Allusonz
New Member
- Joined
- Nov 3, 2010
- Messages
- 4,679
- Reaction score
- 17
DNA is not a big factor in this case.
The biggest 'gotchas' are:
1. the weird happenings at the hotel that night with the exit door, the camera being first unplugged and then later pushed up to point at the ceiling, which had never happened before,
2. combined with the video of JY walking out at midnight wearing a completely different pullover sweater (a sweater that was never found...not even when police seized his luggage immediately upon his arrival back in Raleigh).
3. The witness ID of JY and his SUV at the gas station at 5:25am where his behavior was so bizarre/angry that the clerk remembered him--he made a strong impression and she got a face to face look at him, corroborated with a cash receipt that shows the purchase of gas at 5:27am
4. No sign of breakin, no robbery of items in the house, MY's purse in plain sight not touched. Only her wedding ring was taken off her finger.
5. A toddler who is not only left alive, but cleaned up and put back to bed, given adult meds to make her sleepy (toddler's DNA is on the dropper that was left on the shelf in her room).
6. The personal type of attack (first strangulation then a beating of over 30 hits) which can only be classified as overkill.
7. Victim was fully clothed in sweat clothes.
8. Shoe prints in the size and type of shoe the husband wore, with an exact sole print ID'd by the FBI. These shoes conveniently went missing. JY claims his wife donated them to charity, but the shoes were only 15 months old. A couple days after the murder JY purchases another pair of shoes, similar, but not exact to the ones he discarded.
9. A water hose outside was left running. Blood of victim found on doorknob leading out to that side door in garage.
10. JY admitted he propped open the emergency exit door at the hotel, but claims he used a twig, not a rock. A landscaping rock was found keeping the door open the next morning. According to the HI personnel this was extremely unusual.
11. JY's hand print found on wall next to his closet, 18 - 20" up from the floor, with his wife's blood splattered around that print, but none of the blood getting on the print (he had his hand on the wall, balancing himself while he beat her to death, as she was on the floor at this point).
12. JY never inquired as to how his wife died, the welfare of his toddler daughter, he refused to speak or listen (the police just asked him to listen at one point and he wouldn't come out of the back bedroom at his sister in law's house). He wouldn't help in any way, never inquired about the progress of the investigation, blocked his daughter from seeing her maternal relatives unless they were closely supervised. Then, access was taken away altogether unless the family would agree to "come out publicly in support of Jason."
13. He defaulted on a civil wrongful death lawsuit, in which he was declared the "slayer" of his wife and a judgement of $15.5 million against him was entered.
14. The Fisher family asked for visitation and a formal schedule. He instead transferred full custody to Meredith. He would not sit for a deposition, answer any questions, or allow himself to be evaluated by a psychologist, so he handed his daughter off.
Those are just 14 items on the list, but that is not a complete list.
I have to disagree. There is alot of DNA.
The problem arises when the DNA is not of over 100 people it was tested against that had been in the home thus there is DNA of unknown individuals.
As well we are talking the DNA on the landscaping rock was LCN DNA as testified in the first trial. What was not disclosed was how many other profiles were found on that one particular landscaping pebble, DNA cannot be "timestamped" thus it could of been deposited at any time. I could sneeze as i walked by you and if something was to of happened to you (which I will pray never does) my DNA would be on your clothes.
There appeared to be a consistent theme throughout the testimony of the first trial.
There is DNA but DNA that does not match JY or MY lets say on the jewellery box.
When dealing with LCN DNA it must be amplified many times over to produce profiles. They were unable to produce a matching profile to JY on the rock. Yes some of his markers namely 2 alleles matched but it probably matched the judge as well