WI WI - Georgia Weckler, 8, Fort Atkinson, 1 May 1947

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Summary: Georgia Weckler vanished near the end of her family's long driveway near their farm outside Fort Atkinson. She had gotten a ride home from school. Neighbors reported seeing a suspicious black-colored four-door 1936 Ford sedan in the area earlier that afternoon, but the vehicle was believed to have driven off around the same time the third-grader got home from school. Authorities came to suspect that a sexual predator kidnapped and harmed Georgia.

636217328320071725-Georgia-Weckler.jpeg


http://www.postcrescent.com/story/n...ho-they-wisconsins-missing-children/98347286/
 
I've updated the website http://georgiajeanweckler-pdf.weebly.com/ with the latest on Georgia Jean. Talked with Det. Leah Meyer and also someone who was writing the article on the search at Sennett's hideout. On page 218 is the link to the news story they just ran. The pdf website is better than the other one I have which is a docx, the other adds 3 pages to the length, but it still has the same information, so the index is off some. So this is current to what I have found, maybe I'll be able to have a closure article sometime.
 
I've updated the website http://georgiajeanweckler-pdf.weebly.com/ with the latest on Georgia Jean. Talked with Det. Leah Meyer and also someone who was writing the article on the search at Sennett's hideout. On page 218 is the link to the news story they just ran. The pdf website is better than the other one I have which is a docx, the other adds 3 pages to the length, but it still has the same information, so the index is off some. So this is current to what I have found, maybe I'll be able to have a closure article sometime.

I am hopeful you will be able to write that very article.

With the science of today, they will hopefully find things in that 'fox hole', that they overlooked so many years ago when they retrieved those ashes.
 
Odd question, early in the thread a leg bone was found along with purse and shoe. Wecklers stated that they did not belong to daughter. So - was there another child missing during that time frame?
 
Georgia Jean Weckler
  • georgia_jean_weckler_1.jpg
  • georgia_jean_weckler_2.jpg
  • weckler_georgia3.jpg
  • georgia_jean_weckler_5.jpg
  • georgia_jean_weckler_6.jpg
Georgia, circa 1947; Edward Gein; Buford Sennett in 1947

  • Missing Since 05/01/1947
  • Missing From Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
  • ClassificationNon-Family Abduction
  • SexFemale
  • RaceWhite
  • Date of Birth 01/28/1939 (81)
  • Age 8 years old
  • Height and Weight 4'3, 65 - 75 pounds
  • Clothing/Jewelry Description A light blue t-shirt with a pink buttoned sweater over it, a blue skirt with a red moon or flower pattern, blue jeans under the skirt, rubber boots or brown moccasin-type shoes with reddish-colored composition soles, and a brown flowered head scarf.
  • Distinguishing Characteristics Caucasian female. Blonde hair, brown eyes. Georgia has a growth on one heel.
Details of Disappearance
Georgia was last seen near her farm home in rural Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin at approximately 3:30 p.m. on May 1, 1947.

A neighbor gave her a ride part of the way home from the Oakland Center school, where she was a third-grader, and dropped her off at the entrance to the half-mile-long driveway leading up to her home. Georgia told the neighbor that she might go into the woods and pick some flowers for a May Day basket before going home.

She and her siblings normally rode their bicycles to school, but it had rained recently and the ground had been muddy, so Georgia's father drove his children to school the morning of her disappearance. Georgia was released half an hour before her older brother and sister, and found a ride with the neighbor, who had gone to the school to pick up her own child.

The neighbor saw Georgia collect a large bundle of letters from her family's mailbox and start walking up the driveway, but she never arrived at her house. She has never been heard from again and the mail she was carrying at the time of her disappearance has never been found.

Georgia's mother was initially not concerned when the child did not arrive home; she assumed Georgia was with her father. The parents began searching at 6:00 p.m. when Georgia's father arrived at home without his daughter.

Witnesses reported seeing a dark-colored, possibly black, four-door 1936 Ford sedan with a gray plastic spotlight in the vicinity that afternoon. The car vanished at the same time Georgia did, and deep tire tracks were later found on the road, as if a vehicle had pulled out fast. The car was being driven by a blond man, 20 to 25 years old.

