- Joined
- Oct 21, 2009
- Messages
- 58,006
- Reaction score
- 173,950
Bumping for this unidentified woman and wondering if she has a family that is still waiting for her to come back home.
Well... I think that Horseshoe Harriet was probably murdered in the winter based on her clothing (lots of wool, lots of layers). Roxane was last seen with a brown leather jacket, and Annie was found in a brown leather jacket. In fact, Roxane was wearing high-heeled boots when she was last seen and Annie was found in high-heeled boots; the only difference is the colour of the boots.
Also Hansen DID say she was a topless dancer or prostitute, I don't know Roxane's profession but she had an alias (Which is something dancers and prostitutes have, but doesn't necessarily mean she was either of those.)
The date last seen vs. the date found is the only problem. She had only been missing about a week when she was reported, which makes it unlikely that they had the date last seen wrong.
Roxane's DNA tests are not complete. Annie is in CODIS and Harriet's DNA tests are not complete yet. I know it's wishful thinking on my part but I'd be surprised if she isn't Annie.
Have there been any cases where the medical examiner was off on date of death by that much of a leap?
Anyone suppose this new NamUs MP might be Horseshoe Harriet, or Eklutna Annie?
https://www.findthemissing.org/en/cases/28953/0
.
I wish they had better pictures of the jewelry, especially the cuff. I'd love to know if there are any hallmarks on it and what it looks like cleaned up. (looking at where the bezel wire is attached to the cuff can tell a lot about the skill of the jewelry maker, which could help indicate where it was made)
Also I have another question if anyone gets this in the article it says she was originally thought to be Roxanne Easlund, how was that ruled out? I googled it but not much info out there. Was Roxannes body found elsewhere?
Im looking at all the names suggested to see what I think
Angela Meeker - Maybe too young, went missing when she was 13, does match up in that it was exactly a year since she went missing to when the body was found, but still maybe too young at the age guess was 16 - 25
Megan Emerick - Went missing 7 years before the body was found. Fits in the age though as she would have been about 22. From Alaska.
But also her disappearance seems like she was kidnapped and probably killed soon after. Doesnt seem like she would randomly run away for
6 years previous to the year gap where the body was killed/found.
Cynthia Gastelle - Her remains have been found
Eileen Hynson - Age fits, 19 when missing, so 21ish when the Doe would have been killed. Right height. From California like the police thought.
The only suspicious thing I see though is she had no reason to vanish if she was on the way to a bridal party dress fitting. She would have to have run off for a couple years before being killed.
Andria Bailey. - The age is right and the time she went missing to when the body was found is right, about a year, Maybe a little tall?
From Washington. Wouldnt rule her out I guess. Closest so far.
Mary Kathleen Thill - Looks alot like the original image.
From Alaska, age would be about right, went missing maybe a couple years too early, Hansen is suspected. Probably a victim of his but maybe not this Jane Doe.
Elaine Kwiatkowski - Yeah, seems like she died in the ocean with the others.
Simone Stephanie Ridinger - Age and missing date seem to fit, possibly a year too early but close, and height matches. And also the note about wearing lots of jewellery. Story is odd, especially about the man who picked her up saying she was in the back of a car. If she was hitchiking around she could have made her way eventually to Alaska, not impossible. Definite possibly.
Elaine Robertson - Dates fit right. Went missing a year before the remains were found. Age is right. But i think definitely too tall. And the details of her disappearance seem to not fit.
Kerry Graham - initial thought was wow, so many similarities! The jewellery, the height, the age, the time she went missing, maybe a bit late as the body was about a year old, red hair, seemed to be a bit of a runaway and the type to start working as a dancer, California,
Says she went missing with a friend 'Francine Marie Trimble' Couldnt find anything on her through google?
I think this one is the best yet. Has anyone sent her info in or heard anything?
Mary Frances Gregory - Seems too far out of the way, more likely is the guy she was travelling with killed her I think. Though height, age and time seem right nothing much else seems to fit
Also seems odd her family believe she suffered memory loss after her disappearance? how on earth would they know that.
So in conclusion my top guesses are definitely Kerry Graham and Andria Bailey and then also possibly throw Simone Ridinger in there
Anyone suppose this new NamUs MP might be Horseshoe Harriet, or Eklutna Annie?
Roxane Easland (and 2 recons of Eklutna Annie)
https://www.findthemissing.org/en/cases/28953/0
![]()
![]()
![]()
She was LKA only a month before Eklutna Annie was found, and about 4 years before Horseshoe Harriet was found.
Unless the postmortem interval for EA (about 1 year) is inaccurate, she was probably not missing long enough to be EA. But I do see a pretty good resemblance in some respects to both recons.
I wonder how long it will take the tip and/or DNA testing to be processed and done so we and the family will know for sure. Roxane just fits so well. Hansen even admitted to her murder, but her body was never recovered. I wonder why they never thought to match it up before? HH I can see being Andrea Altiery, the admitted other victim of his whose body was never recovered.
Which also makes me wonder, and granted I haven't been able to find much on it, did LE ever check out the other X locations on his map? 12 bodies were recovered iirc, but there were many other spots marked off. I read somewhere that one theory is that Megan Emerick (who was excluded as EA) and Mary Thill may be buried in two of those spots.