GUILTY PA - Jasmine, 4, & Nicole Snyder, 6, starved to death, Lycoming Co, 10 Sep 2021 *arrests*

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
She was supposed have an arraignment hearing on 10/17/22.


Oct. 12, 2022
WILLIAMSPORT – The mother accused in the intentional starvation deaths of her two young daughters has agreed to plead guilty to first-degree murder and continue to cooperate in the prosecution of co-defendants.

Marie Sue Snyder, 32, is scheduled to plead Oct. 31 to two counts of first-degree murder and be sentenced to consecutive life sentences, her attorney, chief public defender Nicole Spring, said Wednesday.

The plea also encompasses a second case in which she is charged with making false statements and theft by deception, Spring said.
[......]
Snyder is accused of illegally obtaining $48,703 in medical assistance and $21,163 in supplemental nutrition assistant program benefits after her daughters were dead.
[.....]
The guilty plea announcement came a day after Lycoming County District Attorney Ryan C. Gardner filed notices of aggravating circumstances required for him to pursue the death penalty against the women.

Those notices had to be filed before their court arraignments scheduled Monday. Gardner explained if he had not done so for Snyder and she decided not to plead he would have been unable to seek the death penalty if she was found guilty at a trial.
[.....]
Butler’s mother, Michele Butler, 47, is scheduled to plead guilty Dec. 5. She is charged with third-degree murder, endangering the welfare of children, obstruction in child abuse cases, abuse of corpse, concealing the death of child and tampering with evidence.
[.....]
The three women are jailed without bail. Ronald Butler was released Sept. 28 on nominal bail because he was not brought to trial within 180 days as is required for an incarcerated individual.



I had Michele Butler scheduled on 10/14/22 - looks like that date was moved.
 
@Niner, according to this article Michele Butler is scheduled to appear tomorrow.

OCT 13, 2022
[...]

Michelle Butler, Echo’s mother, is scheduled to plead guilty Friday before Judge Ryan Tira.
 
Friday, October 14th:
*Plea & Sentencing Hearing (@ 9am ET) – PA - *Jasmine Jean (4) & Nicole Elisabeth (6) Snyder (missing/last seen since Sept. 2015 & found Nov. 6 & 7, 2021 buried in Williamsport City, Lycoming County; Jasmine: died/was killed on around Aug. 11, 2017 & subsequently buried in 2017 & Nicole: died/was killed around May 10, 2016 & subsequently buried in 2016, both in the back yard on Livermore Rd.) – *Michele Lee Butler (43 @ time of first crime/48/now 49) (mother of Echo) arrested & charged (11/9/21) , recharged & arraigned (1/7/22) with 2 counts of 3rd degree murder, 2 counts of felony endangering the welfare of children, obstruction in child abuse cases, abuse of corpse, concealing the death of a child & tampering with evidence. Bond denied, reason: flight risk & danger to society. Plead guilty. Sentencing date 10/14/22.
Case info, affidavit & court info from 11/6/21 to 4/11/22 reference post #146 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...lycoming-co-10-sep-2021-arrests.600153/page-8

6/21/22 Update: Plead guilty (on 4/11/22). Sentencing hearing is rescheduled on 8/30/22. 8/30/22 Update: Sentencing hearing continued on 10/14/22.
10/12/22 Update: Butler is now scheduled to plead guilty on10/14/22. She is charged with 3rd degree murder, endangering the welfare of children, obstruction in child abuse cases, abuse of corpse, concealing the death of child & tampering with evidence.
*Marie Sue Snyder (27 @ time of first crime/32/now 33) “mom” – Fraud: Plead guilty on 8/19/22 sentencing on 10/31/22. Murder: Plead guilty on 10/12/22 & sentencing hearing on 10/31/22.
*Echo Lane Butler (21 @ time of first crime/26) – Arraignment hearing on 10/17/22.
*Ronald Ray Butler (53/now 54) (father of Echo) – Pretrial hearing on 12/13/22.
 
Looks like sentencing date was moved to December for M. Butler


Oct. 14, 2022
The mother of one of the women charged in the starvation death of two young children in Hepburn Township will plead guilty on Dec. 5.

Michele L. Butler, 49, is charged with murder of the third degree, endangering welfare of children, obstruction, abuse of corpse, conceal death of children, tampering with/fabricate physical evidence, and tamper with/fabricate physical evidence.

A scheduled plea was continued until the December date in Court Room 1.
 
