PorcineGranny
crabby old lady!
- Joined
- Jul 25, 2009
- Messages
- 1,417
- Reaction score
- 3
Hi, PC. ADD or ADHD requires extensive testing to diagnose; in my professional opinion, it is often over-diagnosed, applied to children with chaotic home lives who have difficulties in school for many reasons: lack of discipline, abuse from caretakers, poor nutrition, inadequate sleep, undiagnosed medical problems, or depression. Some kids with terrible home lives may be so far behind by the upper elementary grades (4th-6th) that there really is no catching up.
But there is no way even a doctor can diagnose ADD or ADHD without testing (although some schools, to their shame, send notes home asking parents to get the family doctor to put a troublesome kid on Ritalin.) I am not aware of the new brain scans (you are giving me homework, there) but most ADD/ADH kids are sent to specialists in this area. A friend of mine has a son with ADD who went through two days of testing before he got a diagnosis. You may well be right that Misty has one of these conditions or some other condition, and you are very, very correct in saying that many learning disabilities are not correlated with the usual forms of "intelligence" kids use in school. From what little I know of Misty's background, though, my guess is that her difficulties in school had multiple causes--some environmental, some physiological, some emotional.
Pittsburg and Helplessly, you will have to admit that "testing" for ADD is comprised of a questionarie that has been submitted to teachers and parents and there is no physiological testing. Although you may also agree that
brain patterns and responses are now testable and it would make sense
that somewhere a test exists but maybe is not readily available because of expense, etc. As to the situation that ADD may be overly given as the diagnosis of children with behavior problems, I could agree somewhat although I do know it is a valid diagnosis and one that is greatly misunderstood. We shall always have those who insist their children do not have ADD and refuse treatment. I think more have it than not and it is a sign of the times we live in for specific reasons. But, I haven't got the constitution to go into detail any more in my life over it. I think it fits Misty but there could be other factors, I don't know her. No matter maybe we can agree that some problem exists and some type of therapy would benefit her in the long run. These are just my opinions except Pittsburgh, I do know that I read that testing in some form that provides physical evidence was told to me several years ago, I don't remember where I got the information.