US Virgin Is - Sarm Joan Lillian Heslop, 41, British, aboard vessel Siren Song, St. John, 7 Mar 2021

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Status
Not open for further replies.
The reports of previous DV are really alarming if true. There is also someone on the FB page (Christiane Daily, Day 10 comments) who has commented darkly that she's not surprised something like this happened from what she knows of him back in MI.

Missing Person: Sarm Heslop

The other person in all this whose behaviour I find intriguing is Flora Pickard ("Flora the sailing chef"), whose opinion seems to be all over the MSM and SM. She's usually described as 'a friend of the couple' but seems more to have been RB's friend than Sarm's and has been relentlessly in his corner - he's 'distraught', 'in pieces', 'confused'. I've even seen her getting into catfights in the comments section of some of the MSM reportage about his character, telling people who express suspicions to *advertiser censored** off etc. I'm curious to know more about her relationship with him. IMO she's protective about him more in the way you would expect of a girlfriend or admirer. Have they been involved in the past? It's interesting to me that she's also a chef - I heard in the original report on Sky that being a chef on RB's boat was a career change for Sarm. Who was in that role before Sarm left her job in Malta and returned to USVI? Was it Flora? And if so, was she really as thrilled that Sarm came back as she says?

She also seems somehow (already?!) to have an IMDB listing consisting of her celebrity appearances on broadcast media as 'Sarm's friend'. Is this normal?? I mean, I'm thinking not tbh.

Flora Pickard - IMDb

All JMO and speculation of course.
 
The reports of previous DV are really alarming if true. There is also someone on the FB page (Christiane Daily, Day 10 comments) who has commented darkly that she's not surprised something like this happened from what she knows of him back in MI.

Missing Person: Sarm Heslop

The other person in all this whose behaviour I find intriguing is Flora Pickard ("Flora the sailing chef"), whose opinion seems to be all over the MSM and SM. She's usually described as 'a friend of the couple' but seems more to have been RB's friend than Sarm's and has been relentlessly in his corner - he's 'distraught', 'in pieces', 'confused'. I've even seen her getting into catfights in the comments section of some of the MSM reportage about his character, telling people who express suspicions to *advertiser censored** off etc. I'm curious to know more about her relationship with him. IMO she's protective about him more in the way you would expect of a girlfriend or admirer. Have they been involved in the past? It's interesting to me that she's also a chef - I heard in the original report on Sky that being a chef on RB's boat was a career change for Sarm. Who was in that role before Sarm left her job in Malta and returned to USVI? Was it Flora? And if so, was she really as thrilled that Sarm came back as she says?

She also seems somehow (already?!) to have an IMDB listing consisting of her celebrity appearances on broadcast media as 'Sarm's friend'. Is this normal?? I mean, I'm thinking not tbh.

Flora Pickard - IMDb

All JMO and speculation of course.

The IMDb things is just... wow. I guess she’s chefing her way to that 15 mins.

I’m a sailor and am always suspicious of cases like this, partly because of how much best practice/ safe practice is a part of the culture and the small worlds and committed environments within those worlds. It’s a bit like climbing or backcountry skiing — accidents definitely happen, but when they happen under awkward or mysterious circumstances antennae go up fast and stay up.

We have this quote, which seems to backed up by many who knew her:

Baldwin, who works for a cruise company, said Heslop was an experienced sailor. “Sarm knows boats,” he said. “She sailed across the Atlantic. I don’t understand how someone could fall from that boat in that situation.”
Family plead for police to search yacht after British woman disappears in Virgin Islands


I don’t understand why the investigators seem to be so timid in terms of pursuing relevant searches, etc. Do any federal agencies have jurisdiction there? It seems that in a recent drug enforcement case US agencies were involved:

Sharpe also commended the agencies that comprise the St. Thomas MOI for their efforts in securing the award and for the overall success of the HIDTA program. These agencies include the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA), Virgin Islands Police Department (VIPD), United States Marshals Service (USMS), Internal Revenue Service-Criminal Investigation Division (IRS-CID), U.S. Department of Homeland Security, Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP), and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF).