Monday, October 17th:
*Arraignment Hearing (@ 8:30am ET) – PA - *Jasmine Jean (4) & Nicole Elisabeth (6) Snyder (missing/last seen since Sept. 2015 & found Nov. 6 & 7, 2021 buried in Williamsport City, Lycoming County; Jasmine: died/was killed on around Aug. 11, 2017 & subsequently buried in 2017 & Nicole: died/was killed around May 10, 2016 & subsequently buried in 2016, both in the back yard on Livermore Rd.) - *Echo Lane Butler (21 @ time of first crime/26) arrested & charged (11/5/21) & recharged & arraigned (1/7/22) with 2 counts of murder, 2 count s of endangering the welfare of children, unlawful restraint, concealing the death of a child, simple assault, recklessly endangering another person, abuse of corpse, obstruction in child abuse cases & tampering with evidence. Bond denied, reason: flight risk, danger to self & others. DA will seek the DP.
Case info, Affidavit & court info from 11/6/21 to 6/16/22 reference post #131 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...lycoming-co-10-sep-2021-arrests.600153/page-7

6/17/22 Update: Butler: Murder: Next arraignment hearing on 7/18/22. 7/18/22 Update: Murder: Arraignment hearing was rescheduled on 10/17/22.
*Michele Lee Butler (43 @ time of first crime/48/now 49) (mother of Echo) – Plead guilty (4/11/22) Sentencing hearing on 12/5/22.
*Ronald Ray Butler (53now 54) (father of Echo) – Pretrial hearing on 12/13/22.
*Marie Sue Snyder (27 @ time of first crime/32/now 33) “mom” – Fraud: Plead guilty on 8/19/22 sentencing on 10/31/22 & Murder: Plead guilty on 10/12/22 sentencing hearing on 10/31/22.
 
Looks like she waived arraignment, @Niner.

OCT 17, 2022
[...]

27-year-old Echo Butler was scheduled for an arraignment and Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition, or ARD, at Lycoming County Court Monday morning, but decided to waive.

[...]

Michele is scheduled for a guilty plea on December 5. Echo will have a pre-trial conference on December 13.

Marie Snyder will be back in Lycoming County court for a guilty plea on Monday, October 31.
 
Looks like she waived arraignment, @Niner.

OCT 17, 2022
[...]

27-year-old Echo Butler was scheduled for an arraignment and Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition, or ARD, at Lycoming County Court Monday morning, but decided to waive.

[...]

Michele is scheduled for a guilty plea on December 5. Echo will have a pre-trial conference on December 13.

Marie Snyder will be back in Lycoming County court for a guilty plea on Monday, October 31.

Thank you! :)
 
Monday, October 31st:
*Plea Hearing (all charges) (@ 8:30am ET) – PA - *Jasmine Jean (4) & Nicole Elisabeth (6) Snyder (missing/last seen since Sept. 2015 & found Nov. 6 & 7, 2021 buried in Williamsport City, Lycoming County; Jasmine: died/was killed on around Aug. 11, 2017 & subsequently buried in 2017 & Nicole: died/was killed around May 10, 2016 & subsequently buried in 2016, both in the back yard on Livermore Rd.) - *Marie Sue Snyder (27 @ time of first crime/32/now 33) “mom” arrested & charged (11/5/21) & recharged & arraigned (1/7/22) with 2 counts of murder, 2 counts endangering the welfare of children, unlawful restraint, concealing the death of a child, simple assault, recklessly endangering another person, abuse of corpse, obstruction in child abuse cases, tampering with evidence & charged (6/16/22) with 3rd degree felony theft by deception & fraud to obtain food stamps and/or assistance ($69,866.27). Bond denied on murder, reason: flight risk & danger to society. Bond @ $10K on theft/fraud charges. Plead guilty to these charges of fraud. For murder charge: DA might seek the DP, but if she cooperates, will take DP off the table.
Case info, Affidavit & court info from 11/6/21 to 6/20/22 reference post #142 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...lycoming-co-10-sep-2021-arrests.600153/page-8

6/27/22 Update: Fraud & Deception: Next hearing on 8/19/22.
7/18/22 Update: Snyder: Murder: Arraignment hearing was rescheduled on 10/17/22 has her attorney wanted more time to review the discovery provided so far.
8/19/22 Update: Fraud & Deception: Plead guilty. Sentencing on 11/29/22 @ 9am. Sentencing changed to 10/31/22.
10/12/22 Update: Marie Sue Snyder is scheduled to plead guilty on 10/31/22 to 2 counts of 1st degree murder & be sentenced to consecutive life sentences, her attorney, chief public defender Nicole Spring, said Wednesday. The plea also encompasses a second case in which she is charged with making false statements & theft by deception, Spring said. Sentencing on 10/31/22.
*Echo Lane Butler (21 @ time of first crime/26/now 27) – Pretrial hearing on 12/13/22.
*Michele Lee Butler (43 @ time of first crime/48/now 49) (mother of Echo) – Plead guilty (4/11/22) & sentencing hearing on 12/5/22.
*Ronald Ray Butler (53/now 54) (father of Echo) – Pretrial hearing on 12/13/22.
 
