Hatfield's and McCoys - History Channel

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves

After watching the history channel mini series I put most of the blame on...


  • Total voters
    56
i felt so bad that Cotton Top was hung. i know he killed that girl but i don't even think he did it on purpose. he was reacting to what he was told to do and it scared him when they came out the door. on his own i don't think he would have hurt a fly.

Awww athy, me too!! That was the worst part of the movie for me, besides when they killed his Daddy. Thank goodness we now have competency hearings.

We tivo'd all three episodes. Hubby will no doubt watch them again when he gets bored with the Justified reruns
icon7.gif
 
OMG! I almost forgot to add that the following post contains SPOILERS....so if you haven't seen the program yet, then you may want to stop reading now!

I don't know about anyone else, but even though the entire mini-series was filled with gut wrenching moments, it was the ending that haunted me the most. The death of Frank Phillips' character (if the program was accurate) just came out of nowhere. It sent chills up my spine.

Even more haunting was how Randall McCoy basically drove himself insane by the end and ended up going in a blaze of glory so to speak. And how about the scenes where Devil Anse took Johnse "fishing" (yeah right) and spent the entire time with his hand on his gun? Did anyone else think that those scenes in particular were acted beautifully? Of course, I especially appreciated towards the end when McCoy was sending his wife to an institution and she called him out by looking him straight in the eye and saying, "you aren't sending me away to 'get better'. You're sending me away so that you can go to hell with Perry Cline." LOL. How perfect!

All in all, I really enjoyed this mini-series. It was just one of the many gems that I enjoy on the History channel.

Couple of my favorite actors were in this movie. Love, love, love- Mare Winningham, have for years so that was a treat. Also Powers Boothe.

What was it she wanted in the movie? Drawing a blank, it was something electrical.
 
Couple of my favorite actors were in this movie. Love, love, love- Mare Winningham, have for years so that was a treat. Also Powers Boothe.

What was it she wanted in the movie? Drawing a blank, it was something electrical.

I think it was a pressure cooker.
 
I dvr'd all 3 parts that just aired on Lifetime. That's the same one as the History channel one, right? Anyway, I haven't been motivated to watch it and almost deleted it, but it sounds like I should watch it! Glad I read this thread!
 
I dvr'd all 3 parts that just aired on Lifetime. That's the same one as the History channel one, right? Anyway, I haven't been motivated to watch it and almost deleted it, but it sounds like I should watch it! Glad I read this thread!

Yeah, if it has Kevin Costner in it then it's the same one. I'm pretty sure it is. Yes, you should watch it. It's the best ever made for TV movie IMO.
 
I'm sure no one will ever know just how accurate this series was compared to the actual facts, but I think the filmmakers did an OUTSTANDING job and so did the actors, every one of them. To me, the main "message" of this whole sordid saga rang clear and true: that hatred, resentment, pride, ego and rage are pure poison, and oh, "the damage done"... Especially appalling was the way both of these powerful patriarchs were so willing to sacrifice their own children just to "win." That scene where Johnse asks his father (who's about to shoot him) if he would have let him drown as a boy brought me to tears. Johnse wasn't bad or a traitor, he was just young and naive, and like he said, he didn't have enough "hate in his heart" to be a Hatfield. And towards the end of part 3, when McCoy's youngest son lay dying on the ground, with blood bubbling out of his mouth, I teared up again, especially because the boy looked so much like my 13-year-old son. How could these fathers lead their sons into such danger and death? It certainly was a "different time," but I don't think these people and their ways were the norm! I think resentment left over from the Civil War had everything to do with this feud, and war had changed both men, not for the better. This story really makes you think about how strongly and irrevocably a parent's actions and words affect their children, and also how many so-called "Christians" (McCoy) walk around damning others while acting anything but Christ-like themselves.
 
I'm sure no one will ever know just how accurate this series was compared to the actual facts, but I think the filmmakers did an OUTSTANDING job and so did the actors, every one of them. To me, the main "message" of this whole sordid saga rang clear and true: that hatred, resentment, pride, ego and rage are pure poison, and oh, "the damage done"... Especially appalling was the way both of these powerful patriarchs were so willing to sacrifice their own children just to "win." That scene where Johnse asks his father (who's about to shoot him) if he would have let him drown as a boy brought me to tears. Johnse wasn't bad or a traitor, he was just young and naive, and like he said, he didn't have enough "hate in his heart" to be a Hatfield. And towards the end of part 3, when McCoy's youngest son lay dying on the ground, with blood bubbling out of his mouth, I teared up again, especially because the boy looked so much like my 13-year-old son. How could these fathers lead their sons into such danger and death? It certainly was a "different time," but I don't think these people and their ways were the norm! I think resentment left over from the Civil War had everything to do with this feud, and war had changed both men, not for the better. This story really makes you think about how strongly and irrevocably a parent's actions and words affect their children, and also how many so-called "Christians" (McCoy) walk around damning others while acting anything but Christ-like themselves.

