This is a great thread -- it's wonderful to see all the "evidence" (AHA to JB!) in one place.
Like another poster, I pegged her as guilty the moment I saw the perp walk in the blue hoodie. But, the final straw for me was the police report released pretty early in the case. "Sometime between 9 and 1, I dropped my daughter ...."
Between 9 and 1? What? What mother wouldn't know every last detail of that day? Look at Annmarie's detailed post about the one hour timeframe when her child hadn't made it home from school. I remember, in slow motion, every painful second of a 3-minute ordeal when my dd, age 2, got in a crowded elevator without me at a downtown department store. I remember, in slow motion, every single second when, at age 4, she crawled ahead and exited a treehouse in the "Honey I Shrunk the Kids" playground at Disneyworld and I left by a different exit. I don't remember what I had for breakfast yesterday ... or what color my bathroom is painted ... but I remember every minute of September 11, 2001 ... until I got back to NJ and picked dd up at school. Between 9 and 1????????? That alone would cause me to give her the needle .........