PA PA - Rochester Mills, N Mahoning Twp, BlkHispFem 30-40, UP5063, post-mortem saw marks, shorts Dec'08

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/news/regional/s_621402.html

Newly discovered portions of a human skeleton in Indiana County might help investigators identify the victim, authorities said Sunday.

The first remains were found in December, and Indiana County Coroner Michael Baker said a weekend search uncovered 90 percent of the remaining bones.

Saturday's search involved about 25 people including Baker, state police and a specialized forensic anthropology team from Mercyhurst College. They found the bones while crawling on their hands and knees.

The body, which was dismembered after death, apparently was left in the wooded area between three and 10 years ago, Baker said.

He would not release details of how the remains were found or arranged, but he confirmed they were from the same victim as the December discovery. He previously said the victim appeared to be a black woman between 30 and 40 years old who died as a result of a gunshot wound to the head.

"There is no question that this individual's death was the result of homicide," Baker said. "Hopefully, the information we will gain from examining the new evidence will bring us closer to making a positive identification of the victim."

Baker is working with the PA Dental Identification Team and the federal Department of Justice's National Missing and Unidentified Persons System in an effort to identify the victim. DNA testing will be done as soon as the new remains are processed and documented, Baker said.

Now that the rest of the skeleton has been recovered, Baker said, investigators might be able to determine whether the woman had additional gunshot wounds.

"We have a lot of very capable people working on it, and every forensic advantage available will be brought to bear in the case."
 
https://identifyus.org/cases/5063
Estimated age Adult - Pre 40
Minimum age 30 years
Maximum age 40 years
Race Black/African American
Ethnicity Hispanic/Latino
Height (inches) 61, Estimated
Address 1 Leisure Road
Address 2
City Rochester Mills
Partially buried skull and misc. other skeletal remains found at a residential construction site in North Mahoning Twp, northern Indiana County. Partially wooded area.

The following people have been ruled out as being this decedent:
First Name Last Name Year Of Birth State LKA
Aesha Muhammed 1977 Pennsylvania
Diane Scott 1961 Pennsylvania

3852
3908


Long bones show clear evidence of post-mortem saw marks
Elastic-banded shorts - similar to running shorts. Size not yet identified. Possible gray in color.
Zip code
County Indiana
 
the black/Hispanic combo is intriguing. I usually associate that with people from the Dominican Republic, although there are Afro-Cubans as well.

many Hispanics consider themselves white regardless of how dark they are.

this one missing person caught my eye, Elba Irrizary, missing from Camden, NJ in June 1994. there is a decent face shot of her but I'm not sure how accurate the compsite sketch is with the mixed ancestry. Elba was 5'3", 110 lbs.

https://www.findthemissing.org/cases/9839/6/

per th NJ State Police, Elba was depressed and had drug addiction issues, but I was having trouble with posting a link from the State Police's missing persons page.
 
Venus Marie Robinson

Age and height are within range. Race matches. She looks similar to sketch (particularly the hair and lips, but her head is at a different angle so I don't know how well the face shape matches up). She also has partial upper dentures like the UID did.

The timing is off by about 2 1/2 years and she went missing from California. Although, there is very little information about her (I couldn't find her anywhere but CharleyProject) so I don't know the circumstances of her disappearance. Maybe she was alive for several years after her disappearance and was in Pennsylvania - maybe with a boyfriend or something - when she was killed?

She isn't in NamUs so no automatic rule-out could be made.
 
