Still Missing CO - Suzanne Morphew, 49, Chaffee Co, 10 May 2020 *arrest* #94

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Status
Not open for further replies.
Do we have any additional info regarding the house viewing in Salida? I would love to know what the realtor had to say about the conversation there.

Haven't read any information regarding realtor comments from May 2020 house viewing(s).

However...

11/3/20 CBI Agent Graham spoke with Cara and Steve Marshall previous homeowners of Puma Path.
Cara and Steve separately said they suspected Barry killed Suzanne after hearing the news of her disappearance based upon multiple observations they made of Barry during and after the sale of the house.
AA page 128
 
Pit of Hell sure sounds accurate. I am not a big hunter and yes I did grow up there quite a few years ago. Most of the hunters there are after bigger game, that requires or most often is field dressed at the site of the kill including quartering. The hunting is fairly remote and removal of the animal can be a challenge.
Thank you for the response!
 
On page 112, Barry tells us exactly where some of the money from the *** went.

Barry was asked where the $30,000 from the ******** page for Suzanne went and whether it was used to pay for the Longhorn Ranch property. Barry said, "I don't recall where money went, but like I said, if it, there, a lot of that money, I paid George $4000 cause he, s-, stopped working. I paid a lot of things out of that money, but I don't recall a lot of what it was."

This is a simple "yes" or "no" answer. It's not complicated, you purchased property with that money or you did not.

We always knew it was a scam, but now we know that some of it was certainly used to buy that lot.

This man is so shady it's unbelievable.
We need to add a weasel!
 
It took me 2 hours lol but I found mention of 1:06 p.m.

https://twitter.com/stephaniebutzer/status/1424748784148385794?s=21
Walker says he spoke with Barry the following day (May 11) at 1:06 p.m.

Barry said the last time he saw #SuzanneMorphew was May 10 at 5 a.m. He said they had had a great day and evening. He said she was "his angel" since they were 17 and they "love each other to death."


I think SB must have made a mistake or they are talking about a different interview. Walker was on the stand on the morning of PH day one and we do not have the text from that to know what was said. Plunder picks up 121 pages into the transcript.

(Barry Interview – May 11th)
In the early morning hours of May 11, 2020,
CCSO Detective Burgess and your affiant interviewed Barry Morphew. Barry explained that he left his residence at approximately 5:00 AM on May 10, 2020 to travel to Broomfield, Colorado for a construction job.10 He did not speak to his wife, Suzanne, that morning because she was still asleep when he left. Barry stated that his daughters were to return to their home on May 10th from a camping trip. Barry said that he texted his wife to wish her happy Mother’s Day and did not get a response, possibly due to poor cell service at their residence. Barry said that he tried to text her again later that morning, again with no response. Barry reached his daughters via text messages and they also stated they could not reach their mother.

Barry specifically provided his route of travel to Broomfield, and in all subsequent interviews with CBI, Barry never stated that he turned west on Highway 50.11

Barry explained that his wife’s plan for May 10th was to clean the house and get the spare bedrooms ready for their two daughters coming back, with possibly a friend to visit. Barry said that his wife rides her mountain bike every day. He added that Suzanne was diagnosed with cancer twice in her life and she beat it.

Barry said that he owned firearms and all the firearms and ammunition are stored in a locked gun safe in the garage. It should be noted that on May 11, 2020, while law enforcement searched the Morphew residence, two firearms were located at the residence that were not inside a gun safe. A high-powered rifle was located in a closet on the ground floor in a closet. The rifle appeared to be spray-painted in a camouflage pattern and your affiant could not locate a serial number. A Benelli 12-gauge shotgun was found lying against the wall in the garage. Also, a loaded .22 long rifle cartridge was located lying on the floor in the master bedroom near the right side of the bed.12

After your affiant ended the interview with Barry, he was told that law enforcement was going to seize his truck to process it. (Page 7 of 129)
 
If not for trespassing, I'd be curious to know where the best spot on the property for viewing the patio might be. Good spot for cellphone bars too?

JL could really help us out here. What was Suzanne doing from 11:30 until 1 and then all of 1 until 2:11? Where was she? For that whole time. What was she wearing? Wardrobe changes? Was there an awareness of Barry at all?