This man is the prime suspect in Georgia's presumed abduction. He has never been identified, though many individuals were questioned over the years. Several witnesses reported seeing a young girl struggling and pleading with a man inside a similar vehicle in Fort Atkinson shortly after Georgia vanished. The child inside the car has not been confirmed to be Georgia, but she closely resembled her.

At first investigators believed Georgia had been kidnapped for ransom, as her father was a public official and a man of means. Days passed and no ransom demands were made, however.

Authorities now believe Georgia was taken by a sexual predator. Curiously, prior to her disappearance, Georgia had made several remarks indicating that she especially feared being kidnapped.

Buford Sennett, a convicted rapist and murderer who had just started serving a life sentence in prison, confessed to Georgia's murder in the fall of 1947 (photo). He claimed that he and a companion he refused to name had kidnapped her for ransom purposes and given her some sleeping pills and she had accidentally overdosed and died.

Sennett said he had tossed Georgia's remains into the Blue River near the town of Blue River, Wisconsin. A search of the river turned up no sign of Georgia, however. Some ashes were found in the woods near his former hideout and were subjected to forensic testing, as a woman reported witnessing Sennett burn Georgia's body. No clues were gained as a result of the testing.

Sennett was never charged in connection with Georgia's case and police are not certain whether he was involved. He later recanted his confession and afterwards maintained that he had nothing to do with Georgia's case.

He was paroled in 1974, but arrested again for the sexual assault of two young girls, and in 1987 was sentenced to twenty years in prison. This sentence ran consecutively to the remainder of his 1947 rape/murder sentence, since he violated parole by being rearrested.

Sennett died in a Wisconsin prison in 2008. He was not the only person to confess Georgia's kidnapping and murder; a number of other individuals, including a convicted murderer from Nebraska, confessed over the years. Nothing could be proven against any of them and most of them later recanted.

Georgia's case received additional attention ten years after she vanished, in 1957, when authorities in Plainfield, Wisconsin arrested Edward Theodore Gein for murdering a local female tavern keeper. A photograph of Gein is posted with this case summary.

Investigators uncovered a gruesome scene at his farm which is still legendary; many body parts and items such as lampshades made from human skin were located. Almost all of them turned out to be from local cemeteries; Gein confessed only to the murders of two tavern keepers. He was declared insane and sent to a mental hospital, where he died in 1984.

Gein is considered a possible suspect in Georgia's disappearance and also in the disappearance of Evelyn Hartley, who was abducted from La Crosse, Wisconsin in 1953. Neither of them have ever been found. They do not fit the profile for Gein's known victims; both of the people he killed were middle-aged women. Gein also does not match the description of the man believed to be Georgia's abductor, but he did own a black 1937 Ford.

Georgia's disappearance remains unsolved.

Source:

Georgia Jean Weckler – The Charley Project
 
Summary: Georgia Weckler vanished near the end of her family's long driveway near their farm outside Fort Atkinson. She had gotten a ride home from school. Neighbors reported seeing a suspicious black-colored four-door 1936 Ford sedan in the area earlier that afternoon, but the vehicle was believed to have driven off around the same time the third-grader got home from school. Authorities came to suspect that a sexual predator kidnapped and harmed Georgia.

636217328320071725-Georgia-Weckler.jpeg


Who are they? Wisconsin's missing children

Great article and very informative. Thanks for sharing!

Bufort Sennett and Charles McClelland are named the primary suspects in many sources. (***see below re: Ed Gein). There are quite a bit of similarities between the two. Both of them:

*confessed and later recanted
*had an unnamed accomplice
*were familiar with the area
*claimed to kidnap for ransom
*affiliation with a 1936 black Ford sedan that was seen in the area that day.
*provided information that was never revealed to media (including description of Georgia's dress/clothing)

***Ed Gein is excluded as a potential here because aside from the victim not fitting his victimology and MO, was there any valid evidence pointing to Gein, aside from speculation and ownership of a 1936 black Ford sedan? IMO, I am sure he is not involved in both Georgia's and Evelyn Hartley's disappearances as other Websleuther's have previously stated.