Puerto Rico/U.S. Virgin Islands High Intensity Drug Trafficking Area Program Receives National Recognition
 
Okay, the IMBD page. Who does that? I wonder how well she knew either of them past acquaintances and is just trying to parlay this into a moment of celebrity. Or she's a little too quick to jump to RB's defense. Or both.

I am also confused about why there aren't more agencies involved. I don't get the feeling that there is lots going on in the background we aren't hearing about. I don't feel a big sense of urgency from the USVI LE at all.
 
TIMELINE for Sarm Heslop

Late 2019 - “Wilson told CrimeOnline that Heslop, who has traveled extensively and lived in multiple countries, first arrived in St. John in late 2019. Prior to that, she had been working on the south coast of Spain and had taken up sailing with a friend. Eventually, she, the friend, and the friend’s partner sailed across the Atlantic to St. John” SOURCE CrimeOnline.

Jul 2020 - Sarm met Cpt. Ryan Bane [RB] while sailing with friends. His 47ft catamaran, Siren Song, is a Leopard 4700. SOURCE Telegraph

Oct 2020 - Sarm left RB and flew from Grenada to Malta, where she took up a job in a call centre in Malta. SOURCE Telegraph and Daily Mail

11 Feb 2021 - Sarm left Malta to return to the Virgin Islands. A friend of Sarm (“Flora the Sailing Chef”) said “I was sad to see her go and even more sad for Ryan. In my heart I prayed she would come back to him. Lo and behold a few months later she’s messaging me about ideas for cooking on boats! She was coming back to Ryan!!” SOURCE Telegraph. “Friends said the 41-year-old had been staying onboard the catamaran Siren Song with her American boyfriend, Ryan Bane, for "a couple of weeks". SOURCE BBC. “The decision to return to St. John was driven in part by her relationship with Bane, the friend said. Heslop now lives and works with Bane on Siren Song, a charter that he rents out, remaining on the vessel as its captain during tours.” SOURCE CrimeOnline.

1 Mar 2021, Monday - Sarm was chronicling her adventures on Instagram. A photo of RB’s dog on a beach posted on March 1st is said to have been her last post. SOURCE Telegraph

7 Mar 2021, Sunday - “There were text conversations happening right up until Sunday,” Wilson said, adding that he was not aware of anything out of the ordinary in her communications.” SOURCE CrimeOnline

7 Mar 2021, Sunday - Sarm spent the day working on Siren Song, entertaining and cooking for clients. SOURCE WestAtlanticMedia

7 Mar 2021, Sunday - Witnesses in another catamaran moored in Frank Bay [a group including husband and wife, DW and VH] say they saw Siren Song arrive in the bay that day and members in their group watched RB anchoring the vessel. Their boat was moored about 100ft away. Some members of the group saw RB and Sarm relaxing on the boat that afternoon and early evening. The group went to bed at about 10pm and didn't hear anything unusual during the night. Siren Song was in the same place the next morning and the dinghy was still on the boat. Siren Song is in a photo they took at about 8am on 8th March. (credit CrimeOnline/David Woody). SOURCE CrimeOnline.

7 Mar 2021, Sunday evening - DISCREPANCIES - Some reports say that, according to the coast guard, RB and Sarm sailed to French Bay on the island of St Thomas, over 6 miles away from Frank Bay, to eat at a restaurant. SOURCE VIFreePress and again here and The Sun. Other reports say they ate at a restaurant in Frank Bay, St John, SOURCE friend LT/Telegraph, friend AB/Daily Mail and BBC. Friend AB is also quoted in DM as saying “there seem to be many discrepancies in the timeline of what we have heard”. Friend LT also says "the couple would have taken a smaller boat to get to it [the shore]."


7 Mar 2021, Sunday 10:00pm - DISCREPANCIES - One report in The Sun says locals say they left the restaurant at 10pm in accordance with covid measures [island curfew]. A report in the Telegraph says RB told the coast guard that Sarm had gone to sleep at around 10pm. Another report says they had dinner at around 10pm and returned to the catamaran and watched a movie. Virgin Islands Daily News reports the coast guard as saying they had gone to sleep at around 10pm. The Daily Mail says RB went to sleep at around 10pm.