Was she outside between 11:30 and 1? Was Barry eavesdropping/watching? Cameras, binoculars? Did he have a dart in his .22? Was he trying to draw a bead on her even then?

Did he go into town because some part of whatever he did was necessary for his mission? For his narrative? For both?

I believe Suzanne thought she had the place all to herself on Saturday -- Barry at work. Probably felt the safest she'd felt in a long time.

If there were any chipmunks around the house that day, it's only because they smell danger and danger was in the woods, back behind the house.

I'm really glad that, in life, Suzanne had her brother Andy. He stopped at nothing, trying to recover her...

She was let down by the other men in her life. Barry, worst of all. And probably down a mineshaft as well.

But JL. He is the one who should have begged for immunity and anonymity. When did he know? I mean know, know. When was his first inkling? Saturday when she stopped responding? Those middle of the night activities on Suzanne's phone? -- did they have a super secret callback app? Akin to "I'll call, let it ring once, you call me back." Is there a thing, where you can make another person's phone ring, but without calling them?

Surely by morning JL must've felt something. No good morning from Suzanne, nothing.

If only he'd had the courage and decency to dial up a wellness check. Saturday. Even Sunday.

In all this, I think the greatest sadness is that Suzanne never got to be her full self. Transparent. Living, loving, making mistakes, correcting them, growing forward, fullfiling her dreams, dreaming new ones

Barry never knew what an absolute treasure she was. He seemed bamboozled that Suzanne should think for herself, want something else from life. He gave her sex and $400 a week, why wasn't that enough? Truly warped sense of what marriage is.

Coming up on two years later, you think he's reflected? Wished he had handled things differently, if only to spare himself the world of expensive trouble he's in?

Leopards don't change their spots.

IMO he's only angrier today than he was then. Angry at Suzanne, angry at cancer, chemo, mixed bathroom chemicals, CBD, IPAs, mountain bikes -- whatever planted those ridiculous thoughts in Suzanne's head. He's likely mad at Spezze, mad at Grusing, mad at LS, mad at anyone who doesn't believe him. None of this would've happened if Suzanne hadn't changed. Her fault.

It's JMO but you know why I think that? Because of how he said it. Tone. Weight.

He. Blames. Her.

Oh, Suzanne.

JMO
 
Last edited:
Several experts have stated that you can't fire tranquilizer darts from a "normal" 22. I'm really interested to know if that is a fact or if there are varying opinions. If you can't shoot a dart from a 22 then shooting her with a dart is out and the bobcat for tampering is out.
 
I'm alittle leery of the investigation in general, but I have to believe that LE was looking high and low for evidence of an affair on Barry's part or anything related to Barry so I do tend to believe they found no evidence of an affair prior to Suzanne going missing. I also have to believe based on the affidavit info that they did interview anyone who called in a "tip" that intrigued them which I have to believe some local would have had the two been spotted. I find it disingenuous to say on one hand that SD doesn't resemble Suzanne at all and how dare someone compare the two and then on the other hand believe she does enough to "fool" people. Wig or no wig.

If one were to immitate another person, I suppose even the closest lookalike would attempt to dress like the person in question. If one were not a close lookalike, more changes would be called for. In either case, I'd think having a similar hair style would be recommended. I don't consider it "disingenuous" to say SD does not look like SM, but that she could, with proper accessories, pass as SM, particularly if the person being fooled would only have a passing glance OR didn't really know SM well.

As far as the investigation goes, I don't think this case hinges on whether SD could pass for SM. It's possible some loose threads could be explained this way, but it does not really matter.

You are good at looking at arguments through the lens of the defense. It would be interesting to compile a list of arguments we think the prosecution will make, have @Momofthreeboys & others put forth possible defense responses, then see how the prosecution might rebut or better present arguments so as not to open themselves to defense wedges.
 
