap, gown wants policy change

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
I guess I sort of see this different than most of those posting here. The boy didn't graduate, so why would he be in the graduation ceremony? If it is THAT important to him, finish the credits and walk with the next graduating class. I fully support the school here. They made a nice gesture in letting him lead the students out. I agree with the poster here that points out that if they let him participate in the ceremony, they open the door to letting virtually anyone participate.
 
Fallacy: Slippery Slope

Description of Slippery Slope

The Slippery Slope is a fallacy in which a person asserts that some event must inevitably follow from another without any argument for the inevitability of the event in question. In most cases, there are a series of steps or gradations between one event and the one in question and no reason is given as to why the intervening steps or gradations will simply be bypassed. This "argument" has the following form:

Event X has occurred (or will or might occur).
Therefore event Y will inevitably happen.
 
I guess I sort of see this different than most of those posting here. The boy didn't graduate, so why would he be in the graduation ceremony? If it is THAT important to him, finish the credits and walk with the next graduating class. I fully support the school here. They made a nice gesture in letting him lead the students out. I agree with the poster here that points out that if they let him participate in the ceremony, they open the door to letting virtually anyone participate.

BBM. I think it's part of the currently belief system that accomplishments don't matter — as long as you tried. Everyone gets a gold star just for showing up.

If schools want to hold a "nice memories ceremony" in which everyone in that grade gets to participate, then they should hold one. But a graduation ceremony is, by definition, for those who are graduating.
 
This hits close to home for me. My 17 year old son will be graduating with his class on Monday. He broke his leg (actually, tibia, fibula and all the bones in his foot) the summer of 2014, just before his junior year. He had bacterial infections and multiple surgeries. He faced the possibility of losing his foot albeit not leukemia. He attempted virtual school, but it didn't work out with hospitalizations, PICC line twice, wound vac twice, home health care for iv antibiotics, etc. When this school year was 3/4 finished, they informed him he could take two online classes and graduate with his class. He went to school, worked and took those online classes. He gets to graduate with his class and on time. Granted, he is not a 4.2 gpa student by any means.

I feel like participating with your class in "walking" is a rite of passage...symbolizing the true beginning of adulthood. I quit school in 11th grade and it has never bothered me that I didn't graduate with my friends. However, I went back to my high school to get football tickets as an adult and they have senior pictures for every graduating class. I saw all of my young classmates and did feel a twinge of sadness that I didn't get to experience that thrill....the thrill of being done with that part of my life with people I had shared that experience with for so many years. I guess it means more to some than others.

There are always so many stories and probably deserving ones, but I agree they can't do for one and not all. Maybe they should have been more accommodating in ways to help him make up for the classes he was lacking so he could officially graduate. It sounds from one of the links upthread, they offered other ways to involve him that were not accepted.
 
I guess I sort of see this different than most of those posting here. The boy didn't graduate, so why would he be in the graduation ceremony? If it is THAT important to him, finish the credits and walk with the next graduating class. I fully support the school here. They made a nice gesture in letting him lead the students out. I agree with the poster here that points out that if they let him participate in the ceremony, they open the door to letting virtually anyone participate.

BBM. I think it's part of the currently belief system that accomplishments don't matter — as long as you tried. Everyone gets a gold star just for showing up.

If schools want to hold a "nice memories ceremony" in which everyone in that grade gets to participate, then they should hold one. But a graduation ceremony is, by definition, for those who are graduating.


It's not a gold star for trying. This kid nearly died from cancer- show some compassion. There needs to be exemptions, at least for medical reasons like this! (Did you read that an 8th grader at my daughter's middle school was awarded her diploma months early because she died of leukemia before graduation???) Colleges let you walk with your class even though you may be a few units short. He tried to make it up in time, he shouldn't have to wait another full year to walk!:banghead::banghead::banghead:
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
181
Guests online
490
Total visitors
671

Forum statistics

Threads
608,288
Messages
18,237,371
Members
234,334
Latest member
ZanziBee
Back
Top