GUILTY FL - Three women, 6yo girl shot to death at Jupiter Thanksgiving dinner, 26 Nov 2009

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
The mind of Paul Merhige: Trying to unravel a mental mystery

Now that he has been captured and cuffed and paraded for the cameras, all the attorneys, moralists and armchair puzzlers can begin to try to fathom the strange synapses of Paul Michael Merhige’s mind.

Was he insane or a sociopath? Did he ever feel remorse?

What thoughts wound through him in his last days of freedom in a Keys hotel, a mattress against the door, apparent suicide devices in a closet?

However the tangled, knotty mass of Merhige’s brain functioned, it appeared to harbor a penchant for violent gestures from an early age.

After an argument in his childhood home in a Miami suburb, a teenage Merhige pulled out a loaded gun and pointed it at terrified family members, a person close to the family said. He was maybe 13 at the time.

Merhige never fired a shot, and it’s unclear how he acquired the gun, but the incident was a chilling foreshadowing of the fourfold massacre to come more than 20 years later, at Thanksgiving dinner in his cousin’s Jupiter home.

~~~~~~~~

He was by no means a functioning member of society. After studying at the University of Miami, he had never held a job and was supported his whole life by his parents. He once shot himself in a supposed suicide attempt and allegedly threatened years ago to cut the throat of one of his sisters.

He was said to be obsessive*-compulsive. An old family acquaintance said he feared germs. At the Keys hotel where he hid out, the owner said Merhige left his room only to wash his clothes.

As authorities scoured South Florida, U.S. marshals knew the suspect would be in pants. Merhige, for unknown reasons, refused to wear shorts.

'Spoon-fed … his whole life’

But was he insane? It may be a jury that ultimately decides whether he meets the state’s legal definition, but various experts say he likely does not.

Veteran criminal profilers point out that his behavior appeared more akin to that of a sociopath than the clinically insane: He knew that killing people was wrong; he just didn’t care.

“You could make the case that this wasn’t some delusional act,” said Gregg McCrary, a former FBI criminal profiler. “(His escape) indicates he appreciated the wrongfulness of what he was doing. He did it and then he fled.”


http://www.palmbeachpost.com/news/crime/the-mind-of-paul-merhige-trying-to-unravel-171565.html
 
Merhige's lawyer seeks to prevent release of evidence in case to public, media

WEST PALM BEACH — Paul Michael Merhige's defense attorney is asking a judge to prevent all evidence against him from being released to the public and media until the first-degree murder case against him is concluded.

Public Defender Carey Haughwout — noting the extensive publicity the Thanksigving Day murders has already garnered — made the extraordinary request in a written motion before Circuit Judge John Hoy. Haughwout also asked Hoy to order all attorneys, police and witnesses involved not to comment on the case publicly.

Haughwout cited Merhige's right to fair trial and what she deems the prejudicial nature all the Merhige publicity.

"Witnesses have been quoted calling for the death penalty as well as referring to the defendant as a 'monster',' Haughwout wrote.

The request may well set a showdown between the First Amendment right to freedom of speech and the Sixth Amendment right to a fair trial. Media outlets, including The Palm Beach Post, can be expected to oppose the request.

Hoy will hear arguments at a specially set hearing on Jan. 29.


http://www.palmbeachpost.com/news/merhige-s-lawyer-seeks-to-prevent-release-of-189353.html
 
Merhige's lawyer seeks to prevent release of evidence in case to public, media

WEST PALM BEACH — Paul Michael Merhige's defense attorney is asking a judge to prevent all evidence against him from being released to the public and media until the first-degree murder case against him is concluded.

Public Defender Carey Haughwout — noting the extensive publicity the Thanksigving Day murders has already garnered — made the extraordinary request in a written motion before Circuit Judge John Hoy. Haughwout also asked Hoy to order all attorneys, police and witnesses involved not to comment on the case publicly.

Haughwout cited Merhige's right to fair trial and what she deems the prejudicial nature all the Merhige publicity.

"Witnesses have been quoted calling for the death penalty as well as referring to the defendant as a 'monster',' Haughwout wrote.

The request may well set a showdown between the First Amendment right to freedom of speech and the Sixth Amendment right to a fair trial. Media outlets, including The Palm Beach Post, can be expected to oppose the request.

Hoy will hear arguments at a specially set hearing on Jan. 29.


http://www.palmbeachpost.com/news/merhige-s-lawyer-seeks-to-prevent-release-of-189353.html

I hate to tell Merhige's lawyer, but this isn't going to happen in the "sunshine state". Bring on the documents!
 
Merhige indicted on murder charges

WEST PALM BEACH -- A Palm Beach County grand jury has indicted Paul Michael Merhige on four counts of first-degree murder and three counts of attempted first-degree murder.

The indictment was handed up Thursday afternoon and the state attorney says he will seek the death penalty.


http://www.tcpalm.com/news/2010/jan/28/merhige-indicted-murder-charges/

State to seek death penalty against alleged Thanksgiving Day killer

WEST PALM BEACH — Prosecutors have decided to seek the death penalty for Paul Michael Merhige, the man accused of fatally shooting four family members in a Thanksgiving rampage in Jupiter.

The decision, announced today by State Attorney Michael McAuliffe, comes almost a month after Merhige's Jan. 2 capture in a Florida Keys hotel, where he had hid out for weeks after allegedly shooting dead his twin sisters, his aunt and his cousin's 6-year-old daughter at Thanksgiving dinner.