Ten people have been ruled out as being this decedent

Lori Boffman 1961 Ohio
Regina Brown 1951 Connecticut
Felicia Coleman 1978 North Carolina
Mia Kelly 1969 New Jersey
Risha Lewis 1979 Delaware
Aesha Muhammed 1977 Pennsylvania
Edwina Onyango 1973 Pennsylvania
Diane Scott 1961 Pennsylvania
Antoinette Williams 1965 New Jersey
Constance Wooten Unknown Pennsylvania
 
One more ruleout:

Lori Boffman 1961 Ohio
Regina Brown 1951 Connecticut
Devin Brown-Bousetta 1980 Pennsylvania
Felicia Coleman 1978 North Carolina
Mia Kelly 1969 New Jersey
Risha Lewis 1979 Delaware
Aesha Muhammed 1977 Pennsylvania
Edwina Onyango 1973 Pennsylvania
Diane Scott 1961 Pennsylvania
Antoinette Williams 1965 New Jersey
Constance Wooten Unknown Pennsylvania
 
The National Missing and Unidentified Persons System (NamUs)

Unidentified Person / NamUs #UP5063Female, Multiple


Date body found: December 29, 2008
Location found: Rochester Mills, Pennsylvania

Case Information


Case Numbers
NCMEC Number: --
ME/C Case Number08-DOEJ
Demographics
Sex: Female
Race / Ethnicity: Black / African American, Hispanic / Latino
Possible First Name: --
Possible Middle Name: --
Possible Last Name: --
Nickname/Alias: --
Estimated Age Group: Adult - Pre 40
Estimated Age Range (Years): 30-40
Estimated Year of Death: 1993-2003
Estimated PMI: --
Height: 5' 1"(61 inches) , Estimated
Weight: Cannot Estimate

Circumstances
Type: Unidentified Deceased
Date Body Found: December 29, 2008
NamUs Case Created: April 14, 2009
ME/C QA Reviewed: April 17, 2009

Location Found Map
Location: Rochester Mills, Pennsylvania
County: Indiana County
GPS Coordinates (Not Mapped): --
Found On Tribal Land: --

Circumstances of Recovery:
Partially buried skull and misc. other skeletal remains found at a residential construction site in North Mahoning Twp, northern Indiana County. Partially wooded area.
Details of Recovery


Inventory of Remains:
One or more limbs not recovered
One or both hands not recovered

Condition of Remains:
Not recognizable - Partial skeletal parts only
Physical Description
Hair Color--
Head Hair Description--
Body Hair Description--
Facial Hair Description--
Left Eye Color--
Right Eye Color--
Eye Description--
Distinctive Physical Features
Item
Description
Amputation
She apparently had been shot in the back of her head and had been dismembered. Long bones show clear evidence of post-mortem saw marks


Clothing and Accessories
Item-->Description-->Clothing:
Elastic-banded shorts - similar to running shorts. Size not yet identified. Possible gray in color.
(On the Body)

Investigating Agency(s)
Agency Name: Indiana County Coroner's Office
Agency Phone Number: 724-349-4511
Agency Case Number: 08-DOEJ

NCIC Case Number: Unknown
NamUs Case Number: UP5063
 
Last edited:
On December 29, 2008 a worker for the Holt Drilling Company was preparing to drill a well on private property in a secluded area off of Leisure Run Road in North Mahoning township when he stumbled upon a human skull about 10 feet from the drill site.

Investigators recovered the skull, jaw bone, several long bones, and some vertebrae along with a partial upper denture in December 2008. In April 2009, most of the rest of the skeleton was found 20 yards away from the initial discovery. The torso was in a black plastic bag just under the surface of the ground, but it did not appear that she had been buried.

The remains were determined to be a female adult, probably black. A single bullet wound was found in the back of the woman's skull. There is evidence of post-mortem saw marks on the long bones. She may have been dumped at the site between three and 10 years ago.
 
The National Missing and Unidentified Persons System (NamUs) For those good at comparing debtals, there are multiple photos of the jaw, teeth and partial upper in the Namus file.

is anyone able to post updates to the exclusions list last posted here in the previous post dated 2016?

One more ruleout:

Lori Boffman 1961 Ohio
Regina Brown 1951 Connecticut
Devin Brown-Bousetta 1980 Pennsylvania
Felicia Coleman 1978 North Carolina
Mia Kelly 1969 New Jersey
Risha Lewis 1979 Delaware
Aesha Muhammed 1977 Pennsylvania
Edwina Onyango 1973 Pennsylvania
Diane Scott 1961 Pennsylvania
Antoinette Williams 1965 New Jersey
Constance Wooten Unknown Pennsylvania

12 Exclusions:
MP7044 -- -- -- -- --
MP32862 Dawn Sneed 12/24/1995 Montgomery OH

*Note - Aesha Muhammed is listed in rats' post above. She is no longer on the list. Also MP7044's profile has been removed.
 
