Othram - General Discussion - #2

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Status
Not open for further replies.
Happy to share we were able to assist the Clallam County Sheriff's Office in identifying Jerilyn L. Smith, who was reported missing in 2018. This case was a DNASolves crowdfund and we are so grateful to everyone that helped fund it!

 
Missing Person / NamUs #MP87747
Circumstances of Disappearance Jerilyn and her husband went to bed on 1-6-18 in their Sequim, Washington home. He moved to the couch during the night and went to church the next morning without seeing Jerilyn. When he returned home Jerilyn was gone. Her husband found Jerilyn's car parked near the Elwha River Bridge west of Port Angeles. Search and Rescue dogs tracked Jerilyn's scent to the middle of the bridge directly over the river. Divers searched the river and the banks down to the beaches along the Straits of Juan De Fuca. Jerilyn was never found.
 
Happy to share we were able to assist the Clallam County Sheriff's Office in identifying Jerilyn L. Smith, who was reported missing in 2018. This case was a DNASolves crowdfund and we are so grateful to everyone that helped fund it!

Can't find a Doe or missing thread on this site for her.

Sleep well, Jerilyn.
 
The Sheriff’s Office partnered with Othram Labs, a private forensic lab based in Texas, to identify a DNA source from the foot.

The Sheriff’s Office usually relies on Washington State Patrol and the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System for forensic analysis, said detective Sgt. Brian Knutson. However, the unique nature of the evidence meant the remains did not meet the criteria for testing through either agency, and the Sheriff’s Office had to crowdfund $7,500.

Othram Labs provided a list of surviving family members to the identified DNA source, and detectives contacted one of them for a DNA sample that was sent to the lab for comparison. The lab confirmed the foot belonged to Smith.

It’s not the first time a missing foot has washed ashore in Washington, leaving. Often, they leave investigators few clues about who died and how.

Since 2007, nearly two dozen human feet in sneakers have washed up along the coasts of the Salish Sea in the U.S. and Canada.

Changes in sneaker design and several factors that play into whether a body floats or drowns explains why so many feet in sneakers wash ashore. *bbm

*Idk why this surprised me so much but it did. Two dozen? Who did they belong to besides Jerilyn and were they the right and left of the same person on any of them?

Due to the limited recovery of the woman's remains, CCSO worked with Othram, a private company that specializes in testing trace amounts, degraded or contaminated DNA.

"If you have, you know, a small piece of the skeleton, like a foot, for example, like, what what can you do with that?" asked David Mittelton, the CEO of Othram. "And then once we built it, the genealogy took a little time but we got through it. The investigators, we have to give them credit, too, because all we do is generate a lead but then we pass to the investigators," Mittelton said.

Jerilyn Smith's picture and information was posted to NAM-US the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System. Her car was found parked near the Elwha River Bridge west of Port Angeles. Divers searched the area but she was never found.

According to the Pennisula Daily News, Smith was the face of the chamber in Sequim. She was a grand marshal of the 2009 Sequim Irrigation Festival and was a chamber office administrator, retiring after 17 years. She later returned to volunteer her time.

Othram is grateful to help investigators find an answer in cases like this.

"Everything we do has to do about either seeking justice for a victim or trying to do our part in some small way to mend families that have been torn apart by either the loss of a loved one or or the infliction of a crime," Mittelton said.

A DNASolves crowdfund was also created to cover the cost of the testing and casework. DNASolves works exclusively with law enforcement to facilitate fundraising for Othram's services.
 
Last edited:
A new day & a new case solved:

As always, BIG UPS & mad respect to @othram! Congratulations on another solve!

That’s great that the family of the perp was cooperative and forthcoming with info about him, disturbing as it was. I found it interesting that his death occurred later in the same year that he murdered CLC. I’m a little curious about how that happened.

It seems Christina was an ambitious and wonderful young lady with so much to offer. May her soul rest peacefully. Hopefully her remaining loved ones have some measure of peace knowing that her killer can’t hurt anyone else.

From your linked article: We are hopeful that the surviving family members of Christina Castiglione, along with victims and families of other violent unsolved crimes who have been awaiting justice for decades, experience closure as advanced testing continues to help law enforcement advance efforts to achieve justice for victims.
Re: the BBM I hope so, too. I keep my fingers and toes crossed that DNA from Tara Baker’s attacker was collected and can be analyzed “Othram style” some day. I’m so bugged that she was pursuing a career in justice, yet 22 years after her egregious demise, there has been no justice for her and her family.