Sennett's accomplice in other crimes (Robert Winslow) was cleared from involvement of Georgia's case. However, it also appears there are many discrepancies suggesting McClellan and Sennett were not accomplices (unless they were lying) as their stories don't jive. McClellan claims she was strangled and buried. Sennett claims she died of an overdose of pills, shotgun wound/s, and was thrown in the river. (His house was also investigated for burials). There is no evidence of any of these claims.

Aside from confessions (that were later recanted) coming from the mouths of the accused, was there any credible evidence or sightings connecting them to the scene? Were there witness accounts placing either of them there?

According to LE, the black Ford seen in the vicinity that day was of a particular make and model that was always manufactured in the color black so it wasn't uncommon. All the suspects (***including Ed Gein) had ties to a vehicle like this.

Looking at the photos of where she lived, there was nothing around. Who would be out there loitering in no-man's-land and why? The possibilities are that whoever kidnapped her either:

*knew her, her routine, and where she lived, knowing it would be easy to kidnap her. She unexpectedly had a ride home that day. But despite the fact that she didn't ride her bike or take the bus as she typically did, she would still arrive home at approximately the same time every day where the kidnapper could have waited for her. This could relate to both the sexual predator theory and the ransom theory. However, it is safe to assume that ransom was not the motive as it appears the Weckler's were never contacted for money.

*or it was a opportunist that just randomly happened to be driving by, similar to how both suspects claimed they were in the area.

Many links to sites regarding this case are dead or unavailable for me to view so apologies if these points have been previously addressed. Also a special thanks to John Weckler for the informative and comprehensive collection of information regarding Georgia's case via PDF. May you and your family find closure some day, and everyone finally be at peace.

Georgia Jean Weckler - pdf

11011954 Lincoln Journal Star Pg 15 Col 1-3 - Newspapers.com

41
Misc Article - October 31, 1954
ADMITS KILLING' 'CHILD, 8, WHO VANISHED IN '47Lifer Says He Helped Kidnap Girl
Jefferson, Wis., Oct. '31 [Special]-Sheriff Rudolph Reichert of Jefferson county, tonight disclosed that a murderer serving life inthe Nebraska state penitentiary has confessed he kidnaped and killed Georgia Jean Weckler, 8, a Wisconsin farmer's daughterwho vanished mysteriously 7 years ago. The sheriff said Charles McClelland, 25, of Booneville, Mo., related he and anaccomplice kidnaped the girl for ransom, May 1, 1947.



