ArmchairDefective
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Aug 3, 2021
- Messages
- 77
- Reaction score
- 873
I think we can narrow the timeline much more than this. If Katie was 10 minutes away from where she was killed at 12:09, she would have had to arrive at that spot at about 12:20. If it had been a completely normal walk and she had turned around immediately and returned home, if she lived very, very close to where she was videoed, she would have arrived home at around 12:35. Let’s suppose this is the case and that’s when she would normally be expected back. Surely her fiancé didn’t raise the alarm immediately—give her 10 minutes, say 12:45. Then the fiancé calls and texts a few times, consults her app, sees Katie’s phone in the park, watches it a while to see it isn’t moving, becomes worried, goes to the park, by then it has to be 12:55 or later, discovers the body, runs out, calls the police (gotta be around 1am or a little after since the cops arrived at 1:10). Almost every minute is accounted for if Katie was killed between 12:20 and 12:30. I just don’t think it could be much later than 12:30. If she was still alive at 12:30, she would have had to be on her way home. The timeline doesn’t work with a later killing.
Something I'm confused about is where Katie was between 11:30 and 12:09. Her wife says she last saw her at 11:30 at her work, Henry's Midtown, which is just one block up from the rainbow crosswalk where Katie was pictured at 12:09. So did Katie walk up 10th Street away from the park and then circle back? Or is her wife perhaps mistaken about what time it was when she stopped by? I was just assuming that given the close proximity, she went straight from Henry's to the rainbow crosswalk but that would be a walk of just a couple of minutes at most.