For today, though, I’m so happy to even have a glimmer of hope, and am encouraged by your success in identifying the monster who took Christina Castiglione’s life. Again, congratulations!
 
Last edited:
That’s great that the family of the perp was cooperative and forthcoming with info about him, disturbing as it was. I found it interesting that his death occurred later in the same year that he murdered CLC. I’m a little curious about how that happened.

Livingston County Cold Case Team solves nearly 40-year-old murder

"They have identified Charles David Shaw as the killer in this case, he was 26 years old at the time of the murder. Shaw was found dead in Detroit on Nov. 27, 1983. The medical examiner’s report lists his death as accidental sexual asphyxiation.

Police were unable to find any direct ties between Castiglione and Shaw. They did not receive any tips that would have led them to Shaw during the initial investigation."


This is precisely the kind of case that most needed @othram
Pre-DNA, suspect died shortly after...
He was 26 & had a criminal history, he may be responsible for other cases.
Thank you Othram!
 
Livingston County Cold Case Team solves nearly 40-year-old murder

"They have identified Charles David Shaw as the killer in this case, he was 26 years old at the time of the murder. Shaw was found dead in Detroit on Nov. 27, 1983. The medical examiner’s report lists his death as accidental sexual asphyxiation.

Police were unable to find any direct ties between Castiglione and Shaw. They did not receive any tips that would have led them to Shaw during the initial investigation."


This is precisely the kind of case that most needed @othram
Pre-DNA, suspect died shortly after...
He was 26 & had a criminal history, he may be responsible for other cases.
Thank you Othram!
Thanks for satisfying my curiosity and providing that link. Wow!

100% agree with the rest of your post, too.
 
Cannot recall offhand if this case was already mentioned as a future Othram solve, but started thread in anticipation of one..
''February 22, 2023
The $9,700 from Seasons of Justice will be paid directly to Othram labs to cover additional forensic work for the Blackburn cold case. The Cold Case Analysis Center had previously provided and secured additional funding from the American Investigative Society of Cold Cases to have a lab analyze selected items of well-preserved physical evidence. An M-Vac tool can penetrate small cracks and crevices on a piece of evidence to collect DNA for analysis.''

Ws thread..
 
Hi @othram

There's a case in Pennsylvania that feels like it won't be solved w/out genetic genealogy. There's DNA but otherwise not much to go on. Maybe you can take a look

Summary from Doe Network:

950UFPA

On Sunday afternoon, September 22, 1991, a woman walking through the woods near her Hamlin home, near Mount Jewett, found a skull cap which she turned over to the police.


The skull was examined by the anthropology department at the University of Pittsburgh at Bradford, who determined that the skull was human. A fracture found in the skull indicated that foul play had been involved. The skull was also examined by anthropologist Dr Dennis Dirkmaat at Mercyhurst College in Erie. Dr Dirkmaat determined that the skull had been exposed to the weather for longer than a year but less than 5 years.


On Friday, May 8, 1992 a search of the area where the skull was found was conducted by the Pennsylvania State Police and the Cattaraugus County (NY) Sheriff's Department, who brought a dog trained to search for human remains. No additional remains were found.


PA - PA - McKean Co, WhtFem 15-30, UP6584, skull on private prop, Sep'91

Unidentified Person / NamUs #UP6584
 
Hi @othram

There's a case in Pennsylvania that feels like it won't be solved w/out genetic genealogy. There's DNA but otherwise not much to go on. Maybe you can take a look

Summary from Doe Network:

950UFPA

On Sunday afternoon, September 22, 1991, a woman walking through the woods near her Hamlin home, near Mount Jewett, found a skull cap which she turned over to the police.


The skull was examined by the anthropology department at the University of Pittsburgh at Bradford, who determined that the skull was human. A fracture found in the skull indicated that foul play had been involved. The skull was also examined by anthropologist Dr Dennis Dirkmaat at Mercyhurst College in Erie. Dr Dirkmaat determined that the skull had been exposed to the weather for longer than a year but less than 5 years.


On Friday, May 8, 1992 a search of the area where the skull was found was conducted by the Pennsylvania State Police and the Cattaraugus County (NY) Sheriff's Department, who brought a dog trained to search for human remains. No additional remains were found.


PA - PA - McKean Co, WhtFem 15-30, UP6584, skull on private prop, Sep'91

Unidentified Person / NamUs #UP6584
We will take a look!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
79
Guests online
2,322
Total visitors
2,401

Forum statistics

Threads
601,733
Messages
18,129,013
Members
231,138
Latest member
mjF7nx
Back
Top