BBM

At the end both families are totally destroyed. It seems they both pretty much got what they deserved in the end. JMO
 
Well....I stayed up all night and watched all 3 episodes! It was awesome!!! Needless to say, I'm tired today, but it was worth it.

Loved the whole Roseanna/Johnse storyline, but a bit of research has led me to believe that he wasn't as enamoured of her as the miniseries indicated. I'm always a sucker for a good love story (still hoping that someday my own will come along...although I've pretty much accepted the unlikelihood of that), so even though I already knew that it wasn't going to end well I still found myself rooting for them.

Anyway, great miniseries and I'm glad I took everyone's advice and watched it!
 
Well....I stayed up all night and watched all 3 episodes! It was awesome!!! Needless to say, I'm tired today, but it was worth it.

Loved the whole Roseanna/Johnse storyline, but a bit of research has led me to believe that he wasn't as enamoured of her as the miniseries indicated. I'm always a sucker for a good love story (still hoping that someday my own will come along...although I've pretty much accepted the unlikelihood of that), so even though I already knew that it wasn't going to end well I still found myself rooting for them.

Anyway, great miniseries and I'm glad I took everyone's advice and watched it!

Iv watched it three times!
It was a great mini series!
I really thought devil hatfield was going to shoot Johnsey these ppl shot anyone women children dogs! even their own family members!
 
Devil Hatfield and randall mccoy lived to their 90's I dont know how lol but they did.
Guess cause they killed everyone else!
 
Devil Hatfield and randall mccoy lived to their 90's I dont know how lol but they did.
Guess cause they killed everyone else!

the reason they lived that long: my mother would say "pure meanness"

oh, and my mom is still alive :)
 
Couple of my favorite actors were in this movie. Love, love, love- Mare Winningham, have for years so that was a treat. Also Powers Boothe.

What was it she wanted in the movie? Drawing a blank, it was something electrical.


Sally wanted some of those electric lightening balls.


Powers Booth was in Southern Comfort with Keith Carradine. He was also in Tombstone with Tom Berenger and Bill Paxton.

Keith Carradine and Tom Berenger were in "Into The West".

Mare Winningham and Keith Carradine were in several movies together.

Kevin Costner and Tom Berenger were in The Big Chill together.


OK I'll stop.

ILTBP
 
Sally wanted some of those electric lightening balls.


Powers Booth was in Southern Comfort with Keith Carradine. He was also in Tombstone with Tom Berenger and Bill Paxton.

Keith Carradine and Tom Berenger were in "Into The West".

Mare Winningham and Keith Carradine were in several movies together.

Kevin Costner and Tom Berenger were in The Big Chill together.


OK I'll stop.

ILTBP

So what does that have to do with Kevin Bacon? :waitasec:
 
Hubby and I have seen parts 1 and 2 and will have to wait until it's reran again to watch part 3, so didn't vote. However, this has been the best show on TV in such a long time. I hope we see more of the same in the future on the History channel.
Yes, Steely things were so different then concerning the law and the way things were handled.
In the Juryroom down stairs is a thread of cold case's 20 years or older and I read the whole thread in several weeks and the most fasinating to me are the one's from the 1800's and early 1900's. STANDREID chooses the case's and Belinda does the recaps. Belinda also has spread sheets to the case's (which I haven't checked out yet but want to as I'd like to reread the old ones). It's a fasntistic thread, you may be interested to read it.

I hope they continue to upgrade their programming also. Hopefully they will get the hint from the ratings. I remember when the History Channel and A & E (Arts and Entertainment) were the correct description for the networks. :banghead: Now it's all reality shows.
 
Kevin Costner and Bill Paxton are nominated for the same Emmy for leading man. Who would you give it to?

I'd say Costner.
 
Tom Berenger and Mare Winningham are nominated too, as supporting actor and actress.
 

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
190
Guests online
284
Total visitors
474

Forum statistics

Threads
609,298
Messages
18,252,260
Members
234,602
Latest member
baba65
Back
Top