8 Mar 2021, Monday 1:00am
- "Friends of Ms Heslop told The Telegraph there was a dog walker on Frank's Bay, where the vessel was moored, who told them 'he heard a scream' at 1am. The witness came forward after friends set up the FindSarmHeslop Facebook page." SOURCE DailyMail.


8 Mar 2021, Monday 2:00am
- DISCREPANCIES - RB claims to have been woken by the sound of the anchor alarm , which sounds if the boat has drifted, and discovered Sarm was missing. All of her personal belongings, including phone and passport, were on the boat. These are in the possession of police. SOURCE DailyMail. A friend of Mr Bane's said … 'Ryan said his anchor alarm went off. He woke and found Sarm wasn't in bed. He got up and went around the boat but there was no sign of her.' SOURCE Daily Mail. A friend of RB's, Flora P, says "He called friends at about 2am to say he could not find her but did not immediately contact the authorities” SOURCE West Atlantic Media. RB's lawyer, David Cattie told CrimeOnline in an email that RB contacted Virgin Islands Police Department by phone at 2:30am and then took his dinghy to meet police on the shore and gave a statement and a photograph of Sarm. He also said that the coast guard searched the vessel that day at RB's request. The coast guard told Virgin Islands Daily News that her shoes and purse were also left on the boat, as well as stating "we do have indication that the person also reached out to 911,” in addition to calling the Coast Guard to report Heslop missing."


8 Mar 2021, Monday 11:46am
- RB alerted the US coast guard stationed at San Juan, to Sarm’s disappearance. "He reported that his girlfriend may have fallen” from the boat,” the spokesman said. SOURCE The Sun. Sarm's best friend AB told Fox News "I find it incredibly difficult to say that she fell from a catamaran that was moored about 100 feet away from shore in shallow water while the boat was anchored." Sarm's friend LT told the Telegraph "it would have been completely out of character for her to try and leave the yacht at night to get to shore or go swimming. “She's very level headed, you know, she's very smart. I just can't see why she would get out of bed to go for a swim between the hours of 10.30 and one o'clock in the morning. I know she wouldn't” "She was a very strong swimmer, but she wouldn’t have chosen to go for a dip at night, and certainly not if her boyfriend was asleep." Friend Flora P told West Atlantic Media "The last message I had from him was ‘I’m in pieces’,” “He is totally distraught. He doesn’t like being in the public spotlight, it’s not his style. He just pursues his dream of living quietly on a yacht with his dog. He really is so confused.” “You might go for a night out and be sitting in the pub with her and then she’d disappear, not even say ‘See you tomorrow.’ Then the next day she’d be back. It wasn’t unusual” “I wouldn’t put it past her if she’d gone up [on deck] for a cigarette and someone went past on a dinghy and said ‘Come and party with us,’” said FP, speaking from the island of St Barts yesterday where she was working as a chef on a charter yacht.”

8 Mar 2021, Monday - The coast guard told Virgin Islands Daily News - "Investigators conducted drift analysis from the vessel that was reportedly anchored 50 yards from shore in Frank Bay and launched boat forces “that commenced a surface search of the shoreline, adjacent islands, and all the waters around and out to sea from where the vessel was located,” In addition, “we had a Coast Guard helicopter searching that afternoon and the search continued throughout the night,” “Conditions were excellent as far as visibility, sea state, and there were no signs of anyone in the water.” Investigators reached out to marine traffic in the area, but there were “no reports of anyone being found in the water,” he said. On Tuesday, “upon sunset the search was called off from that standpoint.”