Any word on this plea hearing? Did she also get sentenced?

TIA! :)
 
OCT 31, 2022
[...]

Snyder, 32, of Lycoming County, appeared in court Monday to plead guilty to two counts of first-degree murder.

[...]

Snyder admitted that she and her partner, Echo Butler, starved the two girls to death and buried them behind their trailer home.

Snyder went on to say that Butler was the one calling the shots, and the two had a premeditated understanding to starve the children.

Snyder also admitted that the children were subjected to constant physical and verbal abuse when they were alive.

The commonwealth recently filed a request to seek the death penalty against Snyder, but the plea deal will allow her to serve two life sentences instead.

[...]

Snyder's sentencing has been delayed until after her coconspirator's trial.

[...]

Butler has decided to take her case to trial. Snyder will have to testify against her partner as part of her plea agreement. That trial has not been scheduled.
 
OCT 31, 2022
The mother accused of abusing and starving her two daughters to death pleaded guilty in Lycoming County Court to four of the 23 charges against her.

Marie Snyder broke down on the stand during her court appearance Monday afternoon, saying she loves and misses "her babies."

Snyder admitted conspiring with her then-girlfriend to kill the girls and is set to testify against her, prosecutors say.

[...]

In all, Snyder pled guilty to:
  • Conspiracy - Criminal Homicide
  • Conspiracy - Criminal Homicide
  • Theft By Deception-Fail To Correct
  • Fraud Obt Foodstamps/Assistance
Snyder won't be prosecuted for these remaining charges, according to the district attorney's office:
  • Criminal Homicide (2 counts)
  • Endangering Welfare of Children - Parent/Guardian/Other Commits Offense (2 counts)
  • Unlawful Restraint/ Serious Bodily Injury (2 counts)
  • Theft By Deception-Fail To Correct
  • Conceal Death of Child (2 counts)
  • Recklessly Endangering Another Person (2 counts)
  • Abuse Of Corpse (2 counts)
  • Obstruction
  • Tamper With/Fabricate Physical Evidence (2 counts)
  • Theft By Decep-False Impression
[...]

Marie Snyder docket sheet

Marie Snyder docket sheet

Echo Butler docket sheet

Michele Butler docket sheet

Ronald Butler docket sheet
 
 
Monday, December 5th:
*Sentencing Hearing (@ 9am ET) – PA - *Jasmine Jean (4) & Nicole Elisabeth (6) Snyder (missing/last seen since Sept. 2015 & found Nov. 6 & 7, 2021 buried in Williamsport City, Lycoming County; Jasmine: died/was killed on around Aug. 11, 2017 & subsequently buried in 2017 & Nicole: died/was killed around May 10, 2016 & subsequently buried in 2016, both in the back yard on Livermore Rd.) – *Michele Lee Butler (43 @ time of first crime/48/now 49) (mother of Echo) arrested & charged (11/9/21) , recharged & arraigned (1/7/22) with 2 counts of 3rd degree murder, 2 counts of felony endangering the welfare of children, obstruction in child abuse cases, abuse of corpse, concealing the death of a child & tampering with evidence. Bond denied, reason: flight risk & danger to society. Plead guilty. Sentencing date 12/5/22.
Case info, affidavit & court info from 11/6/21 to 8/30/22 reference post #164 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...lycoming-co-10-sep-2021-arrests.600153/page-9

10/12/22 Update: Butler is now scheduled to plead guilty on 10/14/22. She is charged with 3rd degree murder, endangering the welfare of children, obstruction in child abuse cases, abuse of corpse, concealing the death of child & tampering with evidence.
10/14/22 Update: Butler’s sentencing date has been rescheduled on 12/5/22.
*Marie Sue Snyder (27 @ time of first crime/32/now 33) “mom” – Fraud: Plead guilty on 10/31/22. Murder: Plead guilty on 10/31/22 & will be sentenced after she testifies at Echo Butler’s trial.
*Echo Lane Butler (21 @ time of first crime/26/now 27) – Pretrial hearing on 12/13/22.
*Ronald Ray Butler (53/now 54) (father of Echo) – Pretrial hearing on 12/13/22.
 
Michele Butler's Guilty Plea was continued, @Niner.