The horrific scale of his alleged crime and the prolonged national manhunt made him one of the nation's most wanted criminals for more than a month. After his capture, the father of one of the victims and the celebrity host of the 'America's Most Wanted' television program each called on McAuliffe to seek to have Merhige executed.

"If there's anyone who deserves the death penalty, it is someone who would execute my 6-year-old daughter while she is in bed," said Jim Sitton, the father of Makayla Sitton, earlier this month.


http://www.palmbeachpost.com/news/c...alty-against-alleged-thanksgiving-200202.html

Death Penalty for Thanksgiving Dinner Massacre

http://www.nbcmiami.com/news/local-beat/Death-Penalty-for-Thanksgiving-Day-Massacre-82963502.html

BREAKING NEWS: State seeks death in case of Thanksgiving shooter

http://www.cbs12.com/news/degree-4723897-counts-first.html
 
Thanksgiving shooting suspect pleads not guilty

Posted on Monday, 02.01.10
The Associated Press


WEST PALM BEACH, Fla. -- A man accused of fatally shooting four relatives at a South Florida Thanksgiving dinner has pleaded not guilty to all counts.

A hearing for Paul Merhige scheduled for Monday was canceled after his attorney entered a written plea of not guilty to four counts of first-degree murder and three counts of attempted murder.

Merhige is now due in court Friday. His attorney will argue for a gag order and to keep all evidence in the case sealed until it is concluded.


more here

http://www.miamiherald.com/news/florida/AP/story/1456984.html
 
Merhige makes unexpected court appearance

WEST PALM BEACH, FL--Paul Michael Merhige made a surprise appearance at a hearing Friday into whether there should be disclosure of the discovery process in his eventual trial.

He is accused of killing his twin sisters, 79-year-old aunt and 6-year-old cousin on Thanksgiving Day at a family gathering in Jupiter. One of his sisters was pregnant. He's also accused of wounding two other family members.

In January, a Palm Beach County Public Defender filed a motion that would prohibit the public disclosure of all discovery materials as well as prohibit prejudicial comments by attorneys, investigators and witnesses.

It is the first indication of where Merhige's defense wants to take the case.

...........

The defense, hoping to give its client a fair trial, wrote: "Between Thanksgiving and the time of his arrest, there was unending, saturating publicity concerning the facts of the case. The media attention to this case has been almost unprecedented. The problem is compounded by the fact that at least one witness/family member is employed at a local TV station."

Photographer Jim Sitton works at WPTV. Not only was his home the site of the crime, but his daughter Makayla and mother-in-law Raymonde Joseph, were among the victims.

In court Friday afternoon a judge ruled that discovery information will be released ten days after it is presented to the court.

Merhige didn't have to be at the hearing, but a courtroom source said he wanted to attend.

He was surrounded by as many as 8 deputies as he was transported in and out of the courtroom.

He looked around the room during the proceeding.

On April 1st lawyers will reconvene to talk about setting a trial date.


http://www.wptv.com/content/news/no...ce-discovery-wptv/JQ5SHJwEnk6SekZjKleOsg.cspx
 
Couple gets $100,000 reward for finding Thanksgiving murder suspect
Posted on Thursday, 03.04.10

The owners of the Edgewater Lodge in the Florida Keys have received the $100,000 reward for providing the tip that led to the capture of a fugitive wanted for killing four family members on Thanksgiving Day in Palm Beach County.

Paul Michael Merhige, 35, had been on the run for 38 days until Paul Pfaff recognized him on America's Most Wanted as a guest at their motel and Melinda Pfaff called the program's hot line minutes later.

``There is nothing to celebrate; we're not going to take a big trip,'' Melinda Pfaff said. ``He killed people in his family and put my family's life in danger.''

The couple have no specific plans on how to spend the money, but Melinda Pfaff said it's likely they will save it for practical reasons like medical emergencies.

``The only reason I want to talk about it is to let people know that rewards are paid and not to be hesitant to call in something,'' she said.

``I'm sure he picked this place because it's small and we don't even have a newspaper box,'' Melinda Pfaff said.

But on Jan. 2, Paul Pfaff was watching football when he saw a preview of the upcoming episode of America's Most Wanted. Pfaff said he recognized the man in the video as the guest who had registered as Paul Baca, and kept his Toyota Camry covered with a tarp.

Merhige had been staying for a month in Room 14, a $69-a-night efficiency next to the room where the Pfaffs' 21-year-old daughter lived.

Melinda Pfaff went on the Internet to look up Merhige's picture and agreed Baca was the same guy. She called the hot line while Paul Pfaff yelled in the background: ``Come get him now.''

Before making the call, the Pfaffs evacuated everyone staying in rooms in the main building that included the office.


more here


http://www.miamiherald.com/2010/03/04/1513499/couple-gets-100000-reward-for.html

Thank goodness they got involved...I sense they would have done it even if no huge reward was offered.
 
Mar 9, 2010 2:21 pm US/Eastern
Thanksgiving Shooting Victim Awakes From Coma
Patrick Knight Injured In Thanksgiving Night Massacre
His Wife, Unborn Child, Aunt & 6-Year-Old Cousin Were Killed


Patrick Knight, whose wife, unborn child and other family members were shot and killed during a Thanksgiving night dinner in Jupiter, is finally awake from his coma.

According to the Facebook page, "In Memory of Makayla Joy Sitton", Patrick is "now awake, yet is in ICU. He is not able to see visitors and has a trache yet is communicating through a communication board." The person who posted the message, Beth Knight, goes on to say, "He does recall the event and has been told about Lisa and the baby, along with the rest of the victims."


http://cbs4.com/local/Paul.Merhige.Patrick.2.1547383.html