42
Arrest jogs recall of 1947 murder
By Richard W. JaegerRegional reporterJEFFERSON

Rudy Reichert, former Jefferson County sheriff, dusted off his yellowing scrapbook when he heard that BufordSennett was being sent back to prison for sexually assaulting two juvenile girls. Sennett, 62, who was sentenced Jan. 27 for thesexual assault, has been sentenced to life in 1947 for the murder of Robert Carlson, a UW Madison medical student. He was paroled in 1974 after serving 27 years of that sentence. Also in 1947, Sennett was at the center of one of Jefferson County's most publicized crimes when he confessed to kidnapping Georgia Jean Weckler, 8, from the driveway of her rural Fort Atkinson farm.Reichert was a deputy sheriff at that time and took part in the investigation. Sennett later recanted his confession, and the caseremains unsolved. The Weckler girl never was found. Two Jefferson County detectives recently interviewed Sennett at the DodgeCorrectional Center in Waupun. He talked to them but repeatedly denied any involvement in the Weckler disappearance. Since his parole, Sennett had been living in Appleton. Robert Winslow, his accomplice in the Carlson killing, also was paroled in 1974 andlives in the Union Grove area. Sennett's recent arrest rekindled some strong memories of the Weckler kidnapping for Reichert andother old timers in Jefferson County. "We thought we had the thing solved when Sennett confessed to doing it back then," Reichertsaid, thumbing the frayed pages of a scrapbook put together by his wife, Marie, that contains newspaper clippings of the Wecklerinvestigation. Reichert initially doubted Sennett's involvement in the Weckler kidnapping, and he still does. "It wasn't his kind ofcrime fooling with little girls," said Reichert, acknowledging the recent arrest may alter that analysis. "There also was a gap in hisstory about his plans to hold the youngster for ransom. He couldn't have known she would be picked up at school that day and noton the bus," he added. Reichert recalls going to Waupun with former District Attorney Francis Garity to interview Sennett in prison. "He said just enough on that first visit to lead us to believe he knew something about the Weckler case. After several othervisits by Garity, he confessed, giving all kinds of details," Reichert said. Garity, now deceased, was convinced by the confessionand arranged to have Sennett taken from prison to a Wisconsin River bridge near Blue River where he said he had dumped theWeckler girl's body the same area where Carlson's body was recovered. Reichert took part in that Blue River bridge search,spending 10 days on the icy river assisting divers probing for a body they never found. "I always figured he conned us into takinghim there so he could try to escape, but we had him too heavily guarded," Reichert said. Sennett said he had an accomplice inWeckler's kidnapping, but he wouldn't name the person. The accomplice, he said, accidently gave the youngster an overdose ofsleeping pills that killed her. There was speculation that Winslow was the accomplice, but Garity and others, ruled out the formerOwen native because he was unfamiliar with the county. Garity
Same information with some missing pagey continued to believein Sennett's involvement even after the recanted confession. A former law partner said Garity based that belief on information provided by Sennett that only the kidnapper would have known. "Sennett told Garity he saw a farmer driving down the lane at theWeckler farm and described the odd way the fellow turned his head to look about, almost as if it were on a swiveled Well, Garitytook a farmer neighbor of the Wecklers over to their place and had him drive down the lane and told him to look back as he drovethe guy's head swiveled just as Sennett had said. That was enough to convince Garity," the former law partner, who asked not to be identified, said. Reichert's scrapbook contains stories about other clues that popped up long after Sennett's confession,including one about a diary found on a Janesville bus describing incidents that corresponded to the youngster's disappearance.Reichert recalls checking clues of his own after he took office as sheriff m 1951, including a trip to a Nebraska prison. Nebraskaconvict Charles McClelland confessed he had buried the child in a shallow grave in Northern Illinois. "We went and dug around but found nothing," Reichert said. Ed Gein, the notorious grave robber and murderer from Plainfield, also was among thosechecked early in the 1950s. Gein drove a black 1937 Ford similar to a car seen near the Weckler farm. "Of course, I think the onlycolor Ford they made back then was black," Reichert said. The last active look at the Weckler file was in 1983, Sheriff KeithMueller said. "We really didn't turn anything up other than talking to some people who said they heard other people talking aboutthe case. Other than ' that we've received reports off and on from other states concerning the finding of skeletons of children,"Mueller said. "Sennett's arrest has caused us to take another look at the Weckler case," said Richard Wellner, sergeant ofdetectives for the Jefferson County sheriff's department. "After all, it is still an open case."
 
Last edited:

Georgia Jean Weckler​

Updated: Jan 12, 2022

c6795b_0e43a54420eb4d7e88c98545d9156274~mv2.jpg


Georgia Jean Weckler, was 8 years old at the time of her disappearance. She was last seen on May, 1st 1947 when Mrs. Carl Floerke, a neighbor and mother of a fellow student at Oakland Center school, dropped Georgia Jean off at the end of her 1/2 mile long driveway which lead to the family farm.

The neighbor saw Georgia collect the mail and walk down the lane leading to her family's farm. Georgia had mentioned that she had plans to pick flowers for a May basket in the nearby woods.

Georgia’s mother, Eleanor, initially thought that Georgia was with her father and wasn't concerned when she didn't show up after school. When George Weckler arrived home at 6:00pm they quickly realized that Georgia was actually missing, and it was at that time that they began searching and then contacted the Jefferson County Sheriff’s office.

Word spread quickly about the missing child and that first night over 200 volunteers searched the nearby 20 acre wooded area for 5 hours but sadly, nothing was found.

As the investigation unfolded over the next few days, It was reported by witnesses that a dark-colored, four-door 1936 Ford sedan driven by a 20-25 year old blonde male was spotted in the vicinity around the time of Georgia's disappearance. Deep tire tracks were found. It was reported that witnesses saw a young girl resembling Georgia, struggling with a man inside a very similar vehicle in Fort Atkinson shortly after Georgia vanished. The man has never been identified, and is considered to be a prime suspect in this case. Many individuals have been questioned over the years.

