Something that bothers me, and no one has ever pointed out is that Markel did the visiting professorship at NYU when the children were very young. The children were born July 2009 and Oct 2010. Markel was visiting professor at NYU for all of 2011. Here's the entry on NYU's site
http://www.law.nyu.edu/centers/adminofcriminallaw/facultyandstaff/scholarsinresidence/2011 . And here's the FSU course schedules that show him not teaching in Spring 2011
https://web.archive.org/web/2010121...demic_programs/curriculum/spring11byclass.pdf and Fall 2011
https://web.archive.org/web/2013022...cademic_programs/curriculum/fall11byclass.pdf Both schedules show Adelson teaching, but Markel is not. (Both taught in Fall 2010 and FSU even published her due date in the course schedule
https://web.archive.org/web/2010061...cademic_programs/curriculum/fall10byclass.pdf.) He already had tenure and guaranteed high paying employment in Tallahassee, but he still did the year of two-under-two at NYU. I can't find an NYU course schedule for Spring 2011, but I would assume that if he was visiting professor there that he was physically in New York, even if he came home on the weekend.
He finalized arrangements while his wife was pregnant. In January, when he'd have started in New York, his wife had to care for a 3 month old and a 17 month old at the same time. It's really hard to take care of young children. She had to work. There she is on the schedule teaching in January 2011, with classes starting while the baby is still 2 months old. People who knew him growing up tend to be from Canada, but these children were born in the U.S. and under U.S. maternity policies. Maybe that is why no one bats an eye. This was the second baby. He knew what a newborn would be like. Even if he came home on weekends, that is not the same as being there consistently at 3am. The divorce could not have been a surprise.
This coupled with the news article about, "Despite the continuing anguish over his divorce, Markel was moving on. He'd fallen in love with a new woman, a law professor at New York University in New York City, friends said, where he often visited and in 2011 was a scholar-in-residence."
http://www.tallahassee.com/story/ne...line-innovator-friend-violent-death/13232743/
I'm not saying he should have been killed or in any way trying to justify that. I'm saying that it's not reasonable to think the divorce was a surprise.