Coley was wrongly convicted of murdering his 24-year-old ex-girlfriend Rhonda Wicht and her four-year-old son Donald at her Simi Valley home in 1978.
He claims a former police detective framed him for the murders by destroying crucial evidence. His conviction was eventually overturned due to advances in DNA technology and faulty evidence.
Investigators couldn't find any of Coley's DNA on the evidence used to convict him but they did find the DNA of an unknown man.
Prison is full of "innocent" men who claim to have been framed squid! MOO.
A simple examination of the facts reveals that CC almost certainly murdered Ms Wicht and also her four year old son Donald.
To summarize:
1. Ms Wicht dumped Mr Coley. He was very upset / depressed by this fact and let many people know this.
2. He went on a all-night bender, drinking with his buddies until 4:30 am
3. Shortly after he leaves his drinking buddies at 4:30 am a heavily intoxicated man causes a ruckus at Ms Wicht's residence, waking the neighbors.
4. At 5:30am Ms Wicht's neighbors see a man who looks like Mr Coley (who they know very well) leaving Ms Wicht's residence.
5. The neighbor's see this very familiar looking man enter a truck that looks exactly like Mr Coley's truck (which they also know and recognize)
6. When police go to Mr Coley's residence to arrest him
they find a blood-stained towel and a a t-shirt soaked in blood. They suggest that Mr Coley was wearing the t-shirt when he brutally beat and strangled his ex to death, and then used a towel to clean himself up before attempting to drive home.
7. Police believe 4 year old Donald was murdered as he could identify his mother's killer.
There are only two reasons why Mr Coley was 'cleared' of this murder:
1. Another man's semen was found on an item belonging to Ms Wicht -most likely the blood soaked towel found at Mr Coley's residence.
2. The police and the prosecution knew Ms Wicht had other male friends / companions but didn't introduce them as alternate suspects at the trial.
The fact that another man's semen was found
(and may actually have been found on the blood-soaked towel at Mr Coley's house!) doesn't mean that Mr Coley didn't kill his ex.
In fact, the evidence that it has been established that Ms Wicht had several other male suitors (once she had ended her relationship with Mr Coley) gives us a perfectly acceptable explanation for why unknown DNA (ie not Mr Coley's sperm) was found.
www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-jerry-brown-pardon-20171122-htmlstory.html
www.vcstar.com/story/news/local/communities/simi-valley/2017/12/02/police-face-challenges-simi-valleys-oldest-unsolved-murder-case/913307001/
www.nytimes.com/2017/11/23/us/jerry-brown-pardon-murder.html