OutOfTheDarkness
Former Member
- Joined
- Jul 7, 2014
- Messages
- 1,525
- Reaction score
- 2
Let's look at if P, then Q ... in part responding to the quoted post.
1. Are the Liknes couple alive: yes, or no?
If yes, then the determination by the medical examiners office that they are dead is dead wrong. They are alive. The Medical Examiner is wrong.
If no, then we accept the decision of the medical examiner, which is supported by 200 officers, numerous police departments, the crown prosecutor's office, and the Chief of Police.
What's the answer to the fist question?
- If they are alive, then the medical examiner is wrong.
- If P, then Q.
- If they are deceased, then the medical examiner is right.
- If P, then Q.
In what scenario is "Liknes couple dead, then police are incompetent"? That doesn't fit.
- If the police department is incompetent regardless of whether the Liknes couple is dead or alive, then the issue is police incompetence ... and there is no evidence of that.
- If P, then Q.
All 200 officers, numerous police departments, and the Chief of Police have all conducted themselves admirably. The senior prosecutor has overseen the investigation from beginning to end.
The only question is whether the couple is alive or dead, and whether we have faith in the Medical Examiner.
What do we know about him?
2. If there was a question 2, it would be: on what grounds should police be considered incompetent?
I haven't seen anything saying the ME declared them deceased, please provide the link. Have they even been LEGALLY declared dead yet? Once we establish that fact, then I will take you through it...