Few random thoughts:
Believe Barry owned an ATV. Wonder if he had a small wagon to attach?
He would have needed to transport body, tools, supplies.
Don't think hot tub involved. He had the Arkansas River for water. Any need to cleanse himself could have been done there whereas using hot tub could leave evidence that needed cleanup so that defeats the purpose and would require additional time.
Believe Barry may have tranq'd Suzanne, set her aside while gathering supplies then just before loading placed her facedown in river to drown.
Then put her in transport and off he goes. Somewhere on or near Puma Path...
Likely near.
In mine or very well camouflaged grave
Edit:
For Barry this really is straightforward.
IMO
 
Last edited:
Haven't read any information regarding realtor comments from May 2020 house viewing(s).

However...

11/3/20 CBI Agent Graham spoke with Cara and Steve Marshall previous homeowners of Puma Path.
Cara and Steve separately said they suspected Barry killed Suzanne after hearing the news of her disappearance based upon multiple observations they made of Barry during and after the sale of the house.
AA page 128

It's fun when you go looking for one thing in the AA and find something else incriminating! Barry is the gift that keeps giving.
 
Several experts have stated that you can't fire tranquilizer darts from a "normal" 22. I'm really interested to know if that is a fact or if there are varying opinions. If you can't shoot a dart from a 22 then shooting her with a dart is out and the bobcat for tampering is out.
I think he could have pushed the dart into her if she wasn’t expecting it.

However I think he did shoot her - because I think he enjoyed it.

JMO
 
Several experts have stated that you can't fire tranquilizer darts from a "normal" 22. I'm really interested to know if that is a fact or if there are varying opinions. If you can't shoot a dart from a 22 then shooting her with a dart is out and the bobcat for tampering is out.

No, they haven't.

Experts have said that you CAN fire those particular darts from a .22.

Here's Grusing on the stand:

A Grusing: So when Agent Harris and I, through our process of speaking with Mr. Morphew we were disclosing parts of our evidence with him to figure out what happened to Suzanne. I did disclose to him that it looked like his cell phone from 2:44 to 2:47 was moving around outside of the house. I believe this was the February 28th interview.

He says, “I shoot chipmunks.” I said well tell me what that means. He goes I’m running around the house shooting chipmunks. And I’m paraphrasing at this time because it’s a back and forth. He said, “I’ve shot 85 chipmunks.”

I asked him if he used a .22 caliber. At that point I had known — and I had not disclosed to Mr. Morphew yet that we found a tranquilizer dart cap in the dryer and I knew from Chaffee county that a .22 cartridge would fire. So when he was talking about running around the outside of the house I asked him if it was a .22 that he used and he said yes, it was.

Shall we go on with Barry and the tranq darts. Let's:

Barry said, “I shoo–, I shoot chipmunks.”

SA Grusing asked, “You shoot chipmunks?”

Barry said, “Yeah.”

SA Grusing said it looks like he was chasing one.

Barry said, “Yeah, I was, I’ve shot 85 chipmunks because they got into my furnace and cost me a bunch of money. So, when I’m home … ”

SA Grusing interrupted and asked if he used a .22, and Barry replied, “Twenty-two. So, when I’m home I just walk around and shoot ’em. Just keep going around the house.” (Barry made circular motions with his right arm.) He said, “Everytime I go around the house, I’ll see another and I’ll shoot it.”

SA Grusing told Barry that activity would explain his phone’s behavior, adding that he left his driver door open in the garage before he went to the first patio. Barry said, “Mhhmhh,” and said,

“Yeah, shootin’,” while nodding his head during the description of movement. He added, “No, I’m shootin’ chipmunks. I’ve done that ever since we’ve moved in.”

SA Grusing asked Barry if he remembered doing it that day. He nodded his head and said, “Mhhmhh, oh yeah.”

Page 71 of 129

SA Grusing asked Barry what happened next. He shook his head and said, “I don’t recall.”
...
(Barry Morphew Interview – February 29, 2021)

While SA Grusing and SA Harris were parked about one block away from Barry’s condo, Barry drove his truck beside the Agents’ car at about 5:03PM and handed a weathered .22 caliber altered rifle with a newly mounted rifle scope to Agents. Barry said that was the gun he used to shoot the chipmunk and he had to leave to workout at the gym.
...
Barry said, “And I gave you my gun. That’s my chipmunk gun. They didn’t even take it.”