~~~~

Victim of Thanksgiving Day shooting out of coma, relative says

A Miami attorney nearly killed in a Thanksgiving Day massacre in Jupiter that left four dead has emerged from a months-long coma to learn that his wife and unborn child died in the murderous attack.

Patrick Knight had been in a coma in the intensive-care unit at St. Mary's Medical Center since Paul Michael Merhige, his wife's mentally troubled brother, opened fire on a holiday family gathering on Nov. 26 .

The shooting left his wife, Lisa Knight, and her twin sister, Carla Merhige, dead, along with two other relatives: 6-year-old Makayla Sitton; and her grandmother, 76-year-old Raymonde Joseph, a Jupiter retiree.

Knight's family has generally declined to discuss his condition as he recovers, but his sister-in-law announced on the Facebook social networking Web site that the 37-year-old attorney is now awake.

"He (Patrick) does recall the event and has been told about Lisa and the baby, along with the rest of the victims," wrote Beth Knight, his sister-in-law, in a comment posted Monday night on a Facebook page dedicated to Makayla Sitton.


http://www.palmbeachpost.com/news/victim-of-thanksgiving-day-jupiter-shooting-out-of-334154.html
 
After the bloodbath on Thanksgiving Day that left four relatives dead, Paul Michael Merhige, the man accused of the killings, made his way to the Florida Keys where he bought supplies to end his own life — and the best-seller handbook on how to do it, prosecutors say.

On Dec. 1, from Borders Express in Key West, he ordered "Final Exit: The Practicalities of Self-Deliverance and Assisted Suicide for the Dying." In the following days he starting buying supplies to do just that, according to a portion of evidence in the case released by prosecutors Thursday.

(snip)

http://www.sun-sentinel.com/news/pa...illings-merhige-case-20100401,0,3276726.story
 
A book has been published, based on audio recordings of Makayla telling her stories.
Her mother kept these and a children's book is available. Proceeds will go to help disadvantaged children have access to the arts.

http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/40357502/ns/today-books/

Coping with this tragedy and their grief will be a lifelong process, the Sittons said. And their first big step was when they remembered “the recordings.”