Numerous leads have been followed up on during the past seventy years, but sadly, no suspect has ever formally been arrested and no remains ever have been found.

Georgia's case received attention ten years after she vanished, in 1957, when authorities in Plainfield, Wisconsin arrested Edward Theodore Gein for murdering a local female tavern keeper.

Gein is considered a possible suspect in Georgia's disappearance and also in the disappearance of Evelyn Hartley, who was abducted from La Crosse, Wisconsin in 1953. Neither of them have ever been found.

 
This would have been the right era for ransom kidnappings. Did the Wecklers ever recieve ransom demands? If not, that leads me to believe that McClelland was lying. I think it's pretty obvious Ed Gein can be ruled out based on his preference of victims/corpses.

Edited to add: Wait, is this case why I know the name Buford Sennett? Or is there another case Sennett is connected to? Can someone jog my memory?
 
There is a new case in NAMUS of a child's bones found in Wisconsin in October of 1959. If the estimated PMI is accurate then it is not likely Georgia, but the remains were that of a 4-9 year old child with blonde hair. The sex is listed as "unsure" but in the notes it mentions that the hair was consistent with a girl's style in 1959. The location where the remains were found is about 70 miles from Fort Atkinson.

 
There is a new case in NAMUS of a child's bones found in Wisconsin in October of 1959. If the estimated PMI is accurate then it is not likely Georgia, but the remains were that of a 4-9 year old child with blonde hair. The sex is listed as "unsure" but in the notes it mentions that the hair was consistent with a girl's style in 1959. The location where the remains were found is about 70 miles from Fort Atkinson.

The Daily Telegram Wed, Oct 07, 1959, Page 7 (link: Newspapers.com) reports that a woman found the girl's head on October 4th, 1959 and searchers found nine teeth the next day. The paper also reported that a man who lived in the area saw a vehicle parked near a culvert back in May of 1959 with a small hand protruding from the car. He reported it to the police but by the time they got there the car was gone. Other body parts were found near the culvert after the search in October.​

We can assume the police never searched the area back in May or they would have found the other body parts of the young girl who the paper reported as seven or eight years old and was believed to have died two to six months before the head and other body parts were found.​


A later news report in The Sheboygan Press, Fri, Oct 09, 1959, Page 9 (source: Newspapera.com) stated some of the blonde girl's bones had been fractured with the police chief stating she was a murder victim. A partial license number of the vehicle was given to the police by the farmer who saw the car with the girl's hand back in May.​

The Stevens Point Journal, Mon, Oct 05, 1959, Page 1 stated" Additional remains of a little blonde girl who had been butchered and flung into underbrush along a suburban road were assembled today."​

 

The Daily Telegram Wed, Oct 07, 1959, Page 7 (link: Newspapers.com) reports that a woman found the girl's head on October 4th, 1959 and searchers found nine teeth the next day. The paper also reported that a man who lived in the area saw a vehicle parked near a culvert back in May of 1959 with a small hand protruding from the car. He reported it to the police but by the time they got there the car was gone. Other body parts were found near the culvert after the search in October.​

We can assume the police never searched the area back in May or they would have found the other body parts of the young girl who the paper reported as seven or eight years old and was believed to have died two to six months before the head and other body parts were found.​


A later news report in The Sheboygan Press, Fri, Oct 09, 1959, Page 9 (source: Newspapera.com) stated some of the blonde girl's bones had been fractured with the police chief stating she was a murder victim. A partial license number of the vehicle was given to the police by the farmer who saw the car with the girl's hand back in May.​

The Stevens Point Journal, Mon, Oct 05, 1959, Page 1 stated" Additional remains of a little blonde girl who had been butchered and flung into underbrush along a suburban road were assembled today."​

I would say if this info is true, that rules out Georgia. How awful that they didn't search after that was called in!
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
173
Guests online
324
Total visitors
497

Forum statistics

Threads
609,440
Messages
18,254,224
Members
234,654
Latest member
Cheyenne233
Back
Top