Michele Butler docket sheet

Guilty Plea 12/05/2022 1:30 pm Courtroom No. 1 President Judge Nancy L Butts Continued

Motion for Bail Modification 12/20/2022 3:30 pm Courtroom No. 1 President Judge Nancy L Butts Scheduled

Guilty Plea 01/06/2023 1:30 pm Courtroom No. 1 President Judge Nancy L Butts Scheduled
 
Tuesday, December 13th:
*Pretrial Hearing (@ 9am ET) – PA - *Jasmine Jean (4) & Nicole Elisabeth (6) Snyder (missing/last seen since Sept. 2015 & found Nov. 6 & 7, 2021 buried in Williamsport City, Lycoming County; Jasmine: died/was killed on around Aug. 11, 2017 & subsequently buried in 2017 & Nicole: died/was killed around May 10, 2016 & subsequently buried in 2016, both in the back yard on Livermore Rd.) – for *Ronald Ray Butler (53/now 54) (father of Echo) arrested, charged (2/28/22) & arraigned (waived) (4/11/22) with 2 counts of endangering welfare of children-parent/guardian/other commits offense (3rd degree) & 1 count of obstruction in child abuse cases. Plead not guilty. $200K bond. Bond reduced (4/20/22) to $50K. Should he post bond he is to be placed on intensive supervised bail with an ankle monitor & have no unsupervised contact with children. He also may not contact the witnesses or co-defendants in the case including his wife Michele & daughter Echo. Posted nominal bail (9/28/22) & is out of jail.
Case, affidavit & court info from 11/6/21 to 9/13/22 reference post #158 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...lycoming-co-10-sep-2021-arrests.600153/page-8

9/27/22 Update: Butler claims he tried to sneak crackers to the 2 girls. That became known Tuesday at a hearing for Butler, who is seeking dismissal of his charges & release on nominal bail. DA Ryan C. Gardner acknowledged an incarcerated defendant not brought to trial within 180 days as is the case with Butler is eligible for release on nominal bail. Judge Nancy L. Butts indicated if she granted the bail motion that Butler would be precluded from contacting witnesses & co-defendants & have unsupervised contact with children. The judge heard testimony but deferred ruling on defense attorney Matthew A. Diemer’s motion to dismiss the charges on the grounds the prosecution failed to present sufficient evidence at the preliminary hearing. Next motion for release pursuant to Rule 600 on 10/4/22 @ 9am & pretrial hearing on 12/13/22.
10/4/22 Update: Butler was released Wednesday, 9/28/22 on intensive supervised bail because he has not been brought to trial as an incarcerated individual within the required 180 days. Butler must wear an ankle monitor & report daily in person to the re-entry center. He may not have any contact with the co-defendants, all of whom are in prison without bail & witnesses. Unsupervised contact with children also is prohibited. Still pending in Butler’s case is a decision from Judge Nancy L. Butts on a defense motion to dismiss the charges due to insufficient evidence. Next pretrial hearing on 12/13/22.

ALSO:

*Pretrial Hearing (@ am ET) – PA - *Jasmine Jean (4) & Nicole Elisabeth (6) Snyder (missing/last seen since Sept. 2015 & found Nov. 6 & 7, 2021 buried in Williamsport City, Lycoming County; Jasmine: died/was killed on around Aug. 11, 2017 & subsequently buried in 2017 & Nicole: died/was killed around May 10, 2016 & subsequently buried in 2016, both in the back yard on Livermore Rd.) - for *Echo Lane Butler (21 @ time of first crime/26/now 27) arrested & charged (11/5/21) & recharged & arraigned (1/7/22) with 2 counts of murder, 2 count s of endangering the welfare of children, unlawful restraint, concealing the death of a child, simple assault, recklessly endangering another person, abuse of corpse, obstruction in child abuse cases & tampering with evidence. Bond denied, reason: flight risk, danger to self & others. DA will seek the DP.
Case info, Affidavit & court info from 11/6/21 to 6/16/22 reference post #131 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...lycoming-co-10-sep-2021-arrests.600153/page-7

6/17/22 Update: Butler: Murder: Next arraignment hearing on 7/18/22. 7/18/22 Update: Murder: Arraignment hearing was rescheduled on 10/17/22. 10/17/22 Update: Waived arraignment hearing. Next pretrial hearing on 12/13/22.
*Michele Lee Butler (43 @ time of first crime/48/now 49) (mother of Echo) – Plead guilty (4/11/22) Sentencing hearing on 1/6/23. Bail modification hearing on 12/20/22.
*Marie Sue Snyder (27 @ time of first crime/32/now 33) “mom” – Fraud: Plead guilty on 10/31/22. Murder: Plead guilty on 10/31/22 & will be sentenced after she testifies at Echo Butler’s trial.

 
@PommyMommy - any updates on next hearings for Ronald or Echo?

TIA!
Moose And Christmas Balls Smiley
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
115
Guests online
2,731
Total visitors
2,846

Forum statistics

Threads
599,920
Messages
18,101,560
Members
230,955
Latest member
ClueCrusader
Back
Top