SA Grusing said the gun did not appear to have been fired in a long time.

Barry said, “Yeah it has.” He added, “I’m just telling you right now that if I was guilty, I wouldn’t hand over weapons to you guys.”

SA Grusing said Barry’s movements that afternoon, to include the truck door opening, him running from porch to porch and Suzanne not answering texts from her lover look different from investigators’ perspectives.

Barry stated, “I explained that. I mean, there’s, I mean, you can ask anybody that knows me- I’ve sh–, I’ve killed 85 chipmunks at my house. That’s all I do, I mean I can’t sit still. I’m a worker. I’m a busy bee. That’s what I was doing that day.”

SA Grusing asked Barry for permission to ask another question about the chipmunk thing, and Barry said, “Yeah.”

SA Grusing said from 2:44PM to 2:47PM, Barry is going to the porches. Barry said, “Mhhmhh.” SA

Page 76 of 129

Grusing said at 2:47PM, Barry’s phone went into airplane mode. SA Grusing asked Barry if he placed the phone in airplane mode.

Barry asked, “I don’t, where was, Was it on me? Or was it on the kitchen or what?” SA Grusing said the phone movement was how Agents knew Barry was moving around. Barry said, “Oh, because it was on me?”
...
Barry asked for more information about the lover and SA Grusing told Barry he was not cleared as a suspect and would have to be cleared before knowing such things and getting guns back.

Barry said, “I would agree with that, but there’s not one gun in that safe that’s been fired for months.” He added, “The only thing I’ve fired is my chipmunk gun and I guarantee you I fired that, even, be-, even after Suzanne went missing.” Barry confirmed that was the gun he gave Agents.
...

SA Grusing said Agents tried to find Barry chasing the chipmunks on the cameras recovered and could not. He said, “well, I don’t think any cameras were there. They were in the safe.” He added, “Everything was in the safe, they took everything from the safe.”

Page 97 of 129

SA Grusing asked Barry how he knew the chipmunk was outside to chase it that day, and he said, “Oh, they’re always out there. That’s just what I do. I mean, I’ve shot 85 chipmunks at my house. And when I’m bored, I shoot chipmunks.”

SA Grusing said, “Right,” and asked if the chipmunk gun was in the car or truck with him and he said he did not remember.

SA Grusing noted from the evidence it appeared Barry made it from the garage to the porch in seven seconds and asked Barry if he remembered where the gun was.

Barry stated, “I don’t recall. It coulda been in the truck. It might’ve been, but I don’t recall.”

SA Grusing asked if the scope was mounted on the gun at the time and Barry said, “Yeah,” nodding his head.

S Grusing asked Barry what he did with the chipmunk after he killed it and he said he either threw it up on the hill, where the crows come and get them, or down by the river.
...
Barry was asked the last time he saw or heard Suzanne prior to that, and he said, “Just probably before we went to sleep. After we had sex.” SA Grusing asked what happened before that, and Barry said, “Before that we had dinner.” When asked where he sat, Barry said, “At the bar.”

Barry was asked what he ate and what she ate. He said, “Uh, we split a steak ’cause she never eats a full meal.”

When SA Grusing asked what else he or she ate, Barry said, “I don’t recall.”

SA Grusing asked, “Before that?” Barry said, “Before that, I think um, it had to be when I got home from doing my bobcat with Crib. And she was outside, laying out in the sun.”

He added, “I think I sat out there with her. I don’t know if that’s when I did the chipmunks or, when the, did the chipmunks before I went to Crib, I don’t recall (unintelligible- UI).”76

SA Grusing said because of Barry’s phone activity, the chipmunks would have occurred after the Crib trip.

Barry stated, “Ok, then the chipmunks, she was layin’ out, I was lookin’- I probably went to sit with her while she was laying out, seen a chipmunk and got my gun and shot the chipmunk.”
...
(Barry Interview – May 28th)
On May 28, 2020, CBI Agent Cahill and Agent Derek Graham interviewed Barry and audio recorded the interview.