9 Mar 2021, Tuesday, evening - Witness DW (in the catamaran moored 100ft from Siren Song Sunday/Monday) learned that Sarm had gone missing. He expressed surprise that RB did not attempt to contact him. By this time the group had moved to another bay and they discovered that locals were trying to locate them with regards to Sarm's disappearance. "DW said he then spoke on the phone to a woman who said she was a friend of Heslop’s and RB’s. Shortly after they hung up, RB unexpectedly called DW. During that brief conversation, DW says, RB advised him to give a statement to police, and gave him a VIPD detective’s contact information. DW says he called that detective, who said they were busy with another case at that time, but would follow up within a day. The detective never called him back, DW said. CrimeOnline has not been able to reach that detective as of Thursday afternoon.

10 Mar 2021, Wednesday - V.I. Police said the Coast Guard has taken the lead in the case, but search efforts have been unsuccessful. SOURCE VIDailyNews

11 Mar 2021, Thursday - "V.I. Police are now the lead agency overseeing the investigation into Heslop’s disappearance, Castrodad said. Police said a dive crew continued the search for Heslop on Wednesday without result. Castrodad said the Coast Guard stands ready to assist in the search, but “at this point we haven’t received any additional information or evidence” that would trigger further action." SOURCE VIDailyNews

15 Mar 2021, Monday - Derima declined to comment on whether investigators suspect foul play, or whether Bane is cooperating with the investigation SOURCE VIFreePress

16 Mar 2021, Tuesday - "A spokesperson for the U.S. Virgin Islands police told CrimeOnline Tuesday afternoon that he did not know if detectives had searched the catamaran. He also said he was unaware if investigators were seeking to obtain CCTV footage from businesses and residences in the area of Heslop’s last known location."

16 Mar 2021, Tuesday - "Trevor Velinor, Virgin Islands Police Commissioner, said: “The Department employs competent and committed individuals who are relentlessly investigating all possible leads into Ms Heslop’s disappearance. While we do have some concerns regarding the details thus far, detectives are thoroughly investigating the circumstances surrounding her disappearance.” He added: “We are working within the parameters of the law to gather all items of value to the case. We thank those who have provided information and urge others to come forward with any information they can provide, no matter if it seems insignificant." SOURCE West Atlantic Media

17 Mar 2021, Wednesday - A spokesman for the USVI police department told The Daily Telegraph: ‘We have not been able to search the boat yet and will do this in due course. It is something that will be done eventually.’ RB's lawyer is quoted as saying "‘Mr Bane will not be sitting for any interviews. Mr Bane’s only hope is that Sarm is found alive and well. His thoughts and prayers are with Sarm and her family during this difficult time,’ a statement from his lawyers said. ‘Mr Bane has spent countless hours searching for Sarm and will continue to do so. Ryan is devastated that Sarm is missing.’

18 Mar 2021, Thursday - "Virgin Islands Police Department said officers were still "actively" searching for Ms Heslop, "passing out flyers and making regular checks of Cruz Bay and Red Hook to see if we see her". SOURCE BBC.
"So far the police have checked almost everywhere on the tiny 20 square mile island of St John which is the smallest of the three American Virgin Islands and have been unable to locate her. Police divers have been scouring the water along the coastline ever since she was reported missing. Police are investigating the possibility that she may have abandoned St John's for the neighboring island of St Thomas. Toby Derima, of the USVI police department, said there had been possible sightings of her since she was reported missing but nothing they have been able to confirm." SOURCE DailyMail. "Although U.S. citizens do not need a passport to travel between St. Thomas and St. John, you do need an official government-issued ID like a driver’s license. British citizens, such as Heslop, would need to produce a passport to take the ferry." SOURCE VIFreePress.

18 Mar 2021, Thursday -Siren Song is not currently available for charter. SOURCE VIFreePress.

Here is an additional discrepancy on March 8:

Virgin Islands Police Department (VIPD) spokesman Toby Derima said officers had performed an "initial land search" after speaking with Mr Bane and had instructed him to contact the US coastguard.

"Soon after reporting Ms Heslop missing, Mr Bane acquired the services of an attorney," he said.

"Upon his attorney's advice, Mr Bane exercised his constitutional right to remain silent and denied officers' requests to search the vessel."