Muriel said she still can’t remember why she first picked up the little cassette recorder and started taping her daughter. Today, she has a treasure: Hours of audio recordings where Makayla, a talkative child, chats about her world.

One day, Muriel asked her daughter: “Tell me a story.” Instantly, an impromptu tale of a bear and a unicorn poured out.

This past year, Makayla’s parents would listen to that tape over and over and over. The lively, well-structured fantasy was their private keepsake until they wondered: If they shared this story with Makayla’s friends, would it keep her memory alive?

From that simple question was born a book: “The Bear’s Castle” by Makayla Joy Sitton.
 
A book has been published, based on audio recordings of Makayla telling her stories.
Her mother kept these and a children's book is available. Proceeds will go to help disadvantaged children have access to the arts.

http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/40357502/ns/today-books/

Coping with this tragedy and their grief will be a lifelong process, the Sittons said. And their first big step was when they remembered “the recordings.”

Muriel said she still can’t remember why she first picked up the little cassette recorder and started taping her daughter. Today, she has a treasure: Hours of audio recordings where Makayla, a talkative child, chats about her world.

One day, Muriel asked her daughter: “Tell me a story.” Instantly, an impromptu tale of a bear and a unicorn poured out.

This past year, Makayla’s parents would listen to that tape over and over and over. The lively, well-structured fantasy was their private keepsake until they wondered: If they shared this story with Makayla’s friends, would it keep her memory alive?

From that simple question was born a book: “The Bear’s Castle” by Makayla Joy Sitton.

I just heard of this tragedy, and now I would like to know, where do we buy the book? Off to search, after trying to dry my eyes.
 
http://www.sun-sentinel.com/news/palm-beach/pb-merhige-trial-postponed-brf-20110616,0,5851110.story

June 16, 2011

A judge has agreed to delay the murder trial of Paul Michael Merhige, the man charged in the Thanksgiving Day 2009 murders of four of his family members.

Merhige has been in police custody since January 2010, when he was captured in the Florida Keys after a monthlong manhunt.

...Merhige's trial was scheduled to begin in August, but Circuit Judge Joseph Marx on Thursday granted defense attorneys' request to move the trial to Jan. 17.

Marx also gave defense attorneys a month to produce a mental health expert to prosecutors so they can question him regarding Merhige's psychological state.
 
WEST PALM BEACH -- Taking a locket from around his neck, Jim Sitton held up a photo of his slain daughter to explain why he and his wife Thursday filed what is expected to be a multimillion-dollar lawsuit against the parents of the man who went on a murderous rampage in their Jupiter home on Thanksgiving Day 2009.

“This is about Makayla and my wife’s mother,” Sitton said, referring to his 6-year-old daughter and his 76-year-old mother-in-law, Raymonde Joseph. They were among the four relatives Paul Merhige allegedly shot before fleeing.

Carole and Michael Merhige set the stage for the carnage, according to the negligence lawsuit filed in Palm Beach County Circuit Court. In a series of emails, it is clear they invited their then-35-year-old son to the family gathering without alerting the Sittons, the suit states. Further, when he opened fire, killing his twin sisters, Joseph and finally Makayla, they did nothing to stop him.

Read more: http://www.miamiherald.com/2011/09/15/2409244/victims-family-sues-parents-of.html#ixzz1Y7PFcQZw
 
http://www.wptv.com/dpp/news/merhige,-sitton-familes-emotional-reaction-to-plea-deal
Seven life sentences

The Sittons said they put up as much of a fight as they could, and they are taking comfort knowing that Makayla's killer will not ever see the light of day again. "In the end, he has gotten death in prison and we know that in the end he will never come out except in a box, and there is comfort in that," said Makayla's mother.
The couple, meanwhile, recently announced they are expecting a new baby, a girl, early next year.
 
Article on how crazy the killer was. His lawyers were going argue for the insanity defense but instead reached the plea agreement.

Sucked his thumb and it had to be wrapped in plastic. Wore 2 pairs of undies at times, so he wouldn't impregnate any women somehow. Had many violent episodes with family, should have never been invited to Thanksgiving. Had lunged at one sister and threated to slit her throat, she got a restraining order against him.


http://www.federalnewsradio.com/?nid=615&sid=2622163
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
78
Guests online
1,770
Total visitors
1,848

Forum statistics

Threads
601,427
Messages
18,124,461
Members
231,049
Latest member
rythmico
Back
Top