Barry was asked about the tranquilizer darts in his house. He stated that the darts’ purpose was to tranquilize bucks to sell them. He said the bucks could then be placed in a trailer that has cubicles. The tranquilizer is a sedative/narcotic and he only did this “tranqing” and selling of bucks back in Indiana. Barry said he has not used the tranquilizer or darts in Colorado.32
...
Barry replied, “And I, I have shot, and again I have told you I don’t want to get in trouble with the DNR,” SA Grusing inserted he was not. Barry continued, “I’m tellin’ you, I’m telllin’ you right now I’ve shot two deer with my tranq gun, ’cause I used to raise deer, and I collect horns, and I’ll tell you exactly what I did.”

He continued, “They’re in the yard. They’re in the yard. I shoot ’em, they go to sleep. I cut their horns off, and I wake ’em up, and they go off with no horns on their head, and I cut their horns.”

SA Grusing said Barry’s friends in Indiana talked about that and he replied, “And, and it’s totally illegal. And, so I’m not gonna share that with the DNR, the way they are, and (exhale), they come arrest me. So, things like that, in my head, ‘What should I say?’ And nobody even asked me about that tranq dart, but you’re gonna find tranq darts around my property because I’ve done that.”
...
SA Grusing said the evidence of the tranq dart was found inside the house. Barry replied, “Yeah, or I, I’ve shot deer from that little breezeway from between the garage and the laundry room, out that back door.”75

SA Grusing asked about the back door and Barry said, “The back door is outside the kitchen window where the bird, uh, bath is. Yeah, yeah, if there was a tranq dart out there or outside or in the house it’s from me shootin’ deer.”
...
(Discussion of Exhibit 19)
Barry was shown photos of the dart boxes recovered from the search and asked if he recalled what all areas around the house he fired them.

He replied, “No, I don’t. I know I have fired from the breezeway before and I’ve fired them from the garage at deer that were up on the hill behind the rock wall.” (See Attachment 5)

Barry was asked if he ever missed a shot and he said, “A deer? Oh no.” He continued, “No, I used to raise deer, I’ve shot hundreds.”

SA Grusing asked if it was ever fired in the house.

Page 109 of 129

Barry said, “Only if it was open in that door in that breezeway. But, not, not inside the house.”
...

In case anyone missed Barry's super secret code, Suzanne is the chipmunk.
 
Several experts have stated that you can't fire tranquilizer darts from a "normal" 22. I'm really interested to know if that is a fact or if there are varying opinions. If you can't shoot a dart from a 22 then shooting her with a dart is out and the bobcat for tampering is out.
Do we know that LE is aware of every gun that Barry possessed? I doubt it. I wonder what was normally in the rifle storage case under the bed. Barry stated that all guns were kept in his safe, and that turned out to be a lie. I believe that the tranquilizer dart was involved, but it didn’t come out of the chipmunk gun. There was either another gun capable of darting that is long gone, or he plunged the dart into Suzanne by hand. Of course, not a fact, but my thoughts and mine alone.
 
Few random thoughts:
Believe Barry owned an ATV. Wonder if he had a small wagon to attach?
He would have needed to transport body, tools, supplies.
Don't think hot tub involved. He had the Arkansas River for water. Any need to cleanse himself could have been done there whereas using hot tub could leave evidence that needed cleanup so that defeats the purpose and would require additional time.
Believe Barry may have tranq'd Suzanne, set her aside while gathering supplies then just before loading placed her facedown in river to drown.
Then put her in transport and off he goes. Somewhere on or near Puma Path...
Likely near.
In mine or very well camouflaged grave
Edit:
For Barry this really is straightforward.
IMO

Before making the South Arkansas a murderer in broad daylight, you might want to note that the Ritter house is right across the river from the Morphew house. I do agree that he used the river to clean himself up after hiding the body, though.
Google Maps

Barry had an ATV. He probably had a wagon, but it wouldn't be necessary and might even be a hindrance on the rocky terrain.
 
I do not think I have read anything where someone has given any plausible alternative scenario for what happened to Suzanne ,taking into account all of Barry's actions that weekend and Suzanne's digital silence.
 
