Theories On What Happened to Caylee Part #1
Theories On What Happened to Caylee Part #2
Theories On What Happened to Caylee Part #3
Theories On What Happened to Caylee Part #4
Theories On What Happened to Caylee Part #5
Theories On What Happened to Caylee Part #6 (New Smoking Gun Theories for DP)
So...theories is well-trodden ground. But since we have some fresh minds @ WS, let's move forward, shall we?
To kick off #7, for my part, IMHO...
1) Caylee's remains being found in the "Big Trouble..." t-shirt is signficant. As established by pics from Ricardo's on 2 occasions in early '08, and, IIRC, further indicated by G and/or C claiming they weren't familiar w/ this shirt...is a strong indication that Caylee died away from G&C's Hopespring Drive home on the evening of Monday, 6/16. And further, that Caylee was in the process of...or had been...prepared for going to sleep for the night.
2) JT's WalMart sighting isn't as rock-solid as I would like it to be. But, for the time being, I will rely on it to further support that Caylee died away from Hopespring Drive on the evening of Monday, 6/16.
3) Per the Blockbuster surveillance video Casey was with Tony for an extended period of time - at least long enough to goto the store and return to his apartment a few minutes away - by 7:54PM 6/16. This is the earliest period for which we can establish that Caylee was not in Casey's care.
4) IIRC, per Tony's statement, the evening of movie watching 6/16 was not a well-planned activity. IOW...IMHO there was no indication that Casey was hell-bent on spending the evening/night with Tony alone, hence, no indication that Casey was pre-disposed to off'ing Caylee to do so. We still don't know the content of all the texting between Casey & Tony well into the wee hours of the morning 6/16...so...suffice it say there certainly could've been enough sexual tension building that there was motive for some time alone.
5) After arriving in the area of Tony's apartment per pings, Casey repeatedly tried to reach Cindy - whose cell phone was off - through the afternoon of 6/16 until the two spoke for just under 2 minutes @ 7:06PM after Cindy had gotten home from work. IIRC, Cindy indicated the context of this conversation was Casey telling her that she & Caylee would be out for the night. I don't place a great deal of emphasis on what Cindy may indicate the context of the call was about. I do place significance on the fact that - UP TO THIS POINT - Casey was actively attempting to reach Cindy. AFTER THIS POINT - Casey appears to avoid contact with Cindy. IMHO, this is a
strong indication that something happened around this time to cause the change in Casey's communication pattern w/ Cindy.
6) At 7:20PM Casey attempted to call Amy unsuccessfully, then, re-attempted @ 7:21PM and connected (i.e. spoke to...or more likely, IMHO, left a vmail).
I speculate the context of this message was a repeat of so many times before,
"What time do you get off work? Call me." IMHO, this is supported by two texts
from Amy later that evening @ 10:45PM & 11:17PM.
"I think I have cramps for the first time in 3 years. This sucks! I forgot how much it hurts."
...when Casey didn't respond...and @ about the time Amy should've been getting off work from TGIF's Amy sent...
So I'm not feeling good so I'm just going to crash at the boys. Ill call in the morning.
Since Amy's first text is otherwise unprovoked, and unfortunately we don't have Amy's cell records to prove it, I speculate that Amy sent the message after getting a vmail left by Casey @ 7:21PM.
The second text indicated that Amy wasn't @ Ricardo's and further supports that she was likely @ work @ TGIF's @ the time Casey called earlier in the evening.
So...given all of the above....and given that Caylee's remains were discovered with duct tape affixed across at least the mouth (if not the mouth & nose)
I speculate that Caylee died in the throes of being silenced by Casey - for what was probably intended to be a temporary childcare solution - AFTER 7:21PM when Caylee had been changed into her "Big Trouble..." tshirt for what Casey thought would eventually be a night @ Ricardo's (sim. to 6/9). Perhaps the <2 minute conversation w/ Cindy @ 7:06PM wasn't civil and served to rekindle the fury of the alleged 6/15PM fight 'tween Casey & Cindy. :waitasec:
Plenty of details/aspects/options intentionally left out here for brevity. And plenty of room to
oke: poke holes and offer alternatives.