Sarm Heslop: 'Nine-hour delay' in report of Caribbean disappearance
 
Here is an additional discrepancy on March 8:

Virgin Islands Police Department (VIPD) spokesman Toby Derima said officers had performed an "initial land search" after speaking with Mr Bane and had instructed him to contact the US coastguard.

"Soon after reporting Ms Heslop missing, Mr Bane acquired the services of an attorney," he said.

"Upon his attorney's advice, Mr Bane exercised his constitutional right to remain silent and denied officers' requests to search the vessel."

Sarm Heslop: 'Nine-hour delay' in report of Caribbean disappearance

I’d never begrudge someone for getting an attorney but seems premature to have his attorney making these statements for him. Wonder what he did to afford the boat? I know we can’t sleuth him so it’s a hypothetical question!
 
This reminds me of a case on Dateline .
Sad and very hinky.
Imo.

I am jumping in to the fire here, LOL..
I agree some shady stuff is/has happened. I get a Dateline vibe, as well as a little Dexter vibe going. Not the blood and guts part, but the political and deep pockets possibility. Shady as ever
 
If the Coast Guard searched the boat then my innocent partner theory goes out the window. I was thinking if he didn’t do it but won’t allow a search then maybe he has drugs on the boat. But you wouldn’t invite USCG on board if you’re a drug smuggler.
This makes me think of Isabella Hellman, where her husband was transporting stolen rare coins...perhaps without her knowledge until she discovered such. Though in that case as well, he killed her for her estate.
 
Here is an additional discrepancy on March 8:

Virgin Islands Police Department (VIPD) spokesman Toby Derima said officers had performed an "initial land search" after speaking with Mr Bane and had instructed him to contact the US coastguard.

"Soon after reporting Ms Heslop missing, Mr Bane acquired the services of an attorney," he said.

"Upon his attorney's advice, Mr Bane exercised his constitutional right to remain silent and denied officers' requests to search the vessel."

Sarm Heslop: 'Nine-hour delay' in report of Caribbean disappearance
I don't understand why LE instructed Bane to contact the Coast Guard. Wouldn't LE want to do that, to make sure it actually got done?

jmo
 
I think it’s a long shot that another boat came along and picked her up, but then I am curious as to why the anchor alarm went off and woke him up at 2am.
So far most of the events and timeline are being provided by Ryan Bane, including the anchor alarm going off at 2 am. I'd like to know what kind of warning system it is and if alarms are logged and traceable.
I don't understand why LE instructed Bane to contact the Coast Guard. Wouldn't LE want to do that, to make sure it actually got done?

jmo
Ryan Bane told LE that Sarm possibly fell overboard. Wouldn't that trigger a MOB (Man Overboard) protocol which would stipulate contacting the Coast Guard if Sarm wasn't found?

I'm ASA certified (monohull) and it's been decades since the courses but I do remember the captain constantly sounding the MOB call in the middle of the frickin' night. His point was the importance of knowing exactly what to do to recover the person from the water and also how to proceed if you can't spot the person.

Did Bane notify the other boats moored nearby? He had no idea if and *when* Sarm may have gone overboard so rallying other boats should have been a priority. Did he sound the whistle (3 longs)? Did he get in the dinghy to search?

Most of all why did he call LE first and not the Coast Guard? Heck, I believe he hired a lawyer before he notified the CG. To me that all says he didn't believe Sarm fell overboard. MOO.
 
In a statement issued Friday evening Virgin Islands Police Department said: “Soon after reporting Ms. Heslop missing, Mr. Bane acquired the services of an attorney. Upon his attorney’s advice, Mr. Bane exercised his constitutional right to remain silent and denied officers’ requests to search the vessel.”

USVI police spokesman Toby Derima added: "We would need to get a warrant to search the boat. We would need to show the court that we had probable cause to search the boat, as this is not yet a criminal case.

