Raging Ranter
Member
- Joined
- Mar 24, 2014
- Messages
- 66
- Reaction score
- 56
Just bought McNamarra's book on Friday and finished reading it yesterday. It's been years since I picked up a book and couldn't put it down. That book kept me squarely rooted to the couch all Saturday and Sunday until I was finished. It is an amazing piece of work. Though the fact that it is now so topical certainly had something to do with it.
I also read Larry Compton's Sudden Terror a few years ago. That book is a piece of crap. Even though he's an original investigator on the case, the book is just junk. It was self-published, and worse, semi-fictional. Yes, you read that right. The various EAR crimes are detailed in chronological order, but they are fictional composites of the actual crimes, not a true retelling. It was a juvenile and ineffectual way of telling the story. He only switches back to reality when he starts talking about the ONS series towards the end.
McNamarra's book was far superior. It's rare for an author to gain the trust of so many investigators that they actually shared files and theories with her extensively. I've read maybe 250 true crime books in my life, and I don't think I've come across that before. It almost seems she knew more about the case in totality than any individual investigator.
I also read Larry Compton's Sudden Terror a few years ago. That book is a piece of crap. Even though he's an original investigator on the case, the book is just junk. It was self-published, and worse, semi-fictional. Yes, you read that right. The various EAR crimes are detailed in chronological order, but they are fictional composites of the actual crimes, not a true retelling. It was a juvenile and ineffectual way of telling the story. He only switches back to reality when he starts talking about the ONS series towards the end.
McNamarra's book was far superior. It's rare for an author to gain the trust of so many investigators that they actually shared files and theories with her extensively. I've read maybe 250 true crime books in my life, and I don't think I've come across that before. It almost seems she knew more about the case in totality than any individual investigator.