I so agree with you on most all of this.
Photo 1) Trader Joe food displayed -formula and Organic High Fiber O's cereal + a Tupperware of watermelon. Pretty much at eye level... She designed that photo.
Photo 2) Directly eye level -she hunched to get just the right angle with a plate of food yes in the foreground, fruit bowl behind, bananas to the right, and then, most bizarre-like -two stacked boxes of cereal, one on top of the other, on the counter. One looks to be TJ Organic Morning Lite, and the other is Organic Granny's Apple Granola cereal.
If where the sink is is like in the photo someone posted of Veloce kitchen, then it sincerely is BIZARRE that two cereal boxes would be stacked on on top the other like that on the island -i.e. it's not as if they were in the corner somewhere against a wall, if you know what I mean...
Here is where I have a different, perhaps more generous towards JB take: We know that the sink would have been perfectly clean, she perhaps lived upstairs at the complex, hot outside...watermelon is surely messy, hot day...combine cooling off babe with messy watermelon and a little cool water.
Like this:
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_vHa_VaemT...9A/8PoRYnna10o/Reuben+-+Kitchen+Sink+Bath.jpg
And here, could just as well be him and his sister... and there is even a cereal box in the background!
http://minirobertsclan.blogspot.com/2011/06/sister-bath-in.html
How about this boy: "Beau eating a popsicle in the kitchen sink.
I stuck him there because he was painting my kitchen walls with it other wise!!!"
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-k4stdyfjDKM/Tn4xQCs-baI/AAAAAAAAC4s/lNGCVXuDm9s/s400/IMG_9336.JPG
My point is that there does not have to be some nefarious reason for feeding your kid a very wet and messy food in the sink, unless you look for it. So let's just say that him eating in he sink is within normal range, and rational to some extent. I would do the same thing -and I am not a child abuser, nor OCD...
But here's where [the photo] goes awry...leading against innocence. If her focus were on cooling and soothing and feeding her hot son without a mess, then the focus of the photo would not be background food.
She staged this photo, is my strong opinion.
I take everything back if I find out that she was in a photography class, and working on a food composition assignment. LOL. But if that's the case, then focus, lighting, subject, everything is off. If the focus was to take a picture of her son, it might have come out like one of these...
http://thumbs.dreamstime.com/thumblarge_612/1308104347tfYZXK.jpg
http://us.123rf.com/400wm/400/400/w...0044/11010070-baby-girl-eating-watermelon.jpg
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_FpkTOcH-8RQ/TDMqL8SHf_I/AAAAAAAAAH0/1MJo3PwRFDU/s1600/darly.jpg
http://www.remakingchristine.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/My-buddy-Cam-eating-watermelon.jpg
(And I just LOVE this one
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-jLsGeZK6R0A/TrrSwCqNygI/AAAAAAAAAKU/-pDLEkIUDGg/s1600/Watermelon.jpg