"We thought we could just ask Mr Bane to search the boat and he would say yes and he didn't. That is his right. Getting the search warrant would be the next step, however we are still searching, doing regular inspections of the areas and speaking to potential witnesses."
Sarm Heslop's boyfriend refusing to allow search of yacht from where she disappeared, police say
:mad:
 
Video interview Fox News Missing woman in Caribbean vanished from boat while boyfriend was asleep

19th March 2021

My transcript (may contain errors)


Fox: Exclusive new footage in the search for a woman missing in the Virgin Islands, shedding light on how close a catamaran, where she was last seen, was from shore. Her boyfriend says she was on the boat with him on March 7th, but when he woke up in the middle of the night she was gone. Jeff Jones who is assisting with the search for Heslop is back here, and Jeff what do we know today that we didn’t know yesterday?

JJ: You know we’ve been able to, with the help of professional drone power (?) Andrew Peter (?), and globaldirt, Help.NGO, providing some exclusive technology, to do aerial searches via map with literally a few thousand different pictures we can zoom in on that give us a unique perspective that you can’t necessarily see from the ground. Those drone searches are continuing. So far the search has proved unsuccessful but we are continuing to [inaudible]

Fox: Jeff, where is the boyfriend? Anyone seen him?

JJ: That’s a good question. I have been here at this location every day since the initial disappearance that Monday morning last week, and doing searches on the land, on the shore, with small craft, multiple scuba dives, snorkelling, as well as drone searches, and I’ve yet to see him. I was told he’s helping with the search but I’ve kind of been at the forefront of the search and have not seen him, so, that’s a good question.

Fox: Jeff is it true that his father is living on the boat and was the father living on the boat when this incident happened?

JJ: You know what, I assume so, in the simple fact that I’ve seen him there almost every day, dinghy’s been tied to the boat, that’s travelling back and forth. This morning I have not seen that dinghy but up until today every day I have, I spoke with him the initial day it happened, very lightly, um didn’t discuss anything as far as the disappearance, details, the facts, wasn’t my place, but I’ve seen him multiple times on the boat almost daily since.

Fox: Jeff what are people saying there on the island, that video you’re showing us as you point out is in shallow water, do you know the last time it was taken out to sea?

JJ: I do not know, as far as I know it’s been here every day. I spoke to another captain, he was moored up the night that she went missing, approximately 100-150 feet to his north-west, he was on the boat alone, he says he heard nothing, saw nothing and that that vessel was in the harbour when he got here on that Sunday morning, the day before.

Fox: Jeff I know this has been going on for several days, what does the weekend look like for you all in terms of the search?

JJ: We’re going to continue drone missions, continue tracking data, continue cooperating with the VIPD and providing them any resources we have available through partners of help.ngo, partners of globaldirt, to provide the technology their software and their professionals to analyse the maps and the information we provide during the search.
 
So far most of the events and timeline are being provided by Ryan Bane, including the anchor alarm going off at 2 am. I'd like to know what kind of warning system it is and if alarms are logged and traceable.

Ryan Bane told LE that Sarm possibly fell overboard. Wouldn't that trigger a MOB (Man Overboard) protocol which would stipulate contacting the Coast Guard if Sarm wasn't found?

I'm ASA certified (monohull) and it's been decades since the courses but I do remember the captain constantly sounding the MOB call in the middle of the frickin' night. His point was the importance of knowing exactly what to do to recover the person from the water and also how to proceed if you can't spot the person.

Did Bane notify the other boats moored nearby? He had no idea if and *when* Sarm may have gone overboard so rallying other boats should have been a priority. Did he sound the whistle (3 longs)? Did he get in the dinghy to search?

Most of all why did he call LE first and not the Coast Guard? Heck, I believe he hired a lawyer before he notified the CG. To me that all says he didn't believe Sarm fell overboard. MOO.

I’m certified also, and raced taught and coached cats, dinghies and sub-40 footers for years and yes, absolutely there are protocols and these are carefully scripted and logged — and would be automatic for this group. I’m not sure how much info we are likely to get on that yet but I share your surprise at how this “accident” apparently happened and what the actual vs narrated events were.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
64
Guests online
2,839
Total visitors
2,903

Forum statistics

Threads
603,386
Messages
18,155,536
Members
231,716
Latest member
Iwantapuppy
Back
Top