On December 29, 2008 a worker for the Holt Drilling Company was preparing to drill a well on private property in a secluded area off of Leisure Run Road in North Mahoning township when he stumbled upon a human skull about 10 feet from the drill site.

Investigators recovered the skull, jaw bone, several long bones, and some vertebrae along with a partial upper denture in December 2008. In April 2009, most of the rest of the skeleton was found 20 yards away from the initial discovery. The torso was in a black plastic bag just under the surface of the ground, but it did not appear that she had been buried.

The remains were determined to be a female adult, probably black. A single bullet wound was found in the back of the woman's skull. There is evidence of post-mortem saw marks on the long bones. She may have been dumped at the site between three and 10 years ago.
On December 29, 2008 a worker for the Holt Drilling Company was preparing to drill a well on private property in a secluded area off of Leisure Run Road in North Mahoning township when he stumbled upon a human skull about 10 feet from the drill site.

Investigators recovered the skull, jaw bone, several long bones, and some vertebrae along with a partial upper denture in December 2008. In April 2009, most of the rest of the skeleton was found 20 yards away from the initial discovery. The torso was in a black plastic bag just under the surface of the ground, but it did not appear that she had been buried.

The remains were determined to be a female adult, probably black. A single bullet wound was found in the back of the woman's skull. There is evidence of post-mortem saw marks on the long bones. She may have been dumped at the site between three and 10 years ago.

where did you find all of this information?
 
where did you find all of this information?

Looks like it was taken verbatim from my old PA Missing site (2004-2019).
Link from Wayback Internet Archive 2/15/2012 (sources at the bottom):
Pennsylvania Missing Persons

The info about Holt Drilling Co came from KDKA (Pittsburgh) and is no longer available on their site but was posted by (the late) Lauren Halleck on Porchlight for the Missing (scroll down):
Porchlight International for the Missing & Unidentified-PAF081229
 
wanted to post an update,
in late 2021-early 2022 i found a potential match with a number of similarities & contacted a caseworker from the doe network, filled out the online form for the panel to review, submitted it, but never heard anything back.
sometime in early 2021 i thought i remembered getting some kind of email saying it wasn't a match but when i went back recently to look for it i couldn't find anything about it at all. i know i didn't delete it as it's very important to me so idk :/.
 
There are still 12 Missing Person exclusions. NamUs shows 13 but the second to last one listed says “undefined”. Not sure if the entry MP7044 is valid as nothing comes up when searching.

1664398020529.jpeg
1664398085541.jpeg
 
wanted to post an update,
in late 2021-early 2022 i found a potential match with a number of similarities & contacted a caseworker from the doe network, filled out the online form for the panel to review, submitted it, but never heard anything back.
sometime in early 2021 i thought i remembered getting some kind of email saying it wasn't a match but when i went back recently to look for it i couldn't find anything about it at all. i know i didn't delete it as it's very important to me so idk :/.
It looks like she’s on the list of exclusions Caring just posted.
 
checking in. the 14th anniversary of her remains being found passed this week on the 29th.
i live in indiana county and as far as i know there's no memorial headstone or anything for her in any of the cemeteries in town. :(
 
checking in. the 14th anniversary of her remains being found passed this week on the 29th.
i live in indiana county and as far as i know there's no memorial headstone or anything for her in any of the cemeteries in town. :(
Did you hear of this case when it first happened? The information on where she was found is confusing. I always read she was found in Rochester Mills, North Mahoning Township, but I read Rochester Mills is in nearby Grant township. Do you know about that?
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
98
Guests online
219
Total visitors
317

Forum statistics

Threads
609,576
Messages
18,255,747
Members
234,695
Latest member
jko80
Back
Top