Ghostwheel
Pyrrhonist
I see what you are saying, though my argument is not "well, anything is possible". I'm hoping that people can see that someone's "what is probable" and someone else's "what is probable" don't have to be the same. My probable does not include Maddie being the target. Doesn't mean I'm right, I just haven't seen any facts that proves she was so I reserve judgment. ATM, I think it was just the house. That could change next week when something else is released, because I originally thought Xana (for reasons I won't go into).But the problem is there are no facts here, we're working with what is probable and what most likely happened based on the evidence. Your argument is that 'well, anything is possible'. True, but that doesn't get us anywhere. It's also possible in the realm of imagination that he accidentally hit the wrong house, but that's highly unlikely to say the least. We can work with only what we know. Also, I might be wrong but I vaguely remember the documents mentioning that Dylan sent messages to all the roommates prior to the texts themselves but it was only Bethany who replied.
The point I was making is that I have seen posters make statements like "We can ALL see this is the only possible *whatever*" and nope, I don't see that as being the only possible *whatever* at all. And I don't think I am alone, but that is again, JMO. People get to have opinions. But we ALL get to have opinions and quite honestly, I would not mind a well thought out "They got the wrong house" theory. I'd like to nurture that a bit more. IMHO.