Last edited:
Due to popular demand, I have now added rats, crabs and snipes to the zoo. (I'll be passing the hat around soon for all the extra buildings required.) The snipes are quite well-behaved, and the rats are really cute, but the crabs! Scuttling here, there and everywhere, and don't even try to keep in their proper place in the choir :eek:.
:D:D
 
Before making the South Arkansas a murderer in broad daylight, you might want to note that the Ritter house is right across the river from the Morphew house. I do agree that he used the river to clean himself up after hiding the body, though.
Google Maps

Barry had an ATV. He probably had a wagon, but it wouldn't be necessary and might even be a hindrance on the rocky terrain.

Thanks for mentioning Arkansas River in view of Ritter's. The river is long so thought he'd have privacy.
Could see Barry packing a bucket of water though in which she could drown. This would keep her alive
longer and decrease chance of cadaverine transfer. He may have needed water for burial cover-up too (mixing concrete, chemicals, etc).
I think drowning Suzanne is a hands off method that Barry may have used. Though I mentioned hot tub not being used he could have submerged her face below water.
Alternately he could have strangled her hence the fingernail indents on his arm or they could be from a surprise headlock to manually inject tranquilizer.
If not ATV what type transport do you think ideal for terrain and maneuvering?
If Suzanne was tranquilized her killing and cover-up would be second nature for Barry. Just replace her for the deer he's done this to many times. He's on record saying he could bury a body that would never be found so for Barry location may not be as important. I think his biggest obstacles may have been telematics and detection.
 
Last edited:
If not for trespassing, I'd be curious to know where the best spot on the property for viewing the patio might be. Good spot for cellphone bars too?

JL could really help us out here. What was Suzanne doing from 11:30 until 1 and then all of 1 until 2:11? Where was she? For that whole time. What was she wearing? Wardrobe changes? Was there an awareness of Barry at all?

Was she outside between 11:30 and 1? Was Barry eavesdropping/watching? Cameras, binoculars? Did he have a dart in his .22? Was he trying to draw a bead on her even then?

Did he go into town because some part of whatever he did was necessary for his mission? For his narrative? For both?

I believe Suzanne thought she had the place all to herself on Saturday -- Barry at work. Probably felt the safest she'd felt in a long time.

If there were any chipmunks around the house that day, it's only because they smell danger and danger was in the woods, back behind the house.

I'm really glad that, in life, Suzanne had her brother Andy. He stopped at nothing, trying to recover her...

She was let down by the other men in her life. Barry, worst of all. And probably down a mineshaft as well.

But JL. He is the one who should have begged for immunity and anonymity. When did he know? I mean know, know. When was his first inkling? Saturday when she stopped responding? Those middle of the night activities on Suzanne's phone? -- did they have a super secret callback app? Akin to "I'll call, let it ring once, you call me back." Is there a thing, where you can make another person's phone ring, but without calling them?

Surely by morning JL must've felt something. No good morning from Suzanne, nothing.

If only he'd had the courage and decency to dial up a wellness check. Saturday. Even Sunday.

In all this, I think the greatest sadness is that Suzanne never got to be her full self. Transparent. Living, loving, making mistakes, correcting them, growing forward, fullfiling her dreams, dreaming new ones

Barry never knew what an absolute treasure she was. He seemed bamboozled that Suzanne should think for herself, want something else from life. He gave her sex and $400 a week, why wasn't that enough? Truly warped sense of what marriage is.

Coming up on two years later, you think he's reflected? Wished he had handled things differently, if only to spare himself the world of expensive trouble he's in?

Leopards don't change their spots.

IMO he's only angrier today than he was then. Angry at Suzanne, angry at cancer, chemo, mixed bathroom chemicals, CBD, IPAs, mountain bikes -- whatever planted those ridiculous thoughts in Suzanne's head. He's likely mad at Spezze, mad at Grusing, mad at LS, mad at anyone who doesn't believe him. None of this would've happened if Suzanne hadn't changed. Her fault.

It's JMO but you know why I think that? Because of how he said it. Tone. Weight.

He. Blames. Her.

Oh, Suzanne.

JMO
So well written there isn't anything more to add.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
83
Guests online
248
Total visitors
331

Forum statistics

Threads
609,777
Messages
18,257,828
Members
234,757
Latest member
Kezzie
Back
Top